The Yard is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

1. The Yard

7.8
500 W Florida St (at Iron Horse Hotel), Milwaukee, WI
Lounge · Walker's Point · 12 tips and reviews

Melissa S.Melissa Sherman: Loved the wood-fired pepperoni pizza!

Neen J.Neen James: Order the Ginger snap cocktail delicious! Also tried the apricourt cocktail!

Aaron P.Aaron Polzin: Love the outdoor patio!

Ian's Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

2. Ian's Pizza

8.4
146 E Juneau Ave (Water Street), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Juneau Town · 31 tips and reviews

Mark B.Mark Brouch: Pizzaception: Take a 12" pepperoni pizza and dice it up and sprinkle it on a 20" pizza. Also known as the Yo Dawg I Heard You Liek Pizza pizza.

Tom N.Tom Nawara: Crazy pizza toppings (Mac & cheese! Penne & broccoli!) and a really friendly staff.

Allysha H.Allysha Heenan: I'm a baller and I party with Conan. Get the Mac n cheese if you're American.

Balistreri's Italian American Ristorante is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

3. Balistreri's Italian American Ristorante

8.6
812 N 68th St (Wells St), Milwaukee, WI
Italian Restaurant · 46 tips and reviews

Shanice H.Shanice Hemphill: Love the think crust sausage & pepperoni pizza.

Elizabeth G.Elizabeth G: Love the pizza, egg plant fries, and cheesy bread

MyCommunityNOWMyCommunityNOW: Not in the mood for thin-crust pizza? Try the chicken Parmesan, a signature dish (via @GrabaBiteNOW). Read more.

Einstein Bros. Bagels is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

4. Einstein Bros. Bagels

7.9
544 E Ogden Ave,, Milwaukee, WI
Bagel Shop · Lower East Side · 24 tips and reviews

Marissa H.Marissa Hansen: Love their pepperoni pizza bagels!

Rae W.Rae Waters: The thin bagel egg white with swiss, asparagus and mushrooms is awesome!

Dan S.Dan Saper: The service here is miserable...but I keep coming back!

Sal's Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

5. Sal's Pizza

7.6
2040 W Wisconsin Ave (21th St), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Avenues West · 16 tips and reviews

Dan P.Dan Peznola: Love Sal's! Pizza is great, and slices are huge, two will be more than enough. The only problem I have is with their weekend hours; they don't stay open as late as many of the other places on campus.

Jennifer W.Jennifer Wallis: Chicken Parm dinner is amazing

Rashad M.Rashad Matthews: Bacon cheeseburger pizza...... Finna destroy

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

6. The Cheesecake Factory

8.1
5799 N Bayshore Dr # L100 (at Bayshore Town Center), Glendale, WI
American Restaurant · 61 tips and reviews

Gaby T.Gaby Turer: The Chicken Di Pana is to DIE for. you cant pass up the chocolate mousse cheesecake too.

Barbara H.Barbara H: MUST GET: RASPBERRY LEMONADE

Michelle S.Michelle Sniff: Fried macaroni balls!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

7. The Cheesecake Factory

8.4
2350 N Mayfair Rd (at Mayfair Mall), Wauwatosa, WI
American Restaurant · 80 tips and reviews

Sean M.Sean Mondt: Wow, fish was very good and the Key Lime Cheesecake was amazing. Cheesecake will never be the same.

Chelsey A.Chelsey A: Order Stefanie's Ultimate Red Velvet Cheesecake. You will NOT be disappointed!

Michelle K.Michelle Krajewski: The Buffalo Blasts appetizer is sooo good. Spicy and delicious!

Shi Chai is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

8. Shi Chai

7.6
832 E Center St (N Bremen St), Milwaukee, WI
Hookah Bar · Riverwest · 21 tips and reviews

BrittRBrittR: My favorite hangout. Excellent service, great hookah and delicious food! Wouldn't want to go anywhere else :)

David M.David Moody: Just ask Saif, he'll take care of it...

Dick S.Dick Steel: Try the juicy pussy

Nonna Bartolotta's is one of The 9 Best Places for Pepperoni Pizza in Milwaukee.

9. Nonna Bartolotta's

6.6
Concourse D (MKE Airport), Milwaukee, WI
Italian Restaurant · Mitchell Field · 35 tips and reviews

RaeRae: Spicy pepperoni pizza was good with a nice side caesar. Service from Carmen was outstanding! Very friendly, attentive, and professional. Try the salted caramel gelato!

Steve K.Steve Knier: Magarhita pizza is strong

Mickey H.Mickey Hipp: Spotted cow Yum @ grandmas