The 13 Best Places for Vanilla Milkshakes in New York City

William Figueroa: You must order the Double Shack Burger and the Hand Spun Vanilla Shake! You can't go wrong!

Matt Lieberman: Double shack burger, fries and vanilla shake...amazing

Flavio Muff: long queue but nice food. the vanilla shake is awesome! you must try.

Sarina Arceo: The vanilla shake is the best ever vanilla shake ever!! So delicious! Not overly sweet either.

Ernest Carter: Vanilla shake with malt! #lifechanging

allison: Dip your fries in a Vanilla Shake!

Anthony Madama: I love their vanilla shake and chicken fingers

Sheen: Amazing vegan pizza 🍕, skip the popcorn 🍿 it has 25086839 grams of sodium

Christina Chin: No idea the theater was there way downstairs. Burger was ok and salted caramel shake was a bit too sweet. Theater small but seats recline yet table doesn't move?

M R: Favorite burger in the city. Make sure you get a vanilla milkshake!

Viv: Overpriced, but v good burger. Get the medium rare cheeseburger with the works, vanilla shake, and fries - $19.75 at the time of writing (!!). Efficient operation but v tiny kitchen - expect to wait.

Jeni Bulcock: Vanilla shakes made with real vanilla bean. Thumbs up!

Carlos M: Must try the honey and pepper vanilla milkshake! It's so different.

Brazil NY Tour: Organic Burgers, great juices and best vanilla milkshake ever!!!

Serious Eats: Popular for its grass-fed beef burgers and "alternative" meats (elk, bison, etc.)

Jenn Allen: The classic, tater tots and handspun vanilla milkshake are amazing!! My niece raves about the maple bacon

Mike Hopkins: Chicken club was phenomenal. Shakes melt quickly - eat fast!

Morgan Jordan: To my fellow Diet Cokeheads: This place has the BEST D Coke fountain in the whole wide world. Perfect ratio of bubbles to water to soda syrup.

Jelena Pasic: thick frosty vanilla shake- yum!

Joanna Pena-Bickley: The classic with a big red and vanilla shake

L. T.: You can never go wrong here. Vegetarians: get the veggie patty which is one of the best I've had - and ask for your fries to be cooked in vegetable oil! Cajun spiced fries are outta control!

Mark Jimenez: The Original Chicken Sandwich and the Mac & Cheese

Ricky: Remember to check your order before you leave,I’ve gotten two wrong orders!

Eugene Kimberg: Bathroom Code 062120

Alison J.: Great food. Don't let lines deter you. The team taking orders via iPads will get you in and out quickly.

Howard: Large and brand new. Plenty of seats. Best yet in nyc

Will Harahan: Terrific staff and great food.

Asim: Can't go wrong with vanilla shake..!

Jakub H.: I tasted the best cheeseburger in New York. mayo, pickles, mustard and onion!

Y: Amazingg ....

Ghaida✨: Very yummy fried chicken burger..and you must to try their "Chick-fill-A sauce" 😋👌

John F: Order ahead on the app.

tloinc.forever: location on 86th & 3rd has been amazingly amazing in these times of uncertainty...

Ian: You have to get the chocolate chip cookie milkshake. Real cookies mashed up in a vanilla milkshake you can't go wrong!

Tom: Great made-to-order burgers and fries. Lucky sauce makes everything better!

Kevin Myers: Best damn burgers in town! Happily located in a gay area for gays who don't give a rat's ass about carbs, fat or calories. Order anything, but the chili cheese fries are tops!

Ellyssa Kroski: Get the spicy redneck (bacon-wrapped chili dog w/ jalepenos) + tater tots + vanilla milkshake...esp good at 1am!!!

Victoria Wooster: For two persons I recommend one hot dog each one and one large fries or tater tots to share. The "good morning" and "Chihuahua" are great options!

Thrillist: We did all the delicious sober work for you, and ate/ranked all 19 of the dogs they've got on hand, from the corn, to all things bacon-wrapped, to the veggie, just because we had to. Read more.