Extra Virgin is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

1. Extra Virgin

8.3
259 W 4th St (btwn Charles & Perry St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 240 tips and reviews

Melody K.Melody Koh: try the monte cristo sandwich- a great combination of "french toast-like" bread with honey ham & smoke turkey

Vanessa B.Vanessa Borgonio: The monte cristo sandwich..Yum!!!!!!!!!!!!

Jeremy B.Jeremy Burns: Amazing brunch, Monte cristo sandwich is da bomb. Try your best to get a seat outside.

Golden Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

2. Golden Diner

8.7
123 Madison St (at Market St), New York, NY
Diner · 35 tips and reviews

Jennifer Y.Jennifer Yu: Monte Cristo: sesame scallion French toast with country ham and gravy 🙌🏼

MarcMarc: GrubHub - NYC ExcitingNew Brgs Sept'19: Golden Chzbrger - feat. a blend of chuck, short rib, & brisket; Asn influences in form of a sesame-scallion milk bun & mushroom-kochujang sauce (spicy & funky)

Zach H.Zach Hamed: Pancakes (with berries) might be the best I’ve had in new york (even better than Clinton St. Baking Co). Chicken club and egg sandwich were also really good

Stage Door Delicatessen is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

3. Stage Door Delicatessen

7.8
26 Vesey St (Church St), New York, NY
Sandwich Spot · Financial District · 42 tips and reviews

Sabri C.Sabri Cittadino: Try toasted monte cristo :)

Tyler J.Tyler Jones: AMAZING! This is well among the best food I have ever had in New York City! The portions are HUGE and diverse!

Capt AwesomeCapt Awesome: Tourist pricing, tourists all over, mediocre food, avoid

Bingo Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

4. Bingo Deli

7.4
77 Pearl St, New York, NY
Deli · Financial District · 18 tips and reviews

Brandon B.Brandon Browne: Monte Cristo is excellent

John L.John LeVine: Order the Cocowawa for lunch. It's a delicious grilled chicken, fresh avocado, lettuce, and cheese sandwich. Get it on a roll.

Katherine A.Katherine Anne: Great sandwiches great price for this area

EJ's Luncheonette is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

5. EJ's Luncheonette

7.6
1271 3rd Ave (at E 73rd St), New York, NY
Diner · Upper East Side · 98 tips and reviews

EJ's LuncheonetteEJ's Luncheonette: Lunch Specials: 1) Penne with Shrimp Marinara 2) BBQ Turkey Meatloaf Sandwich 3) Deluxe Crunchy Monte Cristo 4) Grilled Asian Salmon Salad. For More Menu Options Visit www.ejsluncheonette.com

Eric K.Eric K: Always go for the French toast with some strawberries on top - it comes highly recommended! Really nice with some butter on it too. Amen.

Talia G.Talia Goldberg: Breakfast all day. The ideal brunch spot.

Theater Row is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

6. Theater Row

7.9
410 W 42nd St (btw 9th & 10th), New York, NY
Theater · Hell's Kitchen · 13 tips and reviews

Pat D.Pat Dwyer: Great space! Comfy seat rows w/legroom and good site lines.

Brian B.Brian Butler: Marvelous wonderettes

Cameron G.Cameron Gidari: I love that they support small and independent theatre, but I wish they had better AC. It was sweltering in the 4th-floor theater.

Stage Star Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

7. Stage Star Deli

7.8
105 W 55th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Deli · Theater District · 13 tips and reviews

Pablo C.Pablo Castillon: All the sandwiches are great at this quintessential deli... But the cheesecakes are true New York.

Anisa A.Anisa Alhilali: Love the unlimited toppings salad bar. Lots of great options including grape leaves and small size is plenty big. And they also throw in cornbread free when they have it

New York Hilton MidtownNew York Hilton Midtown: Offers a varied menu making it a great breakfast or lunch stop on your way out of the hotel!

Mansion Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

8. Mansion Restaurant

8.0
1634 York Ave, New York, NY
Diner · Yorkville · 65 tips and reviews

LaurenLauren: Best diner on the UES. Solid staples: eggs, home fries, wraps, etc. Great service & staff, too.

Ruben B.Ruben Brosbe: The York Ave is without a doubt the best item on a very solid menu

Anna O.Anna Osgoodby: One of my favorite diners around the UES. The staff is great, the menu selection can't be beat and the food is delicious!

Green Gourmet is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

9. Green Gourmet

7.9
1368 York Ave (East 73rd & York Ave), New York, NY
Deli · Upper East Side · 22 tips and reviews

GDBGDB: Very nice deli: try the fresh made sushi or muffins!

Jonathan R.Jonathan Richards: Great breakfast wraps!

Kathleen O.Kathleen Osborne: Everything is fresh. So much gfree products to choose from. Some things are a bit pricey, but seriously, the options outweigh cost.

Church Street Kitchen is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

10. Church Street Kitchen

7.1
178 Church St, New York, NY
Deli · Tribeca · 3 tips and reviews

KMP BlogKMP Blog: Really good food. Get an avocado sandwich. Worth every cent.

D. B.D. Bloch: Friendliest short order in the neighborhood.

D. B.D. Bloch: Their cookies are made fresh.

The Bread Factory Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

11. The Bread Factory Cafe

7.2
935 8th Ave (btw 55th & 56th), New York, NY
Bakery · Theater District · 14 tips and reviews

Alexandra L.Alexandra Levitas: Amazing assortment of all snacks and sandwiches. Good take out (go sit in Central Park) but also nice seating. Yummy pastries, good sandwiches.

NedNed: Superb plain cheese pizza slice

Jon M.Jon McHatton: Order before you check in!:)

Murray Hill Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

12. Murray Hill Diner

7.5
222 Lexington Ave (at 33rd St), New York, NY
Diner · Rose Hill · 50 tips and reviews

Nick H.Nick Harris: Possibly the best and cleanest diner in the area

Nick H.Nick H: Great breakfast wrap options.

Katie L.Katie Lynn: So CLEAN!!!! try the Belgian Waffles, eggs and ham!

Square Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

13. Square Diner

7.6
33 Leonard St (at Varick St), New York, NY
Diner · Tribeca · 56 tips and reviews

John M.John McCrory: Probably my favorite diner in the city. The burgers are charbroiled. Great with a thick chocolate shake.

Corey C.Corey Crago: It's a diner; it's cheap, it's good, and it's in New York. There aren't enough places like this left.

Max R.Max Rodriguez: Comfort food...popular with locals and blue collar types.

Waverly Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

14. Waverly Restaurant

7.8
385 Avenue of the Americas (at Waverly Pl), New York, NY
Diner · West Village · 107 tips and reviews

Sara .Sara 🌈⚔🍾: My favorite diner in the city! Classic. Great for breakfast food and late night fixes.

Varun S.Varun Shetty: Best diner in the city. Come late and become friends with Kumar and Bobby

Caitlin C.Caitlin Coburn: Waverly melt. Delicious. Nom Nom Nom

'Essen is one of The 15 Best Places for Monte Cristo Sandwiches in New York City.

15. 'Essen

7.3
515 Madison Ave (at E 53rd St.), New York, NY
Deli · Midtown East · 28 tips and reviews

Kenny C.Kenny Costello: Great place to get food if you feel like you would like to eat some food. And they have the items usually found at a Botega, so it's a great combo with all you need. Tastes delicious too!!

P-LO L.P-LO Louis: Their shrimp shumai udon soup is to die for :-) #enjoy

Imani G.Imani G: Shakes and Fresh juices are delicious and healthy.