Chile Pies Baking Co. is one of The 7 Best Places for Peanut Butter Pie in San Francisco.

1. Chile Pies Baking Co.

601 Baker St (at Fulton), San Francisco, CA
Pie Shop · Western Addition · 107 tips and reviews

Marshall S.Marshall St. Clair: Chocolate peanut butter pie rated #2 pie in Bay Area by 7x7 mag

goldstein j.goldstein jodi: Chocolate & peanut butter pie w/ peanut butter ice cream!!! Holy f&%$!!!!!

Nino E.Nino E: You must experience their legendary Pie Shake. I usually get the peanut butter pie with an Oreo crust and blend it with Madagascar vanilla ice cream. It's perfection in a jar.

Hard Water is one of The 7 Best Places for Peanut Butter Pie in San Francisco.

2. Hard Water

Pier 3 (on The Embarcadero), San Francisco, CA
Whisky Bar · Northern Waterfront · 112 tips and reviews

pearl w.pearl wong: also had collard greens, chocolate peanut butter pie = good. but service was slow and inconsistent. place is too small. over-rated

Maya R.Maya R: Do not miss the pork cracklings or the scotch kisses. Amazing whiskey selection and awesome service.

Salvador T.Salvador Tovar: The staff and food exceeded out expectations! If you are a whiskey man or woman, the selection is off the hook!

Southpaw BBQ is one of The 7 Best Places for Peanut Butter Pie in San Francisco.

3. Southpaw BBQ

2170 Mission St (btwn 17th St & 18th St), San Francisco, CA
BBQ Joint · Mission District · 107 tips and reviews

Joerg R.Joerg Rings: Fantastic house old-fashioned with pecan syrup

annie .annie 🧸: Idea: if here with one other person, order a single BBQ meal platter (comes with 2 sides) and one or two appetizers

Kristina S.Kristina Schneider: Get the pulled pork plate. Better be REALLY hungry.

Boxing Room is one of The 7 Best Places for Peanut Butter Pie in San Francisco.

4. Boxing Room

399 Grove St (at Gough St), San Francisco, CA
Southern Food Restaurant · Civic Center · 185 tips and reviews

Lisa E.Lisa E: Deep fried alligator & charred oysters are a must. And if they're serving the pork chop special, don't pass it up!

ThrillistThrillist: Score some delicious Southern food including honest-to-goodness fried gator. It’ll (cap’n) hook you. Read more.

tal k.tal keinan: Fried alligator is to die for.

Z. Cioccolato is one of The 7 Best Places for Peanut Butter Pie in San Francisco.

5. Z. Cioccolato

7.0
474 Columbus Ave, San Francisco, CA
Chocolate Store · North Beach · 32 tips and reviews

Sylvie R.Sylvie Robitaille: They have so many toffee barels to try from !!!! Gelato are great!

SoopahVivSoopahViv: Super tasty fresh caramel popcorn! $1 a bag or free with purchase.

Abbey K.Abbey Keck: They also have chocolate covered gummy bears!

Hard Rock Cafe San Francisco is one of The 7 Best Places for Peanut Butter Pie in San Francisco.

6. Hard Rock Cafe San Francisco

7.7
39 Pier #256 (at The Embarcadero), San Francisco, CA
American Restaurant · Fishermans Wharf · 147 tips and reviews

Matteo M.Matteo Matt: 3 Times in 2 Years...Flying 15 hrs... YES! I can say I like iit! Try the local burger it's really good and made with 1st class ingredients (my opinion). I love Anchor Steam Beer!

Kapil D.Kapil Dalwani: don't miss the Nirvana guitar just on the entrance..! get yourself clicked..!

Jake T.Jake Textor: Overpriced food and signed guitars make white people think they are somewhere special. Buy a stupid t-shirt!

Bi-Rite Creamery is one of The 7 Best Places for Peanut Butter Pie in San Francisco.

7. Bi-Rite Creamery

9.2
3692 18th St (at Dolores St), San Francisco, CA
Ice Cream Parlor · Mission Dolores · 687 tips and reviews

Amanda T.Amanda Taylor: If they have the Olive Oil flavor, try it. Life-changingly amazing and subtle. Paired with the Basil it was phenomenal.

SFGateSFGate: Trust us, you can't go wrong with the Salted Caramel…until you're addicted. Read more.

7x7 Magazine7x7 Magazine: We die for the salted-caramel ice cream...it's #35 on 7x7's Big Eat SF 2010. Read more.