1. Motorino
8.4
349 E 12th St (at 1st Ave), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 318 tips and reviews
Rastakiki Rastakiki: Very delicious pizza (one of the best of New York), i have tried the sausage pizza, but the margherita seems even better. Not expensive.
Kaoru Fujita: Amazing pizza and meatballs. Highly enjoyed the fennel salad too.
James: Amazing Cremini pizza with mushrooms and sausage. Crazy combo but it works!
3. Lil' Frankie's
8.3
19 1st Ave (btwn E 1st & E 2nd St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · East Village · 264 tips and reviews
Diana Melton: Funghi pizza and Pomodoro Penne is delish!
Sara 🌈⚔🍾: Amazing! Real brick oven pizza and authentic Italian dishes. I had the salame piccante pizza, which was great. I will definitely go back to try the others!
Karima: Cozy vibes, the pizza is fantastic and reasonable, the nutella calzone/focaccia is amazing and they have an unbeatable 3 for 1 brunch drink situation on the weekends.
5. Emmy Squared
9.0
83 1st Ave (at E 5th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 32 tips and reviews
Noah Weiss: Delicious Detroit style pizza. Colony^2 with pepperoni, hot pepper, honey plus new curry row pizza all great.
Adriana De Los Palos: Margarita pizza delicious 😍 Wes was very friendly and gave us great recommendations for restaurants at NY
Konstantinos Psychogios: Pizza is great! Loved the broccoli salad too!
7. Double Zero
8.1
65 2nd Ave (at E 4th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 47 tips and reviews
Cory Bangert: Truffles celeriac pizza is out of this world delicious!
Raquelle Jessie: The dough is fantasticcc. Get the Pizza with the walnut cream, shitake mushroom, lemon zest & green harissa!
Max Bpm: Another vegan spot that catches your attention and never let's go. One of the best vegan plant based pizzas I have ever tried. Delicious vegan tomato basil mozzarella from start to finish!
8. Gemma
8.3
335 Bowery (btwn E 2nd & E 3rd St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · East Village · 192 tips and reviews
Theory: NY. Gemma’s location in the Bowery Hotel and menu make it a great place to dine with friends. Sidewalk seating in the summer is a bonus. Must try: the burrata, grape tomato & black olive pizza.
Shrutika Sachdev: Lovely warm rustic atmosphere: good place for first dates or groups! - lobster ravioli, pizza and NUTELLA Calzone are a must!!! (good writing pen for the bill...)
A Z: AMAZING Italian food. Polenta fries are a MUST! Truffle pizza and Rigatoni pasta are delicious 😍😍 will definitely come back here!
Cara Moccia: The pizza is great, get the 18" so you can try 2 kinds. The mushroom bruschetta is lovely but the Carbonara is a disaster!
Robin Ching: Their pizza are wonderful with great wine. I definitely want to come back. I am from Rochester, NY
dipti p.: Def a favorite pizza hole in e vil...tasty sauce , crust, and cheese...All you need.
10. Gnocco
7.9
337 E 10th St (Avenue B), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Alphabet City · 95 tips and reviews
2 Dine Out: In addition to some fantastic pastas (Maccheroni al Torchio and Gnocchi al Pomodoro among others) and exceptional pizza, Gnocco serves delectable appetizers. I went with the eponymous Gnocco-$12.45.. Read more.
Katie Koster: Affogato is yummy, as is prosciutto and arugola pizza
Anto S.: Pizza here was really good and service very nice and quick even in a busy Friday night.
12. Lavagna
8.8
545 E 5th St (btwn Avenue A & Avenue B), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Alphabet City · 78 tips and reviews
Mark J: Pizza delicious, proscuitto with figs,Mulderbosch Faithful Hound at a good price point
Jaki Winkles: I came here with two friends and we ordered the Pizza de Giorno and Prosciutto de San Danielle - both were great! Yum!!
Mariam Muzaffar: Delicious and intimate setting. The pizza from the wood burning oven is delicious! (Everything was!) great service
Jaclyn: i love their rotating pizza specials and late night hours!
Daan V.: The best pizza place in terms of decorum and staff. The pizzas have funky names like Tony Clifton (which I can personally recommend, great toppings). Plenty of vegetarian options, plus one vegan pie.
Daniel McDonough: My absolute favorite pizza. Get 2 slices of cheese and a Pepsi. They also host an annual Oscar pool winner gets a free pie.