the shrimp cocktail definitely lives up to the hype, it is a must get. Filet was good and the lamb is excellent.
St. Elmo is especially famous for its shrimp cocktail, which comes out with great to-do-four jumbo shrimp, on ice, with a generous dollop of cocktail sauce. And the steak’s pretty epic, too. Read more.
The ribeye and shrimp 🍤 cocktail are amazing.
Shrimp fettucine is delicious! Great atmosphere too.
This place is beautiful. Dress nice. I'm having a Bloody Mary. Delicious. The shrimp cocktail is amazing!
Friendly staff, great menu, high atmosphere for Indy. Try the shrimp sliders on the appetizer menu, the aged peppercorn entrusted steaks, and a nice bottle of wine for dinner.
The sour cream mashed potatoes are amazing! I hope, for your sake, the Lake Trout is on the fresh catch list - delightful (especially the chef's special prep)!
Best seafood restaraunt in the world. Amazing oysters, lobster, and fish. Amazing everything! Read more.
Crab cakes and barramundi with white wine, butter, caper sauce were amazing... Definitely coming back!
The fresh fish, shrimp cocktail, fried okra!!
Lobster roll is legit. Expensive but freshest seafood in Indy. Eat here or carry out. They cook it for you, or you can cook it yourself at home.
Great fishmarket, fish sandwiches, seafood delights!
Great service. Great food. Great times. Get the shrimp cocktail and a pomegranate martini! Thank me later. ; )
Prime rib sandwich and calamari are a must! Shrimp cocktail is just as good as advertised. Prime rib pizza is also delicious.
Of course the world famous shrimp cocktail is a must have. Have the fried green tomatoes, too.
Very nice little restaurant. The salmon sandwich was great and definitely try the Wedge salad
Pulled pork nachos and mahi mahi tacos are the way to go!
Pork nachos, mahi mahi tacos and wurst app were all awesome!
It was awesome! We sat outside on a perfect Saturday night and got the Salmon Rousille and Rainbow Trout. Cleared the plates!
PowderpuffPersians.com loves this place great oysters on the half shell. Yummy seafood. Great service. Nice location on the lake. Patty atmosphere in the summer😉
Nice outdoor seating right on the water. Start with some oysters and gumbo and then splurge for the double lobster tails
Best dinner idea: Bang Bang shrimp & corn chowder. Plus share a Bang Bang shrimp appetizer. Read more.
The lobster tails are the best!
The potstickers and bang bang shrimp are the shit it's a must try
Best place in town, meat is really tasty and with a different touch , like coffe for example. Try the Delmonico and even the crab mac & chesse is amazing
The sea bass was amazing and the steak tartare was unique but delicious. Outstanding service !
Very neat and classy place , location , ambience and service are super , tried lobester and crab burger , it's excellent
The Rock n Roll, Spicy Tura Roll, Shrimp Tempura - YUMM!
Get the soft shell crab roll!! They serve huge chunks of soft shell on the sushi. Try the unagi don as well. 6 hearty pieces of delicious unagi to all unagi lovers!! :)
Best soft shell crab anywhere.
Amazing fresh fish! Read more.
Try the Hoosier rolls or the Buffalo shrimp linguini!
Very good selection of seafood, preparations conservative but delicious. A bit pricey, particularly for lunch.
The asparagus patties were amazing and the shrimp scampi has my mouth watering a day later.
Get the mussels....I don't care if you're hungry or not...you must get them.
Amazing cuisine at decent prices. Only open for dinner, but oh so worth the wait. Get the crab cakes!
Loved the moscato and Coopers Hawk White. Tilapia sandwich was amazing!
We loved the orange moscato and Coopers Hawk White! The tilapia sandwich was amazing!
Very much enjoyed the gnocchi w/roasted butternut squash & I don't even like veggies! Husband loved the beef short ribs w/risotto. daughter loved the trio medallions & in law loved the salmon! A win!
The crab cakes were simply awesome!
Lobster Mac and Cheese deserves a spot on every table!
Great food, great atmosphere, great service! Oysters and spicy shrimp cocktail are fantastic!
The taco are awesome!!!! Defiantly try the fish taco!!!! So good!!! While your there get a pitcher of margaritas!!! Great place to hang with friends!!!
Fish tacos are awesome!
Best tacos in town. Short rib and fish are my favorites.
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA