Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream & Java is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

1. Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream & Java

9.3
9922 E 79th St (Fall Creek Road), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Geist · 24 tips and reviews

Julie S.Julie Sawyer: Fantastic homemade ice cream, big variety, even exotic green tea flavor. Support locally owned/run stores like this!

Randy D.Randy Davis: Vanilla Malt!

Randy D.Randy Davis: Ice Cream is the perfect treat on a hot summer day!

Graeter's Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

2. Graeter's Ice Cream

9.3
5560 N Illinois St (56th Street), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Butler - Tarkington · 10 tips and reviews

Paul C.Paul C: The best French pot made ice cream!

Championship C.Championship Co: Some of the finest quality ice cream in the country. Chocolate chips in ice cream can vary in size and some can be downright gigantic!

April G.April Gregory: Buckeye Blitz and black raspberry chocolate chip are my favorites!

Trader's Point Creamery is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

3. Trader's Point Creamery

9.0
9101 Moore Rd (at W 92nd St), Zionsville, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · 24 tips and reviews

Marcia E.Marcia Erne: Awesome dinner at Trader's Point Creamery! Try the Quinoa Patties- they are incredible! Friday night the singer/guitarist was great! Service is excellent, as well!

SuperBowl 2012SuperBowl 2012: Watch cow milking daily at 4pm.

Everest C.Everest Castillo: Their blueberry ice cream , is great , if you have time take a walk on the path in the back , ( self guided tour) I'm sure as fall approaches it will be even nicer !

BRICS is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

4. BRICS

9.1
901 E 64th St (at Cornell Av), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Broad Ripple · 56 tips and reviews

Jason W.Jason Williams: Fantastic ice cream and shop is right on the Monon Trail. Big thumbs up for the yellow cake batter with swirled fudge. Read more.

Kristen N.Kristen Neal: ALWAYS order water with your ice cream. Trust me, you'll need it! Read more.

MujtabaMujtaba: They have a large selection of flavors of Ice Cream. Also, Ask for either the soy or the coconut milk-based ice cream, if you are allergic or lactose-intolerant.

Cold Stone Creamery is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

5. Cold Stone Creamery

8.7
5025 E 82nd St, Ste 400, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · 5 tips and reviews

Lindsay G.Lindsay Goodwin: The Founder's Favorite is my favorite, too!

Tiffanie B.Tiffanie Bridges: Coffee Lover's Only is a dream!!

Katie C.Katie Chancey: Founders favorite with cake batter Ice cream. The best

Nicey Treat is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

6. Nicey Treat

8.5
916 E Westfield Blvd, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Broad Ripple · 7 tips and reviews

Bo S.Bo Stephens: Excellent place with loads of non-dairy options. Highly recommended.

Amy M.Amy Mitten: Everything is good!!!!

Sarah F.Sarah Falkenthal: Normally not a Popsicle fan, but the flavor of the month was mojito and I just had to try it! Totally worth the line, it was delicious!

Wyliepalooza is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

7. Wyliepalooza

8.3
5535 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Irvington · 20 tips and reviews

Jeremiah C.Jeremiah Cosner: Absolutely a must try. Could be the best in Indy!

Denise Miller B.Denise Miller Byers: I love this place! Scott is amazing!

Isaac P.Isaac Pellerin: Fat Elvis - will definitely get it again after I work through all the other flavors.

Ritter's Frozen Custard is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

8. Ritter's Frozen Custard

8.2
4949 E Stop 11 Rd (by McFarland Ln and Emerson Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · 7 tips and reviews

Sheldon C.Sheldon Cashman: I get choclate glacier with banana and peanut butter, it’s REALLY good

Chris H.Chris Harvey: Custard...need I say more?! Try the cookie dough glacier.

Ray H.Ray Hopkins: Mud Sunday

Dairy Queen is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

9. Dairy Queen

8.1
7116 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · 9 tips and reviews

James Trèvis B.James Trèvis Boyd Jr.: Great food and Service! Yummm caramel NUT ROLLLLLL.

Lance R.Lance Rinker: Fast & friendly service. That & the new $5 mini blizzard meal deal made for one of the best fast food experiences of my life!

Lylene M.Lylene Mason: The new cotton candy blizzard is probably one of the tastiest things to ever touch my lips. Awesome!

Baskin-Robbins is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

10. Baskin-Robbins

7.9
1337 W 86th St, Greenbriar Shopping Center, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · St. Vincent - Greenbriar · 4 tips and reviews

Douglas M.Douglas Meissel: Love the Pralines and cream! Yum yum!

Mckenzie H.Mckenzie Hamilton: There cookie dough ice cream with a cone 👅👅👅

Carol J.Carol James: Pralines and Cream - the very best!

Cold Stone Creamery is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

11. Cold Stone Creamery

7.9
6010 W 86th St, Ste 142 (at Traders Point), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Park 100 · 5 tips and reviews

April G.April Gregory: Red velvet ice cream though.

Dashuna W.Dashuna Wilson: Founder's favorite us the best

Jarrod R.Jarrod Reid: Always great service! Smiling friendly faces!

Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

12. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream

8.1
427 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Downtown Indianapolis · 39 tips and reviews

Matthew S.Matthew Sadler: You have to try this if only for the experience. It is so much more than a gimmick. I had the smoothest coconut custard with chocolate shavings. A must go.

Grace Y.Grace Ybarra: You have to try the peanut butter bonds!

Steve H.Steve Hill: Is that the sound of angels? I think so, I know so; the ice cream is heavenly.

Ritter's Frozen Custard is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

13. Ritter's Frozen Custard

8.1
4840 W 57th St (at Georgetown Road), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Snacks - Guion Creek · 7 tips and reviews

Mark A.Mark Apple: Turtle Sundaes are delicious

Francene C.Francene Costello: Amazing selection of delicious treats!

Derrick B.Derrick B.: Prices increased 5/18 but still worth it

Wyliepalooza is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

14. Wyliepalooza

7.6
Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · 2 tips and reviews

Chris R.Chris R: A nice sweet treat for anyone. Highly recommend the turtle sundae and peanut butter shake. (with chocolate soft serve!)

Julie S.Julie Sawyer: Treat yo'self to delish treats and cozy drinks while you continue to support locally owned and run business!

Dairy Queen is one of The 15 Best Ice Cream Parlors in Indianapolis.

15. Dairy Queen

7.5
9040 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Nora - Far Northside · 2 tips and reviews

Mike N.Mike Nelson: This service stinks in the dining room

Heather C.Heather Campbell: YAAAAAAAAAAAS