Gray's Papaya is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

1. Gray's Papaya

8.1
2090 Broadway (at W 72nd St), New York, NY
Hot Dog Joint · Lincoln Square · 246 tips and reviews

Izzy R.Izzy Rock: Piña colada !!! Great!!!!

NellieNellie: Friendly Filipino staff tonight! A filipino station was playing on the radio lol. Hotdogs were okay and piña colada as well as coconut champagne were a little too sweet. But I'm glad we tried it!

What's Good HereWhat's Good Here: Gray's is a NY institution. Come in on a late night and order the two hot dog special with a piña colada drink to wash it down.

CupcakeStop is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

2. CupcakeStop

8.3
(See Twitter for current location), New York, NY
Cupcake Shop · SoHo · 20 tips and reviews

gabi p.gabi porter: Get the Elvis or the Pina Colada

Mohammed C.Mohammed C.: French Toast cupcake is my favorite. Tastes exactly as advertised!

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Anything from their seasonal menu is spectacular, but this regular is vanilla butter cake, dyed a festive array of colors, topped with a swirl vanilla frosting and finished with rainbow colored sugar.

The Calaveras is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

3. The Calaveras

7.6
949 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Upper West Side · 4 tips and reviews

Christina L.Christina Louise: Frozen Pina Colada is amazing!

Lisa D.Lisa Day: Best tacos!

Elizabeth B.Elizabeth Burstein: Corn soup so good

Mr. Fong's is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

4. Mr. Fong's

8.9
40 Market St (btw Madison St & Henry St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Two Bridges · 56 tips and reviews

VivianVivian: Their take on a piña colada tasted like a delicious curry soup! Also try the michelada — best I’ve had to date :)

AmandaAmanda: Get Fong's Colada! A vibrant fusion of coconut, lemongrass, and pandan. My new favorite summer cocktail.

stephiedoostephiedoo: The Salty Plum Old Fashioned is yum, and the bacon buns are just enough to hold you over before dinner.

Negril Village is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

5. Negril Village

8.4
70 W 3rd St (at Bleecker St.), New York, NY
Caribbean Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 146 tips and reviews

Les G.Les Grant: The Pina colada Sorrel is the best!!

Akiko B.Akiko Bombita: Great reggae and fun vibe in the middle of the city. Get breakfast for dinner: ackee and saltfish, boiled banana and dumpling. Pina coladas are pretty good.

Elvis R.Elvis Rodricks: Wow.... this place is a blessing for Manhattanites! loved their oxtail stew- similar to Negril, Jamaica. Also, they have wrey and nephew rum for the brave rum lovers! Dont miss this authentic spot.

Tommy Bahama Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

6. Tommy Bahama Restaurant

8.3
551 5th Ave (at W 45th St), New York, NY
Hawaiian Restaurant · Midtown East · 87 tips and reviews

Emily B.Emily Brimmer: The piña colada cake is life changing!

Courtney L.Courtney Lewis: My parents’ favorite place to eat in NYC. Start w/ the Macadamia Crusted Goat Cheese. Get the Parmesan Crusted Sanibel Chicken w/ Cauliflower Potato Mash as the main. Finish w/ the Piña Colada Cake.

Emily R.Emily Roy: the BEST restaurant in midtown. Deliciously strong drinks, yummy seafood apps, and a great scene often with live music!

Juice Generation is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

7. Juice Generation

8.4
122 E 42nd St (Park Ave & Lexington Ave), New York, NY
Juice Bar · Midtown East · 49 tips and reviews

JaisyJaisy: Kale Colada is so yummy

M23M23: I like the smoothie called "I Love Watermelon" as well as the Vegan Gluten Free Maki Rolls.

Erica S.Erica Sklar: I love watermelon smoothie, hail to Kale juice and the hot cold warrior drinks are so good. The Kale avocado salad is tasty too and the staff is really friendly

Juice Generation is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

8. Juice Generation

8.6
117 W 72nd St (at Columbus Ave), New York, NY
Juice Bar · Upper West Side · 64 tips and reviews

Damian B.Damian Bayona: Get the Kale Colada served in a coconut and be the envy of all your friends. Great way to balance your PH

Mrs L.Mrs L: Shot of wheatgrass w/ginger, & the peanutbutter split smoothie is delish. Lots of raw goodies & funky beats.

Anita M.Anita Moore: Its all about the supa dupa greens

Ricardo Steak House is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

9. Ricardo Steak House

8.6
2145 2nd Ave (btwn 110th & 111st St), New York, NY
Steakhouse · East Harlem · 86 tips and reviews

Donell H.Donell Hinds: The pina coladas awesome! They have a way to make you feel..... like family. Stop by and check it out. Also have a good time. :D

Gigi C.Gigi C: Love this place! My penne a la vodka w grilled chicken was amazing! Staff is great! The sangria is good. A+ for having a great dj playing dope music.

ChantalChantal: Great steaks seafood and sangrias!!!!!

Miss Lily's 7A is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

10. Miss Lily's 7A

8.9
109 Avenue A (at E 7th St), New York, NY
Caribbean Restaurant · East Village · 170 tips and reviews

Jean L.Jean L.: One of the city's best pina coladas

EaterEater: Miss Lily’s 7A Cafe, is the perfect date night spot with reggae records on the walls and a cozy atmosphere. Menu standouts include sorrel glazed pork ribs and oxtail with butter beans.

Patrick H.Patrick Hayes: Excellent food. Great cocktails. Get the jerk anything.

Bazar Tapas Bar and Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

11. Bazar Tapas Bar and Restaurant

7.3
31 W 26th St, New York, NY
Tapas Restaurant · NoMad · 13 tips and reviews

eurika d.eurika destin: The drinks!! Bazar Colada was amazing!

Allison N.Allison Niksich: Everything was great here - I highly recommend! Try the tuna tar tar, octopus & shishito peppers. Great vibe and cool atmosphere

Umaimah S.Umaimah Sharwani: the ambience is lovely but the food isn’t the best.

Red Lobster is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

12. Red Lobster

7.5
5 Times Sq Fl 1 (at W 41st St.), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 232 tips and reviews

Elke M.Elke Medina: Red passion pina colada & their biscuits _ yummm :)

Jessica V.Jessica V.: Sunset Passion Colada!!!

Hana S.Hana Slevin: LobsterFest! Cheddar Cheese Buscuits! If you have a wait for a table, hang at the bar and get a Sunset Passion Colada.

Virgil's Real BBQ is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

13. Virgil's Real BBQ

7.9
152 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 6th Ave), New York, NY
BBQ Joint · Theater District · 273 tips and reviews

Kawme F.Kawme Ferdinand: Wings are not but for the ladies the Pina Colada is awesome.

Ramon R.Ramon Rojas: Ahhh miss the Pina Coladas. Cant wait to indulge again!

Jason Y.Jason Yarborough: Get the wings. You won't regret it. Probably the best you'll ever have.

Otto's Shrunken Head is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

14. Otto's Shrunken Head

7.3
538 E 14th St (btwn Avenue A & B), New York, NY
Bar · Stuyvesant Town - Peter Cooper Village · 127 tips and reviews

Raj S.Raj S.: Get the piña colada. Don't get anything else.

Annie T.Annie T: Shrunken Head and Mai Tai. The Pina Colada tasted way too processed. Would stay away from frozen stuff and stick with their signature drinks.

Nate F.Nate Folkert: piña piña is a very good piña colada mocktail

Pier I Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Colada in New York City.

15. Pier I Cafe

8.9
W 70th St (at Riverside Blvd), New York, NY
Café · Lincoln Square · 179 tips and reviews

Psychedelic MessPsychedelic Mess: wow amazing date spot in the summer time, the food is delish and the drinks range from beer to yummy cocktails. I LOVE the piña colada taste just like icecream

Eric F.Eric Friedman: Really great outdoor bar and food by the water. Excellent service and lots of options in the sun or shade. Take a walk on the waterfront when you are done sipping your cocktails.

NYC ParksNYC Parks: There is no better time to go than on a summer evening when you can sit on the water and enjoy a beer and great burger.