Shake Shack is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

1. Shake Shack

8.6
366 Columbus Ave (at W 77th St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Upper West Side · 509 tips and reviews

Drazzel F.Drazzel Feliu: Shack Stack, Fries, and Peanut Butter Shake. So worth the wait and the hustling for seats.

Rachel C.Rachel Clark: Looove the peanut butter shakes.

Joanna L.Joanna Liff: The peanut butter shake is amazing!

Shake Shack is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

2. Shake Shack

8.8
691 8th Ave (at W 44th St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Theater District · 855 tips and reviews

Cherry LynnCherry Lynn: Thumbs up to the indoor Shake Shack! Shackburger's a must & the Peanut Butter shake is yummy! Very nice staff, insisted upon giving me an extra treat for free when my buzzer didn't ring!

Artemis S.Artemis Sara: Love the peanut butter shake!!!

Leo W.Leo Waka: Delicious hamburguers... Must try the peanut butter shake!! A little crowed... Should be a little bigger place, because there are tons of tourists

Bareburger is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

3. Bareburger

7.8
514 3rd Ave (30th), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Rose Hill · 146 tips and reviews

Matt28800 @.Matt28800 @: It is less about IF you eat here and more about how often you eat here...it's great! veggie jalapeño burger is so good! Chocolate peanut butter shake is also great!

Laurent M.Laurent Magloire: Lean burgers. Great ingredients. Love the lamp burger with multigrain bread.

ZenFoodsterZenFoodster: Brunch is yummy. ;8

Black Tap is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

4. Black Tap

8.5
529 Broome St (btwn Thompson & Sullivan St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · SoHo · 222 tips and reviews

Amy M.Amy Mixa: Loved the Mexican burger and the peanut butter shake...so full!

Christian S.Christian Stangier: Good selection of craft beers and ... - of course - delicious burgers!

PureWowPureWow: The classic burger is great, but we’re more about “the Mexican”: a chorizo burger with jack cheese, pickled jalapeños and chipotle mayo. Followed by a decadently thick milkshake, of course. Read more.

abcV is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

5. abcV

8.6
38 E 19th St (btwn Broadway & Park Ave), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Flatiron District · 101 tips and reviews

NancyNancy: Exquisite combination of flavors & textures, beautifully presented, & lovely atmosphere. All delicious, but today had humus, beet salad & a peanut butter shake- wow! Expensive, small plates, filling

Anna K.Anna Kramer: Hummus, cauliflower and pine nut dip were all amazing!

Nikhita M.Nikhita Mahtani: So yummy!! And healthy! Get the labneh, dosa, spaghetti ❤️

Schnipper's Quality Kitchen is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

6. Schnipper's Quality Kitchen

1 Madison Ave (at E 23rd St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · NoMad · 193 tips and reviews

Juan S.Juan Sanchez: Chocolate peanut butter shake is amazing

Manjari R.Manjari Rastogi: The veggie and goat cheese sandwich is delicious! Pro-tip: Ask for some of schnipper’s special sauce on the side.

Cesar R.Cesar Razuri: Bathroom code is on the receipt.

Schnipper's is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

7. Schnipper's

7.7
620 8th Ave (at W 41st St), New York, NY
Comfort Food Restaurant · Theater District · 313 tips and reviews

Raymond C.Raymond Colón: Chocolate peanut butter shake is very tasty, but not tasty enough for a 15 minute wait at that price (~$7.50)

Monee P.Monee Perry: Love: fish and chips, all the salads, chicken strips, mac n cheese, sweet tea!

Matthew K.Matthew Knell: The Sloppy Joe here is exceptional.

Westerly Natural Market is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

8. Westerly Natural Market

9.0
911 8th Avenue (at 54th St), New York, NY
Grocery Store · Hell's Kitchen · 92 tips and reviews

Elevine B.Elevine Berge: Delish raw vegan spirulina cake from the incredibly well stocked raw cake shelf by the juice bar at the back! With a glass of choc almond milk it was the perfect treat for a day like this 😄

Zachary Adam C.Zachary Adam Cohen: Smells like hippies and amniotic fluid here. Their apple cider vinegar is fun for enemas. Watch out for blind gypsys. They steal ur wallet.

BluePrintBluePrint: Standing ovation for Westerly Natural Market's convenient location and abundance of healthy treats. We love stopping in for a refreshing pre- or post- theatre BluePrintJuice!

Bareburger is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

9. Bareburger

8.3
535 Laguardia Pl (at Bleecker St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Greenwich Village · 193 tips and reviews

Leah M.Leah Melby: One of the best turkey burgers I've ever has. The peanut butter shake's amazing, too. (totally worth it)

Jeanne C.Jeanne Cho: Get the chocolate peanut butter shake. Dogs on patio!👍🎉

Jeanne C.Jeanne Cho: My first visit and surprised that their fries weren't greasy, turkey burger didn't suck, and the chocolate peanut butter shake stole my virginity.

Clinton St. Baking Co. & Restaurant is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

10. Clinton St. Baking Co. & Restaurant

8.6
4 Clinton St (at E Houston St), New York, NY
Bakery · Lower East Side · 973 tips and reviews

Daniel C.Daniel Cape: Yes, yes... Blueberry pancakes, sugar-cured bacon... It's all true. (Chocolate peanut butter shake is also a nice touch.)

🔹Maria L🔹🔹Maria L🔹: Dont miss this brunch eatery!! Blueberry pancakes are my favorite!!

ThrillistThrillist: Pancakes that are worth the five-hour wait on a Saturday, but if you go during the week you just might beat the crowd...

Bill's Bar & Burger is one of The 11 Best Places for Peanut Butter Shakes in New York City.

11. Bill's Bar & Burger

7.8
16 West 51st St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Rockefeller Center · 356 tips and reviews

Gal A.Gal Amir: The onion soup burger with maple bacon is to die for!! The nachos are great as well.. For desert take the Chocolate Peanut butter shake.

Lizzie H.Lizzie Hatfield: Yummy burgers and not too pricey considering location in Rockefeller Center. Get maple bacon in your burger!

Time Out New YorkTime Out New York: Here, Chef Brett Reichler smashes the beef patty thin and sears it hard on the flattop for a crusty-on-the-outside, juicy-on-the-inside consistency. (Readers Choice) Read more.