Norma Gastronomia Siciliana is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

1. Norma Gastronomia Siciliana

8.9
801 9th Ave (W. 53rd St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 9 tips and reviews

Matteo P.Matteo P.: A real hidden gem! Authentic Sicilian food, with an intriguing menu and a great service

Jasmine D.Jasmine D: Amazing & authentic pizza and pear salad

David R.David Reichsfeld: Great pasta at a fantastic price to quality ratio for NYC. Flavorful plates and great unique Sicilian pasta plates.

Masseria dei Vini is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

2. Masseria dei Vini

8.6
887 9th Ave (btwn W 57th St & W 58th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 29 tips and reviews

Rim K.Rim Karoui: Waiters are very nice and friendly! Every single thing on the menu is delicious. Had the caprese salad and ravioli and oh boy was it good!! Lemon sorbet for desert is the perfect way to end your meal!

Eric G.Eric Grant: Fantastic food, drinks and service. Our neighborhood definitely needed this kind of upscale restaurant.

Michael F.Michael Fox-Rabinovitz: Loved the staff, actually main guys are truly Italian. Nice wine menu. Appetizers octopus and meatballs are nice, calamari ok. Had rigatoni with short rib, not too special, dessert was ok.

The Meatball Shop is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

3. The Meatball Shop

8.3
798 9th Ave (53rd & 9th), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 38 tips and reviews

Ida P.Ida Paras: Lamb meatballs naked with pesto on a bed of broccoli. Don't forget to get a side of roasted carrots and DESSERT! --- brown sugar icecream in between 2 double chocolate chunk cookies ❤️👌🏾

Craig H.Craig Hodgkins: Great service, good portions and choices. Large cocktail menu.

Hany Y.Hany Youssef: Cool restaurant the staff r very friendly everything is super delicious

Orso is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

4. Orso

8.2
322 W 46th St (btwn 9th Ave & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 31 tips and reviews

uəɥdəʇs ə.uəɥdəʇs əɔɐd: I recommend the Carciofini (pan fried baby artichokes), Pollo (pan roasted free-range chicken), Cavoletti (fried Brussels sprouts), and chocolate Budino.

Eric T.Eric Tash: Very good pizza, overall nice after theatre spot. Prices aren't too exorbitant. Good probability you'll see celebrity dining at the table next to you.

Savannah P.Savannah Petrick: great pre-show meal. rigatoni and orchiette are both solid options.

Tavola is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

5. Tavola

8.3
488 9th Ave (at W 38th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 72 tips and reviews

Ozgur K.Ozgur K.: Another wonderful pizza and Italian food place in town. This is a real thing, not a trendy touristic places. It has the casual spirit. Best to enjoy on the bar

Michael A.Michael Axelbaum: The lasagna and wild boar meatballs were great. Wood fried artichokes were delish. Service could use some polishing. But we were here on night 1.

Banana Nut Bread O.Banana Nut Bread Oo Oo Oo Oo Kie: Look up at the ceiling, the fans work on an old school belt system by rotating rope! Awesome. Oh and the pizza is very very good!

Il Melograno is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

6. Il Melograno

8.1
501 W 51st St (10th Avenue), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 41 tips and reviews

Nicole S.Nicole S: Try any of their salads! They usually have great salads on special, but my favorite is the Pear salad - light, fruity and delicious. Also, try the Spaghetti w/ homemade san marzano sauce at least once

Sara D.Sara D'Alto (Cappelli): Food is delicious! And they have a super friendly staff. Feels like your back in Italy, very fresh & cozy! Try the cheese plate and the Pappardelle with Sausage. House Red is the best!

Don F.Don Flanders: Bolognese is the best.

La Vela Dining & Bar is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

7. La Vela Dining & Bar

7.9
558 11th Avenue (42nd & 43rd Streets), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 7 tips and reviews

Tayler R.Tayler Rinehart: 100% authentic delicious Italian fine dining and bar. There’s outlets next to the tables so you can charge your phone! The staff is great, the lighting is dimmed and sets the mood. Love it

Enrique C.Enrique Cruz: Amazing and authentic neapolitan pizza.

Ellie T.Ellie Troutman: Absolutely loved this place. The lasagne was incredible the service impeccable. Glad we chose La Vela for dinner.

Becco is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

8. Becco

8.0
355 W 46th St (at 9th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 196 tips and reviews

Ray F.Ray F.: Sit at the bar and enjoy the three-pasta special. Have Geronimo satisfy you wine cravings. Becco is a great place to engage with others.

Showtime NetworkShowtime Network: You’ll need to confess to the Pope himself after the sinful delights of this restaurant.

LogoTVLogoTV: "There's a special with unlimited amounts of their 3 amazing pastas of the day. I recommend devoting as many hours as you can muster and leave on a gurney." -Jeffery Self, Jeffery & Cole Casserole

Giardino 54 is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

9. Giardino 54

8.0
400 1/2 W 54th St (at Ninth Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 7 tips and reviews

Sophia T.Sophia Tan: Authentic Italian food, with handmade pasta and the most delicious prosciutto. Good service and quite vibe. A gem in Hell’s Kitchen!

Chris A.Chris Andrew: Great little place. Good service good food and ambiance.

Natra A.Natra Aga: Lovely outdoor and indoor space!

ViceVersa is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

10. ViceVersa

7.9
325 W 51st St (8th & 9th Aves.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 36 tips and reviews

Lisa N.Lisa NYCnonprofit: Duck pasta. Swordfish. Spinach salad. Eggplant appetizers. Delicious and unique

Marques S.Marques Stewart: get a 3 course meal for only $35, all the time.

Tash C.Tash Concepcion: Mushroom pasta is ok but a little too much oil. Order the smaller portion.

Il Punto Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

11. Il Punto Ristorante

7.7
507 9th Ave (Corner Of 38th), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 35 tips and reviews

Julian M.Julian Modesto: Great laid back Italian restaurant around the Theater District. Pound a wine, get the fettuccini and finish with some grappa.

Nation's Restaurant NewsNation's Restaurant News: Chef Antonio Mermolia came up with his shrimp salad with onion gelato on a hot day in July when he was trying to create a refreshing yet out-of-the-ordinary dish. Read more.

Annabell A.Annabell Alvarez: Calamari is amazing. Very friendly staff

dell’anima is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

12. dell’anima

7.7
600 11th Ave, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 8 tips and reviews

Kate Z.Kate Zecher: Everything is amazing here. The homemade pastas and protein entrees are unreal. Love the branzino, chicken and lamb chops. Can’t go wrong.

Lou P.Lou Paskalis: Octopus, hanger steak and outdoor seating all rock...

Rob A.Rob Atkinson: Casual at the counter but great service and food. Reasonable prices for the city. Cacio e Pepe or carbonara can't go wrong

Bocca Di Bacco is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

13. Bocca Di Bacco

8.0
635 9th Ave (btwn W 44th & W 45th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 38 tips and reviews

DoubleDeuceDoubleDeuce: Very typical Italian for NYC, and plenty of seating for larger groups or larger folks who want feel more comfortable.

Jeremy D.Jeremy Davis: Get the Bruschetta Ai Funghi to start. It. Does. Not. Disappoint.

Mandar M.Mandar M: Just wait for the free bread if you are ordering an entree, it comes with garlic tonatoes - you can make your own bruschetta!

Mama Mia 44sw Italian Cuisine is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

14. Mama Mia 44sw Italian Cuisine

7.6
621 9th Ave, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 12 tips and reviews

Taylor M.Taylor Mulligan: Everything. Chicken parm!

Karmyn T.Karmyn Tyler: Great little spot. Yummy food. Usually crowded in the weekends.

Cyril S.Cyril S.: Great food but slow service

Bad Roman is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen, New York.

15. Bad Roman

7.2
10 Columbus Cir Fl 3, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 7 tips and reviews

Paula B.Paula Buzzo: Start with roasted garlic babka; as an entrée, we ordered filetto with cacio e pepe raviolo and a side of rosemary fries. The food was super tasty. Excellent attendance.

Paige C.Paige C: Loved the appetizers, drinks and dessert. Wasn’t entirely thrilled with our entrees. Not to be missed: the garlic babka, the whipped feta, and the lemon cheesecake.

Michael G.Michael G.: Worth the hype. Everything was phenomenal