1. Red Hook Lobster Pound
8.9
284 Van Brunt St (btwn Verona St & Visitation Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Red Hook · 171 tips and reviews
Robyn: Awesome lobster rolls and Mac n cheese!
Port Lau: Lobster roll is a must get! Definitely get a lobster mac and cheese on the side! There's no such thing as too full when it comes to lobster!
Rachel W.: Lobster rolls, lemonade (some of the best in NYC), and the potato salad are all super legit. Love their new expanded menu.
IrmaZandl ZandlSlant: Great spot for lunch or quick snack. salmon tartare with pickled jalapeño was amazing and lobster rolls are yummy. wine and beer with Rose on tap. Fish store up front makes space smell fishy!
Public House Wine: The newly opened Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co. is officially serving sustainable and delicious lobster rolls, ceviches and fish tacos -- and pad thai made with kelp, instead of noodles.
Jaimee Estreller: Came here on a rainy day for brunch, so no wait for a table! Had the market fish sandwich, which was amazing and also shared the special - buttermilk biscuits with scrambled eggs and lobster gravy!
3. Luke's Lobster
8.7
11 Water St (Under the BK Bridge), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · DUMBO · 51 tips and reviews
Mia Jacobucci: Soooo good!!! We got it through a deal and tried the lobster, crab and shrimp rolls. I couldn't decide which I liked better!
F. Bastard: This is the best lobster roll I've ever eaten. And I've eaten a lot of lobster rolls. Fresh, lightly toasted bun: check. Abundant chunks of luscious, pristine lobster: check. Easy on the mayo, too.
Martin Jonasson: Excellent fast food! Go for the lobster roll and just enjoy it and life in general close to the Brooklyn Bridge.
4. Randazzo's Clam Bar
8.1
2017 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 96 tips and reviews
Natalya: Start off with Loster Bisque, the fresh oysters anytime of the year, steamed female lobster, yumm fried zucchini on the side mussel di zuppas great as well and so is the stuffed lobster, just everythi
The Corcoran Group: A landmark restaurant serving fresh seafood! Get the Lobster Bisque & Spicy Crab, then the Combo with Hot Sauce or the Cold Seafood Platter and a side of biscuits.
Public House Wine: A lowbrow seafood joint that's been ravely reviewed Fresh clams , lobster fra diavolo and last-meal-status $6 lobster bisque are well worth the trip to Sheepshead bay.
5. Sea Wolf
8.8
19 Wyckoff Ave (Troutman St.), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Bushwick · 58 tips and reviews
Rami Haykal-Manning: Great lobster roll, well seasoned fries and salad. Open for Breakfast, Lunch and dinner. Good addition to the neighborhood
James Kiernan: Great vibe and deliciously decadent lobster roll. Lots of open space for families. Also dig the 80s sk8 decor!
Will Scholl: Shrimp and chourico (homemade chicken sausage) was flavored impeccably. Lobster roll was delicious. Our server, Lee, was so friendly and accommodating. Excellent all around.
6. Brooklyn Crab
8.6
24 Reed St (btwn Van Brunt & Conover St), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Red Hook · 271 tips and reviews
Sean Bartnik: Great view from the deck. Seared scallops w/ bacon & kale were great, as was mac n cheese w/ lobster. Still working some kinks out with the service. A little pricey, but good food & good times.
The New Yorker Manager: "[F]resh cold oysters and perfectly steamed lobster, eaten in the open, relatively salty air, with a killer view of New York Harbor." Shauna Lyon on Brooklyn Crab (8/27/2012): http://nyr.kr/R50GAo
Lindsey: The crab legs and lobster were phenomenal and the views are great from the roof deck!
8. Nick's Lobster House
7.5
2777 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Southeastern Brooklyn · 416 tips and reviews
Dylan Nord: really enjoyed the calamari and lobster sandwich, well priced compared to others in NYC
Johnny Tito: Whole lobster, lobster bisque and grilled shrimp Caesar salad are very good.
Henry: The BEST Lobster house in Brooklyn!!! Scenery is wonderful, food is exquisite and the pricing is VERY reasonable!!!!
9. Surf Bar
7.5
139 N 6th St (btwn Bedford & Berry St.), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Williamsburg · 157 tips and reviews
Jennifer Jenncity Arroyo: Lobster Roll! Staff was great to us!
Denise S: Sand floor, tiki stuff, boards... and a great NY lobster roll :)
Drew Murphy: good lobster rolls, cool place to hang
10. The River Café
8.8
1 Water St (at Brooklyn Bridge), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · DUMBO · 164 tips and reviews
🍙 allie 🍙: Apple crumb foie gras, lobster, and sea scallops were amazing! Finish off with Brooklyn Bridge dessert.
Eater: The prix-fixe menu includes wagyu steak tartare, poached lobster, and mushroom Wellington. And, of course, River Cafe offers unparalleled views of the Brooklyn Bridge and downtown Manhattan. Read more.
Duygu AKTAN: 1st time. We had rabbit, steak tartare, lobster, steak, brooklyn bridge shaped desert and pistachio semifreddo. Not even the food can beat the view, which is not bad. Do try, maybe just once.
11. Soco
8.2
509 Myrtle Ave (btwn Grand Ave & Ryerson St), Brooklyn, NY
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · Clinton Hill · 174 tips and reviews
Stevie C.: Try buttermilk chicken & red velvet waffles, shrimp & lobster grits and the mac & cheese!! Everything tastes amazing. Sangria, red lemonade & Georgia peach are awesome cocktails to compliment the food
LadyENY: The lobster, shrimp & cheddar grits are perfect but I wish there was 2 more shrimp and a little more grits. Also try the soco sangria!
Feece B: Awesome place. Good service and great food. What made me fall in love with this place was the music. The lobster, shrimp, and grits was awesome just wasn't enough food for me.
12. The Black Swan
7.6
1048 Bedford Ave (btwn Lafayette Ave & Clifton Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Gastropub · Bedford-Stuyvesant · 209 tips and reviews
Fazeela Mohammed: LPT -lobster pork belly sandwich and bloody Mary with side car
Nay White: MAC AND CHEESE W LOBSTER AND BACON !!!!
Gothamist: This spot is particularly adept at furnishing their already perfectly suitable mac n' cheese with tasty extras like sun dried tomatoes, jalapeños, fresh lobster meat, bacon, etc. Read more.
13. Nathan's Famous
8.0
1310 Surf Ave (at Stillwell Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Hot Dog Joint · Coney Island · 356 tips and reviews
Astoriawinediva: Coney Island Nathans is a must! Love sitting outside w cold beer & people watching. Ok u dig the dogs here, but on Coney Island menu they have a lobster sandwich to die for- move over Luke's - delish!
Anthea Pena: 96yr legend. long lines but worth it. Try lobster rolls, cheesesteaks & burgers but dogs are a must
Jennifer Neapolitan: Lobster soup in winter, hot dog plain in summer or any time
14. Verde on Smith
7.2
216 Smith St (at Butler), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Boerum Hill · 57 tips and reviews
Pat McGann: Best Lobster Bisque Soup. Seriously.
Melody Gambino: the all you can drink brunch is awesome, and their lobster bisque came in first place in the Smith St Soup Fest this year!
Jay Blessed: The service was great and so. To was the food. If you are a seafood lover, have the lobster feast - terrific!
15. Shipwreck
8.8
1047 Bedford Ave (Greene), Brooklyn, NY
Fish Market · Bedford-Stuyvesant · 6 tips and reviews
Christina Xu: Super fresh, restaurant-grade seafood. They've got everything from a live lobster tank to fresh, prepared food.
Martin Bringmann: Lobster rolls and crab cakes are sooooo good!!
Alice Q: They go to the market every morning to supply their fish and you can tell. They stand by their product with a guarantee of freshness. Plus locally owned and operated.