Insomnia Cookies is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

1. Insomnia Cookies

8.2
809 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Dessert Shop · Broad Ripple · 11 tips and reviews

Ashley J.Ashley Jackson: 12 cookies for $12 & you MUST try the s'mores chocolate cookie!!!!!! Yum-yum!!!

Dana P.Dana Parker: Double chocolate mint cookies are the shiz

SarahSarah: Warm cookies for a late night snack, yum!

Rene's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

2. Rene's Bakery

8.8
6524 Cornell Ave (btw 65th & Coil), Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · Broad Ripple · 16 tips and reviews

Kamilah G.Kamilah Gill: Go to Rene's Bakery on a Saturday afternoon. If you're lucky, you can get a fresh chocolate chip cookie and a baguette. Everything there tastes great. Read more.

Joe G.Joe Gault: Try the ham and cheese croissants, almond croissants, chocolate brioche, brownies, choco chip cookies.... It's all good.

Denise D.Denise Dilworth: Two words: ginger cookies. *swoon*

BRICS is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

3. BRICS

9.1
901 E 64th St (at Cornell Av), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Broad Ripple · 56 tips and reviews

Jonna P.Jonna Patel: The chocolate chip cookie dough was amazing.. ;)

Sabrina L.Sabrina Lynch: The oatmeal cookie ice cream was absolutely delicious

Stephon G.Stephon Gilder: The chocolate chip cookie dough is amazing!

Potbelly Sandwich Shop is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

4. Potbelly Sandwich Shop

8.5
55 Monument Circle, Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Downtown Indianapolis · 39 tips and reviews

kylie b.kylie beaudreau: A Wreck add meatball and marinara. THE WRECKING BALL! Of course with a strawberry smoothie or... a cookie sandwich. :)

Jess T.Jess Thrower: Pizza sandwich, coffee shake, sugar cookie, and soup. BEST MEAL EVER.

Claire J.Claire Jones: Easy to get to from the Conference Center. They have a great menu with a lot of cheap choices. Definitely get the Chocolate Browning Cookie!

Taylor's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

5. Taylor's Bakery

8.7
6216 Allisonville Rd (at E 62nd St), Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · 23 tips and reviews

Jennifer C.Jennifer Coffey: Best birthday cakes, cookies and cupcakes in the city for birthdays!

April G.April Gregory: The best cakes and cupcakes! The cake is so good and the icing is even better. Full bakery including cookies, candies, and donuts. And try their homemade ice cream.

CS_just_CSCS_just_CS: Some of the best donuts in Indy. The Danish, Bavarian, and old fashioned are some of our favorites.

Goose The Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

6. Goose The Market

9.2
2503 N Delaware St (at E 25th St), Indianapolis, IN
Gourmet Store · Fall Creek Place · 74 tips and reviews

Tom D.Tom Deeter: Try the shagbark cookie, its delicioso!

Cindy R.Cindy Robbins: Make sure to get a cookie w that sandwich

ChristinaChristina: All the sandwiches are fantastic, and do not forget to get a cookie, too! They are thick, buttery, nut-filled and delicious.

Landmark Keystone Art Cinema is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

7. Landmark Keystone Art Cinema

8.8
8702 Keystone Xing (in the Fashion Mall at Keystone), Indianapolis, IN
Indie Movie Theater · Keystone at The Crossing · 34 tips and reviews

KateKate: They have Alternative Baking Company, Inc vegan cookies FTW

Andrew W.Andrew Warner: Get a vegan cookie while you are there.

Catrina S.Catrina Smythe: Best theatre experience in Indy, apart from the loud talker(s). Great, healthier snacks $$$. Love their Special Events! Frankenstein, The Hermitage, etc. Tibbs drive-in is a close second.

McAlister's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

8. McAlister's Deli

8.1
7711 Shelby St (at S US 31), Greenwood, IN
Deli · 43 tips and reviews

Jozette S.Jozette Shaffer: Soups and cookies to die for! Delicious!

Denise H.Denise Holaday: Free cookie for mom on Mothers' Day!

Griffin M.Griffin Mullins: Food was fast and fresh. Good service! Definitely try the nachos!

McAlisters Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

9. McAlisters Deli

7.8
8840 Michigan Rd Ste 104 (at Vincennes Rd.), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · College Park · 53 tips and reviews

Ted G.Ted Givens: Orange Cranberry Club and a Heath bar cookie yum yum

Jim H.Jim Holzmeyer: best chocolate chip cookies anywhere

Aubrey P.Aubrey Phillips: Fantastic tortilla soup. Great to pair with the Reuben!

Hart Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

10. Hart Bakery

7.7
7030 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · East Gate · 9 tips and reviews

Chrystal P.Chrystal Parvin: Mmm butter cookies!

Tom K.Tom Ketchum: Everything is great. Cakes decorated to order, fantastic doughnuts, wonderful cookies.

Nainse T.Nainse Tindall-Sponsel: Pecan Rolls are awesome. Call ahead to make sure they save you one.

Monon Coffee Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

11. Monon Coffee Company

7.7
920 E Westfield Blvd (bt Guilford & Winthrop Avs), Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Broad Ripple · 35 tips and reviews

MirandaMiranda: The shagbark cookies are the best thing ever! I always buy one to eat with my coffee at home the next day. The people who work there are always friendly, too.

Dana P.Dana Parker: They sell 4birds oatmeal cookies, and their con pan a is the best in Indy

AmandaAmanda: The strawberry lemonade smoothie is beyond delicious. The employees are great too.

Calvin Fletcher's Coffee Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

12. Calvin Fletcher's Coffee Company

8.1
647 Virginia Ave (at College Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Fletcher Place · 85 tips and reviews

Kris R.Kris Reed: Best choc chip cookies...

Angela J.Angela Jorden: The Chai latte is phenomenal and so much better than Starbucks. Always great service and fresh cookies!

Maria A.Maria Alviz: A great place for organic drinks and pastries, also they are pet friendly!

Subito is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

13. Subito

8.2
44 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Soup Spot · Downtown Indianapolis · 3 tips and reviews

JohnnyCRSrJohnnyCRSr: The soup and cookies are my favorite but you can't go wrong with the sandwiches or salads either.

Dalton S.Dalton Spear: Sandwiches are loaded and bread is fantastic. Get the Reuben with a small side of soup

Mike H.Mike Heintzleman: Probably my favorite sandwich shop in Indy. Great staff. Love the variety in the menu and the side of macaroni salad is the bomb.

Maggiano's Little Italy is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

14. Maggiano's Little Italy

8.9
3550 E 86th St (Keystone Crossing), Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 54 tips and reviews

Shashank S.Shashank Soni: My wife and I love the classic pastas. They have excellent tiramisu, coffee, and those lemon cookies..awesome!

Jill D.Jill D: Great place for lunch. Not as crowded. Also try the take home pastas. Try a pasta and take another one home!

Mallory D.Mallory D: Hands down the best service when it comes to gluten free dining! (gfree pasta is tasty too!) the chef comes out to speak w you about your allergies, which let's you really enjoy your meal w no worries

Huddle's Frozen Yogurt is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Indianapolis.

15. Huddle's Frozen Yogurt

8.3
1356 E 86th St (at Monon Tr), Indianapolis, IN
Frozen Yogurt Shop · Nora - Far Northside · 43 tips and reviews

Chris R.Chris Ruel: Great yogurt. Loved the cookies and cream.

Jessie M.Jessie Munn: such a great deal, and so many awesome flavors. red velvet cake is where it's at!

JuliusJulius: Cake batter and Red Velvet cake are amazing