bethanne: The Pastrami with whitefish and Riesling sauerkraut on pumpernickel is quite possibly the best tasting thing I've ever eaten. Ever. Ever ever.
Real Cheap Eats: "The baked salmon salad works really well with a warm, toasty bagel; in one bite, the combination is cool, warm, crunchy and soft. The salad tastes fresh and will satisfy any salmon lover." Read more.
Time Out New York: Try the Peter Shelsky. A spin on the bagel-and-lox format with 3 kinds of fish—Eastern Gaspé salmon, soft sable & sweet pickled herring in cream sauce. It’s one of our #100best dishes & drinks of 2011 Read more.
2. Brooklyn Wine Exchange
8.7
138 Court St (btwn Pacific & Atlantic), Brooklyn, NY
Wine Store · Cobble Hill · 40 tips and reviews
David Kaplan: This is one of the best places to buy one of the best-tasting spirits, Sorel. Great whiskey and local (Long Island/North Fork) wines.
estheribrown ✌🏻: The staff here are super friendly and helpful - they're happy to make recommendations and I've never had a miss w/one. Love the $12 and under table and the free wine tastings & classes. Great shop.
Scott Flaherty: I'm no connoisseur (tend to pick wine by the design on the label), but it seems like they keep the cheaper stuff on a table in the middle, and in general have a great selection.
4. Red Hook Winery
9.0
175 Van Dyke St (Pier 41 Suite 325A), Brooklyn, NY
Wine Bar · Red Hook · 28 tips and reviews
On the Grid: Red Hook Winery is worth the trek, offering an impressive variety and amazing waterfront views. Read more.
Alex Rainert: Brooklyn has its very own winery?! These guys are right on the beautiful Red Hook pier, offer tastings on the weekends and even have a killer wine club where they send you 12 special bottles a year.
Amelia Manderscheid: Tastings for $5 Saturdays from 12-4!
5. Shelter
7.5
80 N 7th St (at Wythe Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Bar · Williamsburg · 99 tips and reviews
Anna Ohare: Place gets pretty busy for dinner so call ahead if you want to get a good seat. Pizza is perfect to share with a friend over some Riesling.
J.M. Saponaro: How come I never been to Shelter before ?!Best pizzas that I've tried in Williamsburg so far. Awesomely cosy vibe (love the fireplace)... I will definitely go again !
Global Highlander: In true Williamsburg style, it offers pizza and Argentinian empanadas w/ an interior of a ski lodge and exterior of an Italian cafe, along with aloof service. The wobbly tables spill water all over!
Eva Drago: Incredible selection of amaro. If you're curious, ask the bartender if you can try a few. Fantastic team - these people really love Italian food and wine, and make you feel right at home.
Sabrina Merchant: Lovely new spot in the hood - bartenders and the manager are super friendly and have a great deal of knowledge about everything they serve!
Lauryn Goldberg: V tiny in here, you have to be okay with being as smooshed as possible. The grilled octopus and all the pastas make it worth it.
8. Mama Rao's
8.2
6408 11th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Borough Park · 21 tips and reviews
Mary Jasen: The food was fantastic, the beet salad was so great, shrimp Oreganata was so light and string beans done just right. The Snowflake dessert drink was outstanding’
🌺 Lauren S 🇺🇸: Best lemon cookies around : )
💋StephanieMarie💋: After you eat go next door & pick up their DELISH lemon cookies! They have a wide selection of cookies & food! Heaven
9. Anthony's Place
7.8
2110 Avenue X (btwn E 21st & E 22nd St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 10 tips and reviews
The Corcoran Group: Straightforward, home-style Italian food, with the BEST garlic knots. Get the house salad, followed by fried zucchini and something from their specials menu.
Gregory Fillinger: Good stuff
Ilyssa D: Fresh, delicious, can't go wrong with anything on this menu...and top it off with zeppoles!
10. The Castello Plan
8.7
1213 Cortelyou Rd (btwn Argyle & Westminster Rd), Brooklyn, NY
Wine Bar · Flatbush · 55 tips and reviews
Krissy Goode: Great wine and beer selection; fantastic food. Try the cheese plate with the special farmers' market salad (changes seasonally but is always amazing). This place is one of my all-time Brooklyn faves.
Hilary: The brunch is fantastic. Get the breakfast plan, comes with a plate full of delicious food and a bellini/mimosa. Their cheese selection is also really good, the Blue di Bufala is deelish.
Samuel Herbig: When you're here for brunch: the Logger is just a wonderful mix of fresh and fried and bread and a delicious half of a grapefruit with salt & honey. Read more.
12. Le Fanfare
8.3
1103 Manhattan Ave (at Dupont Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Greenpoint · 36 tips and reviews
Jake Przespo: Le Fanfare is a brand new spot with a lot of promise. Classic cocktails, great tasting food, and live jazz music makes for a solid Saturday night.
Nadia IssaBella: Save room for the fresh canolli. They're divine.
Ms Helene: Burrata & octopus apps, Branzino market fish of day with fregola $22. No cover for live jazz.
goop: This warmly lit, cozy wooden house offers an excellent selection of wines and a small menu of casual small plates such as crostini, cheese and daily specials. Read more.
The New Yorker: This cabinlike saloon, complete with a clapboard façade and Adirondack chairs out front, was “designed with two places in mind: Stowe, Vermont, and Jackson Hole, Wyoming.” Read more.
Gothamist: Ever-romantic Wine House is the fireplace bar to go to. The rustic, farmhouse-style wine bar lets you settle in with a glass ($6.50-$11) or bottle ($28-$45). So relax and enjoy the warmth. Read more.
14. Bricolage
8.7
162 5th Ave (btwn Douglass & Degraw St), Brooklyn, NY
Vietnamese Restaurant · North Slope · 61 tips and reviews
marcy stone: We had a sea of apps. The ribs, crepe and chicken wings are delicious but you can forgo the pigs ears. The garden is so pretty and serene you'll forget you're in the city.
Geoffroy Bablon: Check out the bathroom, where you can witness the distant creation of the universe while you wash up.
Eater: With an expanded new menu, this Vietnamese joint in Brooklyn has caught our attention. Try the sizzling and sprout-driven ban xeo crêpes heaped with fresh herbs. Read more.
15. Achilles Heel
9.2
180 West St (at Green St), Brooklyn, NY
Cocktail Bar · Greenpoint · 85 tips and reviews
Project Latte: a NYC cafe culture guide: A chill, all day cafe and bar, Greenpoint's Achilles Heel has a real neighborhood feeling, offers delicious small plates, and an ambitious coffee program with selections from different roasters. Read more.
Joshua Ingram: Good god - they serve the best oysters I've had in my life.
Project Latte: a NYC cafe culture guide: A chill neighborhood bar, Achilles Heel is run by the same group as Marlow & Sons and as such, has a quality daytime coffee program, also featuring George Howell. No food and not a work space. Read more.