16 Handles is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

1. 16 Handles

8.3
325 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 75th & 76th St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Upper West Side · 50 tips and reviews

Lindsay W.Lindsay W: Love to get a cookies 'n' cream + coffee froyo combo. Add some Oreo crumbles and fruit and you're good to go.

Ashley N.Ashley Nicole 💍⚓💙: Red velvet ..salted Carmel...cookies & cream & vanilla are all delishhh

Shoshana S.Shoshana S: So yummy ! The hot fudge is great and when u blend it it'a also really good

Milk & Cream Cereal Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

2. Milk & Cream Cereal Bar

8.1
159 Mott St (Grand Street and Broom Street), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Little Italy · 42 tips and reviews

Ricky N.Ricky Nguyen: Their cookie dough ice cream blended with cereal and fresh fruits 💯🔥

Sunny K.Sunny Kim: I got the cookie dough ice cream with honey oats cereal & toasted coconut flakes with a drizzle of honey. Very sweet and generous serving. I'd recommend sharing to minimize the guilt 😆

Connie C.Connie Chiu: So good and cute inside! Cookie dough ice cream base with Reese’s puffs and teddy gram. Huge portions.

Sedutto is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

3. Sedutto

8.4
1498 1st Ave (btw 78th and 79th St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Upper East Side · 45 tips and reviews

Arielle S.Arielle Smith: Chocolate Cookies & Cream. Yummmmmm.

Allie H.Allie Hunt: Best ice cream on the UES. Try the cookies & cream 👍

Yaz S.Yaz S: Delicious and creative ice cream flavors. Great spot in the UES

Schmackary's is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

4. Schmackary's

8.8
362 W 45th St (at 9th Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Hell's Kitchen · 287 tips and reviews

Tasting TableTasting Table: Dunk sugar-bomb cookies (such as the Cookies & Cream made with dark cocoa powder, white chocolate, Oreo pieces and vanilla buttercream frosting) in chilled milk or hot coffee until midnight here: Read more.

Adrienne C.Adrienne C: Maple bacon is pretty solid but I think the real winner was Red Velvet. We tried the two aforementioned as well as Blueberry, Choc PB, Ginger, Cookies n Cream, and lemon poppy shmackentash.

Reagan B.Reagan Barbosa: Cookies & Cream is my favorite😋

16 Handles is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

5. 16 Handles

8.2
178 8th Ave (at 19th St.), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Chelsea · 41 tips and reviews

Brian M.Brian McFadden: People complain about the prevalence of froyo places in NYC, but it's hard to complain if you're a patron. This stuff is good! I go for a cookies 'n' cream setup + a few more flavors, like cheesecake.

NicoleNicole: Cookies & cream froyo with cheesecake bites, crushed Oreos, and cookies & cream bark pieces will satisfy any Oreo milkshake cravings. Clean location, great for my allergies.

Lee H.Lee Hoffman: Love this place, Cookies and cream is my goto, but coconut custard (seasonal) is amazing

Emack & Bolio's Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

6. Emack & Bolio's Ice Cream

9.0
1564 1st Ave (btwn 81st St & 82nd St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Yorkville · 84 tips and reviews

Prakash A.Prakash Arjunan: Space cake, cookies & cream, toasted smoreo & cosmic crunch - ridonculous!!

Jessie C.Jessie Catana: Such a cute lil place! Delicious and creative flavors

Anthony C.Anthony Ciolino: These people do things to Oreos that Paula Deen can only dream about

Sundaes and Cones is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

7. Sundaes and Cones

8.9
95 E 10th St (btwn 3rd & 4th Ave), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · East Village · 293 tips and reviews

Chris H.Chris Harding: The best cookies n cream in the city!

Betül Y.Betül YILDIZ 🌴: Incredible cookie cream milkshake babe!

Rami M.Rami Massoud: Lots of very tasty unique flavors and a great space

Harlem Shake is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

8. Harlem Shake

8.2
100 W 124th St (at Lenox Ave), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Central Harlem · 175 tips and reviews

AnthonyAnthony: Amazingly delicious milkshakes and burgers. Try the jerk burger and a cookies n cream milkshake. Always opt for the larger milkshake size!

Asli S.Asli S: Cookies n cream milkshake 😍

Derek P.Derek Penn: Burger was nice and tasty . Try the classic

Baked By Melissa is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

9. Baked By Melissa

7.9
1585 Broadway (on 47th), New York, NY
Bakery · Theater District · 23 tips and reviews

Alice N.Alice Nam: Cupcaron and milk cookie cream! Check them out this month before too late

Jen N.Jen Nay: Love this Place! It is a must if you are visiting New York.

Linnie D.Linnie D: Get six to go and eat them at intermission.

Chick-fil-A is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

10. Chick-fil-A

8.4
700 Avenue of the Americas (at W 22nd St), New York, NY
Fast Food Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews

Mark J.Mark Jimenez: The Original Chicken Sandwich and the Mac & Cheese

RickyRicky: Remember to check your order before you leave,I’ve gotten two wrong orders!

Eugene K.Eugene Kimberg: Bathroom Code 062120

Chick-fil-A is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

11. Chick-fil-A

8.3
918 8th Ave, New York, NY
Fast Food Restaurant · Theater District · 4 tips and reviews

HowardHoward: Large and brand new. Plenty of seats. Best yet in nyc

Alison J.Alison J.: Great food. Don't let lines deter you. The team taking orders via iPads will get you in and out quickly.

Will H.Will Harahan: Terrific staff and great food.

Black Tap is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

12. Black Tap

8.5
529 Broome St (btwn Thompson & Sullivan St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · SoHo · 222 tips and reviews

Deven M.Deven Marte: I thought the Texan Burger would be greasy- It was not! Incredibly juicy, and the bacon was prime cut! Paired with a super cookies & Cream milkshake 😍😋

Federico A.Federico Asara: Au poivre. Get it. You need it. Staff is great and there is a good selection of beer.

PureWowPureWow: The classic burger is great, but we’re more about “the Mexican”: a chorizo burger with jack cheese, pickled jalapeños and chipotle mayo. Followed by a decadently thick milkshake, of course. Read more.

STK Downtown is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

13. STK Downtown

8.2
26 Little W 12th St (btwn 9th Ave & Washington St), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Meatpacking District · 155 tips and reviews

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Birthday cake - Almond torte, cookie dough ice cream, vanilla rum butter cream

Gianna L.Gianna Lohnn: Great restaurant week menu! Perfectly cooked steak and wonderful appetizers

Peter F.Peter Friedman: Tuna Tartare is excellent

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

14. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

9.1
48 1/2 E 7th St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · East Village · 307 tips and reviews

Max W.Max Wenneker: Chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream. Avoid the sprinkles, too crunchy

Natalie L.Natalie LeMoss: Incredible ice cream, highly recommend the Mario berry cheesecake.

Will H.Will Hou: try the gianduja ice cream

Bibble & Sip is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies & Cream in New York City.

15. Bibble & Sip

8.5
253 W 51st St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Coffee Shop · Theater District · 266 tips and reviews

Asli S.Asli S: Cutest desserts! Try the cookies & cream puff & biggie macaron

Cat L.Cat Lo: Amazing Matcha Jasmine Latte and Pistachio Cake with Rasberry Gelee is really great.

Christine W.Christine Wong: lavender latte is so nice :)