Hollywood Gelato is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

1. Hollywood Gelato

8.4
1640 Bayview Ave (at Manor Rd. E.), Toronto, ON
Ice Cream Parlor · Davisville · 44 tips and reviews

Joel S.Joel Solish: Key lime pie, nothing beats it. In the fall I highly suggest trying the pumpkin pie also. Good stuff here and made fresh daily.

Jackie B.Jackie Beauchamp: Wild berry and Key Lime Pie, an excellent combo!

Stephanie C.Stephanie Cheng: Hazelnut is like Ferraro Rocher in gelato form - so good. They also make a great latte.

Olde Yorke Fish & Chips is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

2. Olde Yorke Fish & Chips

8.4
96 Laird Dr. (Lea Ave), Toronto, ON
Fish and Chips Shop · 53 tips and reviews

Tricia K.Tricia K: If you're considering the key lime pie, do it!!!

Shari K.Shari Kaisar: Best key lime pie EVER!

Hesam M.Hesam Mas: the best fish & chips in the city...almost worth the road trip.

Hy's Steakhouse is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

3. Hy's Steakhouse

8.5
120 Adelaide St. W (at York St), Toronto, ON
Steakhouse · Financial District · 19 tips and reviews

- R.- R: Try the New York strip with peppercorn sauce, amazing. Caesar salad is made right at your table and is definitely worth getting. Key lime pie for dessert 👌🏼

Ann S.Ann Stevens: It's classy, comfortable seats, speedy & efficient service. Food is very tasty. Nice selection. Meeting rooms downstairs. An elevator to take you to either the upstairs or downstairs. Very accessible

Chrissy B.Chrissy Benoit: Took my bf here for dinner. Perfect date night! So romantic and the steaks are great :) beautiful building. The decor is lovely. Put on a nice dress and have some red wine ;)

Summer's Homemade Ice Cream is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

4. Summer's Homemade Ice Cream

8.7
101 Yorkville Ave. (west of Bellair St.), Toronto, ON
Ice Cream Parlor · Yorkville · 41 tips and reviews

LindsayLindsay: Key lime pie frozen yogurt is amazing! Real bits of Graham cracker crust too!

Jordan S.Jordan Saxe: Best ice cream in the city. Roasted Hazelnut FTW

Almyra J.Almyra Janice: Best homemade waffle cone!!! Nomnom

7 Numbers is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

5. 7 Numbers

8.2
307 Danforth Ave. (at Bowden St), Toronto, ON
Italian Restaurant · Riverdale · 25 tips and reviews

Ahmet S.Ahmet Sabancı: lamb shank is amazing...so is key lime pie

Derrick G.Derrick Gray: Family style menu is the way to go!!

VitoVito: Check out the iPad menus

La Carnita is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

6. La Carnita

8.5
501 College St (at Palmerston Blvd), Toronto, ON
Taco Restaurant · 125 tips and reviews

Charles L.Charles Law: You gotta try the key lime pie Popsicle.

Katricia B.Katricia Barleta: Key lime pie paleta is heaven.

Rob I.Rob Iacocca: Yes, the tacos are amazing - maybe even the best in the city - but the drinks (awesome beer list) and the deserts (CHURROS!) are also worth your attention and $$$.

The Carbon Bar is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

7. The Carbon Bar

8.2
99 Queen St E, Toronto, ON
Restaurant · St. Lawrence · 46 tips and reviews

AliAli: Have the key lime pie, ribs, chicken, fries !!! So amazing.

Joanna S.Joanna Sable: Huge, fabulous. Bbq from everywhere. As always David Lee is king. Go go go.

Chris G.Chris Gauvin: Excellent reservation system (and reso service) which sets you up in a beauty dining room. No TVs, fantastic tunes, great atmosphere. The Buttermilk Fried Chicken was perfection. #GoodEats

Wanda's Pie in the Sky is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

8. Wanda's Pie in the Sky

8.3
287 Augusta Ave (Oxford St), Toronto, ON
Bakery · Kensington Market · 54 tips and reviews

Gabriel S.Gabriel Seah: Key lime pie had light, fresh cream. It had a crumbly base which had no body - I'm not a fan. The lime taste wasn't too strong & it had bits of fruit.

jocelyn L.jocelyn L.: the coconut pie is the way to go!

ClickflickcaClickflickca: They had no cupcakes at the end of night! I missed out.

Red Lobster is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

9. Red Lobster

8.1
1790 The Queensway (N Queen St), Etobicoke, ON
Seafood Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

Linda .Linda 🌟: The lobster was amazing! The ceaser salad wasn't the greatest and the cheese biscuits rocked as always. The pina colada was fab and the service was fast and polite. Stuffed!!!

Chris K.Chris K: CHEDDAR BAY BISCUITS ARE THE BEST!

Kaitlyn M.Kaitlyn May: I love the fried shrimp and the the garlic shrimp! Try the "create your own combo" - the portions are huge!

Red Lobster is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

10. Red Lobster

8.1
20 Dundas Street West (at Bay St), Toronto, ON
Seafood Restaurant · 43 tips and reviews

Cheryl D.Cheryl Duggan: The NEW Fire Grilled Lobster, Shrimp and Salmon is a dream platter for fish fanatics.

Andre M.Andre McKay: Endless shrimp!

Serene W.Serene Wong: Cheddar biscuits are the best!

The Shore Club is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

11. The Shore Club

7.5
155 Wellington St. W, Toronto, ON
Seafood Restaurant · Entertainment District · 14 tips and reviews

WendyWendy: Visited during Summerlicious. Great price for great food, great drinks, and great ambiance. Try their tuna tartare; it tastes super fresh, as if it was just freshly caught. Delicious!

Roger H.Roger Hawa: Amazing, amazing and amazing ! Open face burger !!!

Charmaine C.Charmaine Chin: Lunch is quick and reasonable.

e11even is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

12. e11even

7.9
15 York St. (at Bremner Blvd.), Toronto, ON
New American Restaurant · Entertainment District · 47 tips and reviews

Gopal P.Gopal Patel: Best bread ever. Try the meatball app.. Finish off with the brownie

NHLNHL: Great place to grab something to eat before you go to the ACC for a Maple Leafs game!

Stephanie D.Stephanie Depano: Great food, atmosphere, wine selection, service and overall great dining experience. It's my new favorite place ❤

By the Way Cafe is one of The 13 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Toronto.

13. By the Way Cafe

7.5
400 Bloor Street West, Toronto, ON
Middle Eastern Restaurant · The Annex · 24 tips and reviews

Anna B.Anna Banana: Amazing food, awesome service, great patio. Sunday brunch is always busy though.

Devon B.Devon B: The restaurant puts cinnamon in the coffee, very tasty!

Haein K.Haein Kim: The curly haired waitress was super dry and rude to only our table.