Welcome to one of my favorite places to eat. You seriously can't go wrong with anything on this menu but I suggest: turkey on a roll, chicken parm platter, Saratoga Club, and the ice cream cake!
The place feels like a lively night downtown, circa 1958. Classics include linguine & clams, veal Parmesan, chicken scarpariello & lobster fra diavolo. Full Menu - http://goo.gl/IkIR5 Read more.
The chicken or veal parm is to die for. The food is great. It gets loud around 7-8pm and seating is tight. A little pricey.
If you are a fan of very thin (almost cracker-like) crust, the pizza here is the best we have found of that style in the city - the large-format lasagna and chicken parm are also excellent.
At brunch, the pancakes, and the French toast are both delicious, and the chicken parmesan sandwich may be one of the best in the city - no lie!