Pierluigi Trotta: Steak for two, creamed spinach and apple strudel with whipped cream is a MUST
Beth Georges: The creamed spinach and the bacon were the real standout dishes. The steak and Luger's sauce were classic and wonderful. The drinks were strong and the desserts were delicious.
Marc Cohen: Thick cut bacon, all steaks, and the schlag for desert. Best steakhouse in NYC.
2. St. Anselm
9.2
355 Metropolitan Ave (btwn Havemeyer & Roebling St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Williamsburg · 318 tips and reviews
Josh Knowles: Easily the best restaurant in the neighborhood right now. Get the hanger steak and truffle mash potatoes.
diana huang: Butcher's steak, side of long beans and a glass of lambrusco makes the perfect meal!
New York Strip was cooked and seasoned to near perfection. The spinach gratin is a must try as well. Stay away from the Veal with the chimichuri sauce.
3. Colonia Verde
9.1
219 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Latin American Restaurant · Fort Greene · 87 tips and reviews
desavoia: Great outdoor seating, highly recommend the grilled arepas, langostine and shaved brussels sprouts cesar salad for appetizer – you can’t go wrong with the wood fire grilled chef’s steak
Village Voice: Try the Chef's Steak -it hits the table with an expertly charred crust, the interior marbled & juicy. Served with a smoky salsa verde and caramelized onion-spiked mashed sweet potatoes. Read more.
Nate Folkert: chef's steak with salsa and mashed sweet potatoes and avocados - low carb, high protein - $32
8. Gage & Tollner
9.2
372 Fulton St (at Jay St), Brooklyn, NY
Steakhouse · Downtown Brooklyn · 16 tips and reviews
Jonathan R: Clams Kimcino, raw bar, and the steaks here are excellent!! Great cocktail program as well.
Rami Haykal-Manning: Get the crab soup, t bone and baked alaska
Noah Weiss: Phenomenal. Perfect meal for two: clams kimcino, ribeye steak, “hash browns”, coconut layer cake, and a smattering of cocktails. Vibe teleports you too.
9. Colonie
9.2
127 Atlantic Ave (btwn Henry & Clinton St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Brooklyn Heights · 245 tips and reviews
MidgeMadge D: Just wow. Might be my new favorite Brooklyn joint. Standouts: The hanger steak, the heirloom tomato salad, sweet corn, egg salad and ricotta crostini.
Kenneth Bing: Everything was fantastic! The scallops great, the skirt steak omg!
Trae F: A great place to splurge and order the steak. Friendly staff and great cocktails.
10. Meadowsweet
9.0
149 Broadway (at Bedford Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Williamsburg · 99 tips and reviews
Mark Kupasrimonkol: Fantastic tasting! For 2, each person gets a different dish per course essentially letting you try the whole menu. Everything was great but the pastas, seafood and steak entrees stood out.
Noah Weiss: Great date spot for Michelin starred New American at reasonable prices. The steak and short ribs was fantastic and big enough for two. Crispy artichoke salad and pastries, too.
Kat C: Everything we tried was great-fluke crudo, cavatelli, black sea bass, hanger steak, and the panna cotta. Order the Smoke Gets in Your Rye cocktail.
11. Olea
9.3
171 Lafayette Ave (at Adelphi St), Brooklyn, NY
Tapas Restaurant · Fort Greene · 236 tips and reviews
Gabrielle Tabak: perfect place for a glass of wine and amazing tapas! Fried green olives or sangria skirt steak, can't go wrong!
Mark Egan: Brunch is best, get in early, though. Steak and eggs are superb!
BrooklynLadyP: Addicted to the kale salad and sangria marinated hanger steak!
13. Alta Calidad
8.5
552 Vanderbilt Ave (at Dean St), Brooklyn, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Prospect Heights · 47 tips and reviews
Amar Pradhan: Excellent everything! Try the octopus, quesos, steak tacos!
Emily Wilson: The tomatillo guac is excellent, as are the tacos (we tried steak and chicken — both killer). Skip the beef ribs (too fatty, hard to eat). Order a tequila or mezcal based cocktail to wash it all down.
Kayleigh Harrington: You can't go wrong with anything on the menu here. The steak tacos with chicharrones will blow your mind. Great cocktails too.
14. Bar Tabac
8.0
128 Smith St (at Dean St), Brooklyn, NY
French Restaurant · Boerum Hill · 211 tips and reviews
ECava: the steak frites and tuna tartare are excellent!
The Corcoran Group: A staple of Cobble Hill. Come for the Steak Frites (with peppercorn sauce), a Late Night Giant Burger or simply sip a glass of wine and listen to the nightly jazz music.
Tony Smith: The grilled chicken wrap was amazing! Juicy and flavorful. The grilled hanger steak sandwich was okay but the near was very tender!