Joanne Trattoria is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

1. Joanne Trattoria

7.7
70 W 68th St (at Columbus Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 64 tips and reviews

Jalina B.Jalina Beck: The lemon chicken was delicious. Also try the mac and cheese. Stuffed mushrooms. Red velvet cake for dessert!

Michael G.Michael Gogel: Have the stuffed mushrooms or become one!

ReemzReemz: Go for the stuffed mushroom and the eggplant meatballs

Harry's Italian Pizza Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

2. Harry's Italian Pizza Bar

7.8
2 Gold St (at Maiden Ln.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Financial District · 139 tips and reviews

Jackie K.Jackie K: The stuffed mushrooms are great!

Benji K.Benji K: Great place, but a few items fall short. Stuffed mushrooms lack a variety of flavors and, even though not fried, are sitting in a pool of oil.

Lee H.Lee Hoffman: Stuffed mushrooms are amazing

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

3. Carmine’s Italian Restaurant

8.9
200 W 44th St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 564 tips and reviews

Anabel T.Anabel Teixeira: Try the shrimp parmigiana and the stuffed mushrooms! Delish :)

RozRoz: The stuffed mushrooms might just be the best I've had in my life! :)

Spotted by Locals - city guides by localsSpotted by Locals - city guides by locals: You simply must try the stuffed mushroom appetizer and the Manicotti main dish! Read more.

Harry's is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

4. Harry's

8.6
1 Hanover Sq, New York, NY
Steakhouse · Financial District · 123 tips and reviews

Stephanie K.Stephanie K: Make sure to try the lobster stuffed mushrooms as an appetizer. The citrus/white wine sauce is amazing!

Nicholas M.Nicholas M.: Salmon, burger, steak sandwich, seared tuna, lobster fried rice

The Wall Street JournalThe Wall Street Journal: Head to the formal dining room in the rear. Harry's is at its best with its classics, like the hanger steak ($25) and a bouquet of french fries ($8.50) on the side. Read more.

El Pote is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

5. El Pote

7.9
718 2nd Ave (btwn 38th and 39th St.), New York, NY
Spanish Restaurant · Murray Hill · 18 tips and reviews

Frank F.Frank Fayer: Paella Valencia, pitcher of sangria. Stuffed mushrooms are good too. Great ambiance, maybe a bit too bright.

Ashley O.Ashley Orkin: Visit El Pote if you want a real Spanish dinner. Order the paella Valencia and red sangria. If you're lucky there will be live music!

Sal C.Sal C: DO get la paella marinera

Cho Dang Gol is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

6. Cho Dang Gol

8.6
55 W 35th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Korean Restaurant · Koreatown · 141 tips and reviews

Stephen P.Stephen Perle: Best Korean meal had stuffed mushrooms and stir fry tofu trio. Great homemade tofu

Michael C.Michael Chang: Mini bossam - pork belly so tender it will make you 🤣

emily c.emily chen: Get the spicy galbi jjim. You can thank me later.

Meson Sevilla is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

7. Meson Sevilla

7.7
344 W 46th St (btwn 8th & 9th Ave), New York, NY
Spanish Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 19 tips and reviews

ドーラドーラ: Must have's: Jamón Serrano (Spanish ham), grilled shrimp, grilled calamari, stuffed mushrooms, artichoke vinaigrette, a pitcher of fresh, chilled Sangria.

Manny L.Manny Lacayo: Try the Spanish Tapas - Pimientos Padrón!!!!

PeggyPeggy: We really enjoyed the marinera seafood paella. The service was friendly and excellent!

Mangia is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

8. Mangia

8.1
50 W 57th St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Midtown East · 55 tips and reviews

Christine D.Christine DaCruz: Delicious well layered pre-made sandwiches and salad bar options like kale salad, shaved Brussel sprout salad, stuffed mushrooms, the list of delicious healthy options is endless.

KaKa: Great quick bite! Huge variety, everything's tasty.

Douglas K.Douglas Kurdziel: They have moved some hot sandwiches (like the wonderful Telera and steak sandwich) to the counter in the back - don't miss them!

Sofia Wine Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

9. Sofia Wine Bar

8.5
242 E 50th St (Bet 2nd & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Turtle Bay · 93 tips and reviews

Kathryn D.Kathryn D: Stuffed mushrooms pair well with red wine on a cold day.

Kenneth M.Kenneth Mørk: Very nice please. Good wine and great pizza. You should try it.

schneidermike s.schneidermike schneidermike: Look. Midtown sucks, but this place rules.

Franchia is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

10. Franchia

8.6
12 Park Ave (at E 34th St.), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Murray Hill · 150 tips and reviews

Katherine M.Katherine Megrue-Smith: The stuffed mushrooms are fantastic!

GabrielleGabrielle: Salad and soup! Also try the spicy eggplant curry

Faith L.Faith Legendre: Don't forget to look up. The ceiling has a lovely floral pattern.

Italianissimo Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

11. Italianissimo Ristorante

8.9
307 E 84th St (at 2nd Ave.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Yorkville · 16 tips and reviews

Nicolette R.Nicolette Romero: You'd never know about this place unless you were walking by. Quaint and romantic spot for date night. The waiters are super friendly and have great recommendations. Try the carbonara!

Kerry H.Kerry Hay: Best kept secret in the Upper East. Reservations recommended.

Mark W.Mark Wyszomierski: excellent, staff is very friendly.

Bhatti Indian Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

12. Bhatti Indian Grill

8.4
100 Lexington Ave (at E 27th St), New York, NY
Indian Restaurant · Rose Hill · 167 tips and reviews

miles l.miles lennon: The best Indian food I have had in NYC. I highly recommend the Lamb Vindaloo, Chicken kebabs and the stuffed mushroom appetizer.

Oz L.Oz Lubling: The best Indian in curry hill. Great for lunch takeout orders.

Phoenix 💥💥💥Phoenix 💥💥💥: Great kebabs here

Gaetana's Cucina Italiana is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

13. Gaetana's Cucina Italiana

7.2
143 Christopher St (at Greenwich St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 50 tips and reviews

Eric C.Eric Cohen: Food here is amazing and Frankie is the best...The stuffed mushrooms are unreal

Brian R.Brian Reaver: Always, always the very best Italian food, inexpensive, with the best service!

melinda l.melinda lee: Just introduce yourself to Frankie. There's no one else like him!

Paesano of Mulberry Street is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

14. Paesano of Mulberry Street

7.4
136 Mulberry St (btwn Hester & Grand), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Little Italy · 92 tips and reviews

Özgür S.Özgür Süyel: Very professional waiters, outstanding service try alfredo and stuffed mushrooms

Gina V.Gina Vivo: Chicken parm and gnocchi with vodka sauce is amazing! :)

Paula L.Paula L: My family has been coming to this restaurant for years. The atmosphere is fun and I love the gnocchi a la vodka.

Red Lobster is one of The 15 Best Places for Stuffed Mushrooms in New York City.

15. Red Lobster

7.5
5 Times Sq Fl 1 (at W 41st St.), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 232 tips and reviews

Nikki M.Nikki Mitchell: The stuffed mushroom wit lobster n crab meat omg a must try

 Deon P. Deon Parcon: Stuffed mushroom with lobster and crabmeat.. anti allergy med ready..

C T.C Tully: Class class class. High end restaurant, a locals-only hangout, and a must see in New York.