4. Schmackary's
8.8
362 W 45th St (at 9th Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Hell's Kitchen · 287 tips and reviews
Tasting Table: Dunk sugar-bomb cookies (such as the Cookies & Cream made with dark cocoa powder, white chocolate, Oreo pieces and vanilla buttercream frosting) in chilled milk or hot coffee until midnight here: Read more.
Adrienne C: Maple bacon is pretty solid but I think the real winner was Red Velvet. We tried the two aforementioned as well as Blueberry, Choc PB, Ginger, Cookies n Cream, and lemon poppy shmackentash.
Reagan Barbosa: Cookies & Cream is my favorite😋
5. 16 Handles
8.2
178 8th Ave (at 19th St.), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Chelsea · 41 tips and reviews
Brian McFadden: People complain about the prevalence of froyo places in NYC, but it's hard to complain if you're a patron. This stuff is good! I go for a cookies 'n' cream setup + a few more flavors, like cheesecake.
Nicole: Cookies & cream froyo with cheesecake bites, crushed Oreos, and cookies & cream bark pieces will satisfy any Oreo milkshake cravings. Clean location, great for my allergies.
Lee Hoffman: Love this place, Cookies and cream is my goto, but coconut custard (seasonal) is amazing
12. Black Tap
8.5
529 Broome St (btwn Thompson & Sullivan St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · SoHo · 222 tips and reviews
Deven Marte: I thought the Texan Burger would be greasy- It was not! Incredibly juicy, and the bacon was prime cut! Paired with a super cookies & Cream milkshake 😍😋
Federico Asara: Au poivre. Get it. You need it. Staff is great and there is a good selection of beer.
PureWow: The classic burger is great, but we’re more about “the Mexican”: a chorizo burger with jack cheese, pickled jalapeños and chipotle mayo. Followed by a decadently thick milkshake, of course. Read more.