The Salty Dog Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

1. The Salty Dog Cafe

8.4
232 S Sea Pines Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 121 tips and reviews

Nikole G.Nikole Grote: Kiwi colada is amazing! Seafood pasta is delicious but the crab cake sandwich is the best bang for your buck! Get here at 4 to avoid an hour plus wait

Stacey S.Stacey Schick: Try the shrimp po boy ....super yummy! and you can't beat the atmosphere :)

Chris H.Chris Holdeman: Salt dog combo plate with gumbo and shrimp sandwich is awesome combination

Kenny B's French Quarter Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

2. Kenny B's French Quarter Cafe

8.7
70 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island, SC
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · 45 tips and reviews

Lauren M.Lauren McMullen: The hush puppies, corn bread, po boy, gumbo, sweet potato fried, soft shell crab, red beans & rice, & even the 7 grain sub roll were EVERYTHING. #yummmm

Josh C.Josh Carpenter: Louisiana Chicken Melt is incredible and the owners are the nicest people in South Carolina.

JP R.JP Reynolds: This place is unreal!! Incredible Cajun food at reasonable prices...even for on Island food. Gumbo Yaya is a must try, po boys are great and, if you have time, slow down and enjoy brunch on Sunday.

A Lowcountry Backyard Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

3. A Lowcountry Backyard Restaurant

8.8
32 Palmetto Bay Rd Ste A4, Hilton Head Island, SC
Southern Food Restaurant · 88 tips and reviews

Chase T.Chase Thompson: Great blackened tofu sandwich!

Rj W.Rj Wilkie: What a fabulous place, great food,great service,cozy atmosphere.A MUST, Suggest the Meatloaf Sandwhich.

Amanda R.Amanda Roufs: Crab dip and crab cake sandwich are good. The shrimp & grits are by far the best. Definitely recommend!

Stu's Surfside Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

4. Stu's Surfside Subs

8.1
1 N Forest Beach, Hilton Head Island, SC
Sandwich Spot · 20 tips and reviews

Trisha T.Trisha Thommi: Best sub I have had in awhile! I got the islander #17. All of them are fresh & good as well! Definitely come eat here, it's worth it!

Bryce W.Bryce Whitsett: Some of the best subs i've ever had!

FRITZ f.FRITZ fritztheyodeler: Typically the subs are pretty damn good here... I like 'em hot. The bread here is really good and sets them apart from most sub joints.

Fat Baby's Pizza And Subs is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

5. Fat Baby's Pizza And Subs

8.3
120 Arrow Ro. Suite B (Target Rd.), Hilton Head Island, SC
Pizzeria · 35 tips and reviews

Paul G.Paul Gorsuch: Get the Fat Baby sub heated

SeanSean: Off the beaten path.. Loved by locals. THE best slice and subs on the island.

Bob W.Bob Webb: Great subs!

The Frosty Frog Pizza & Daiquiri Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

6. The Frosty Frog Pizza & Daiquiri Bar

8.3
1 N Forest Beach Dr (at Avocet Rd), Hilton Head Island, SC
Pizzeria · 80 tips and reviews

Roxy B.Roxy B: The crab cake is really good, the sandwich version is good too!

Debbie M.Debbie McCall: Crabcake sandwich & pina colada daiquiri

Zach W.Zach Wells: The chicken parm sandwich is awesome. Also, try to sit outside and listen to they live music they have at night.

Hudson's Seafood House on the Docks is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

7. Hudson's Seafood House on the Docks

8.2
1 Hudson Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 85 tips and reviews

Christopher J.Christopher Jennison: Special of the day is blackened swordfish sandwich with Cajun Aeoli- delicious!

Andy B.Andy Black: The shrimp po' boys are amazing!

Jessica H.Jessica Hansen: Blackened chicken club is soooo good. Beautiful view in or out of the restaurant.

Sea Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

8. Sea Shack

8.4
6B Executive Park Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 62 tips and reviews

Angela I.Angela Ice: Crab cake sandwich was delicious!

Kenny R.Kenny Rolt: Sandwiches rock!

Ryan W.Ryan Windley: Conch fritters were great. Buffalo shrimp on the po boy were good and spicy - I ditched the bread 1/3 of the way through.

The Crazy Crab is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

9. The Crazy Crab

7.8
149 Lighthouse Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC
Seafood Restaurant · 100 tips and reviews

Erkang Z.Erkang Zheng: The blackened grouper sandwich here is awesome!

KateKate: I have had the crabcake sandwich (awesome!) and the blackened grouper sandwich (even more amazing!) but nothing tops their she crab soup! Yum!!!!!!!!!

Mac R.Mac Ray: The blackened grouper sandwich lunch special is one of the best I've had.

Giuseppi's Pizza & Pasta is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

10. Giuseppi's Pizza & Pasta

8.5
32 Shelter Cove Ln, Hilton Head Island, SC
Pizzeria · 54 tips and reviews

Debra O.Debra Ortiz: Eggplant sub was very good!

Elizabeth M.Elizabeth Miller: Kids will devour the macaroni and cheese. Good sandwiches. Great pizza. Fun atmosphere.

Brian K.Brian Kush: The food was ok, not spectacular, just regular pizza and sandwiches. AC did not work real well inside and they lost our order.

Watusi Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

11. Watusi Cafe

8.2
71 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island, SC
Coffee Shop · 30 tips and reviews

Chris M.Chris McKinney: The Big Watusi Sandwich is great! Bacon and sausage! Best coffee on the island!

Carolyn M.Carolyn May: The ocean scramble on the breakfast menu was unbelievable! If you get a side of toast you can make a scramble sandwich..yum!

Megan K.Megan Kai: I loved the environment in this cafe.The staff were very friendly. I got the farmers market sandwich. My food was great, very flavorful and a good portion.

Island Bagel & Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

12. Island Bagel & Deli

8.0
841 William Hilton Pkwy, Hilton Head Island, SC
Bagel Shop · 8 tips and reviews

Monte B.Monte Babington: Both halves on the bagel sandwich are tops! Epic. Easily as good as the ones I get in NYC

Daniel P.Daniel Peluso: The bagels ate excellent, but do not forget to try the hoagie sandwiches, they are AMAZING!

Aubrey RamonAubrey Ramon: Nice calming restaurant. Everything looks great! I had The Kitchen Sink with Pasta Salad & it was AWESOME! HIGHLY recommended.

Reilley's Grill & Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

13. Reilley's Grill & Bar

8.2
7D Greenwood Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 32 tips and reviews

Brock I.Brock Irvin: I recommend the American poboy

Spencer V.Spencer Vairo: Incredible bottomless brunch bargain! Sub out home fries and get the French fries instead. You will be drunk and happy guaranteed

Frank M. S.Frank M. Severino Jr: Great Meatloaf and Cheddar Sandwiches.

Harold's Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

14. Harold's Diner

7.7
641 William Hilton Pkwy (Singleton Beach Rd), Hilton Head Island, SC
Diner · 27 tips and reviews

Christina✌Christina✌: Philly Cheese Steak and onion rings are amazing! Don't mess up your order or you'll get yelled at!

Jason F.Jason Feldman: Grilled grouper sandwich with cheddar cheese and grilled mushrooms and onions with a side of cole slaw. You're set.

Elizabeth M.Elizabeth Miller: Great burger. Pick your toppings, like a WichWich sandwich. No need to cover up this burger with cheese and condiments. It stands on its own without the extras. Fries were just "ok" - too greasy.

Jane Bistro and Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Sandwiches in Hilton Head.

15. Jane Bistro and Bar

8.7
28 Shelter Cove Ln #109, Hilton Head Island, SC
American Restaurant · 5 tips and reviews

Gary R.Gary Robertson: Fried green tomato sandwich was awesome. Big. Fries good too. Lots of food!

Bob W.Bob Webb: FGT sandwich was great, as was Tomato bisque !

Tammy S.Tammy Stuck: Excellent patio, ask about daily dinner specials and be sure to make reservations if going for dinner. A bit pricey, but you get what you pay for. Good cocktails!