Tinker Street is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

1. Tinker Street

9.4
402 E 16th St, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Herron - Morton · 16 tips and reviews

Eric M.Eric Meininger: The menu changes seasonally but is consistently good and includes vegetarian and vegan options. The cocktails are quite good as well.

VasuVasu: All three cakes on the menu - olive oil, honey and chocolate with bourbon ice cream. Yum!

Ezra K.Ezra Katz: Everything was delicious. I had the caviar tater tots and the duck.

Bluebeard is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

2. Bluebeard

9.1
653 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 60 tips and reviews

Brian W.Brian Williams: Hard to find at first but well worth the search!

Andy @.Andy @hust0058: Don't like brussel sprouts? Get them.

Joey M.Joey Marburger: Best foie gras I've had. And I've had a lot of duck liver.

The Garden Table (Mass Ave) is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

3. The Garden Table (Mass Ave)

8.7
342 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 15 tips and reviews

Maria A.Maria Alviz: Healthy choices and great brunch spot in Mass Ave.

Jane R.Jane Rose: Brunch menu and espresso drinks!

Nicholas F.Nicholas Fennig: Eggs Benedict, cappuccino

Seasons 52 is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

4. Seasons 52

8.9
8650 Keystone Xing, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 48 tips and reviews

Brigitte M.Brigitte Mills: Grilled trout entree was not only nutritious but very tasty also. Pomegranite martini fantastic!

Visit IndyVisit Indy: Nothing is fried, live music every night, an amazing, rotating menu and delicious quail. Are you sure this is a chain?

Will M.Will McClain: You should valet. The valet service is quick and easy, and you don't have to circle around the parking lot trying to find a spot!

Milktooth is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

5. Milktooth

8.4
540 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 55 tips and reviews

Erik R.Erik Rowley: Milktooth is a great example of farm to table restaurants popping up all over Midwestern cities. Highly recommend the roasted broccoli Dutch baby pancake. Excellent coffee and hipster vibes.

Joe S.Joe Shoemaker: Though technically a full-service restaurant, the coffee prep here is fantastic!

Walt H.Walt Hughes: Everything here is good. My favorite is the Dutch pancake.

Conner’s Kitchen And Bar is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

6. Conner’s Kitchen And Bar

7.8
50 W Maryland St, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 2 tips and reviews

Brent S.Brent Smith: Brussel sprouts are amazing!

Juan B.Juan Brooks: I love the breakfast nachos

Vida is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

7. Vida

8.0
601 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 8 tips and reviews

ブルーノブルーノ: This place is amazing. I'm a foodie and I had such a surprisingly great dinner at Vida! Also loved the ambiance, the service and the cocktails. Can't wait to be back.

Kevin O.Kevin O'wings: Try the 6 selection it was awesome.

Maria A.Maria Alviz: I love this place because you can choose to have a four course meal for $65! It's great for an evening out in the city.

Public Greens: Urban Kitchen, Greens & Grill is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

8. Public Greens: Urban Kitchen, Greens & Grill

8.1
902 E 64th St, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 9 tips and reviews

Rachael L.Rachael Lee: Dog friendly spot with lots of shade and water bowls on the patio!

Dana P.Dana Parker: Their Eggs in Purgatory is so good

Scott R.Scott Riley: Fried Chicken, root beer

Mimi Blue Meatballs is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

9. Mimi Blue Meatballs

7.6
874 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 20 tips and reviews

Bill H.Bill Hendrix: Great selection of meatball types and sauces. Great comfort food!

Leslie Lynnton F.Leslie Lynnton Fuller: Buffalo meatballs recommended & fried Brussels sprouts yummy. Friendly staff, blues music.

Willie M.Willie Matis: All beef meatballs with Spicy Bolognese sauce

Drakes is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

10. Drakes

7.5
3749 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Castleton · 59 tips and reviews

Chelsea F.Chelsea Frenn: Such an amazing place!! I can't wait to try the one in cool springs

Dawn D.Dawn DeVirgilio: Bar food & Good Sushi. It does exists! Get the Crab Rangoon Roll. No, seriously - get it.

Brendan O.Brendan O'Sullivan-Hale: Burgers are good and I'm always eager to support places that give back to the community...Drakes has supported the Dayspring Center, a shelter for homeless families with children.

Skyline Club is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

11. Skyline Club

7.4
1 American Square, 36th Floor, Indianapolis, IN
Lounge · Downtown Indianapolis · 15 tips and reviews

Andy B.Andy Beall: Can't beat the atmosphere here!

Satyen J.Satyen Jhaveri: Great staff! Ask for Jamie, Cezar or Alyssa. Beth is a great bartender. Mark and his team do a great job!!

Serina K.Serina Kelly: What a great place for meetings, trainings and an office outside the office! Food is great! Try the black bean soup-yummy!!

Pioneer is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

12. Pioneer

7.2
1110 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN
Modern European Restaurant · Fountain Square · 5 tips and reviews

SarahSarah: They have a great space for live music. Drinks are a bit expensive, but the patio area is great.

Cathy C.Cathy Cooper: Excellent and creative food.

Andrew F.Andrew Furman: Steak is pretty good, but I'm gonna try something else next time.

Repeal is one of The 13 Best New American Restaurants in Indianapolis.

13. Repeal

636 Virginia Ave (College), Indianapolis, IN
Cocktail Bar · Fletcher Place · 10 tips and reviews

Robert D.Robert Dilley: Love this place! Great atmosphere, drinks, and food.

Catherine A.Catherine A: We came here for brunch and it was very tasty. They have a DIY Bloody Mary setup. I had the summer vegetable hash and it was delicious.

Brett S.Brett Saladino: Cat was a wonderful, welcoming bartender, and great drinks too.