GREAT burger, get it with bacon, no lettuce or tomato. Worth the price. Cottage fries are good too.
Love the atmosphere here. Great burger! Great cottage fries and I love their key lime pie
Possibly the best burger in Manhattan. Indulge in some cottage fries too.
One of the shortest lines of all the Shake Shacks! Definitely get the shack burger and the vanilla shake is to die for!
Love the burgers - but the hotdogs are just as excellent and definitely worth a try...
From what I know, who doesn't like this awesome burgers and crinkle cut fries. Also delicious shakes and hot dogs!
Been coming here since the mid 70's. 90% of the time, it's always the Baldouni Burger. It never disappoints. Still very reasonable for NYC and still up there as one of the best burgers you'll find.
Best burger chain in NYC. No fail burgers and get a table in the outdoor space in the back! Great to see the prices are still affordable compared to the ones that make you "stand in line".
Best burger in manhattan; choose sweet potato fries over waffle cut.
Great burger. Fresh fries. Spiced beef sandwich is salty and delicious. Pickles are spicy!
Great selection of beer on tap and scotch on shelf...oh and there's a killer burger to help you get through that next round. Check the back bar for current craft beer offerings.
The Penrose medium done with caramelized onions will be the best burger you ever had.
Best special in the area. FREE burger with the purchase of ANY drink! All day, everyday
Besides the fantastic beer selection, free burgers and wings, honestly, the music is ON POINT. kind of the best place, EVER
Free burger with draft beer, great beer selection, and Owen the bartender is awesome. By far my favorite neighborhood bar!
The burger with jalapeño was amazing!! Fries with yummy supply house sauce are great as well.
The Supply House Burger is really good. Pair it with a side of fries and a beer and you're good to go. They also have weekly live music; a nice touch.
JWF burger is fantastic! FYI...Stilton is crumbled blue cheese. I had no idea.
If you're in search of authentic English pub food, this is your place. While we love the fish and chips, the JWF burger with bacon can't be missed.
excellent fish and chips and burger
keep this review in context but 2nd week opened BUT some highlights are the shaved sprouts salad w. pear and some UES specific fries. burger is always a must but the patties were dry + fries lukewarm
Burger is amazing — would sleep inside that pretzel bun. The Colony2 is a perfect combo of spicy and sweet. Would have just skipped the truffle topping on the waffle fries.
The big le Matt burger was a crowd pleaser, and I absolutely adored the Caesar salad with real anchovies
The Duck Burger is one of the best burgers I've ever had!
Great burger and long beer list.
Deviled eggs and lamb burger for the win
Lamb burger was flipping amazing; Arctic char was done to perfection. Could live off the seeds w bread. Farmers market salad was very ordinary. Go with a date or group!
Perfect Mac & Cheese. Lamb burger fantastic. Would also definitely go back for fish cake slider, boar slider, & ribs
Hearty and delicious noodles, burger was a bit dry, noodle soup was great. If u are offended by the service, dnt go to china.
Cumin lamb burger is awesome. So is the sour hawberry tea.
Cumin lamb burger and spicy cumin lamb noodles are delicious but greasy
Happy hour till 8 and I loved the burger. Good fries too
Burger is really good!
Excellent brunch burger
One of the best burgers in all of uptown. It can get slammed for lunch but their service is still extremely fast.
A little hole in the wall with amazing burgers and amazing chicken tacos!!!!
One of my favorite burgers in the city and under $10! Great place, super down to earth. Go in, grab a stool, grab a burger and a milkshake, and thank me.
Awesome burger. Very authentic and nice staff.
Burgers and fries
Burger is very tasty...get the spicy mayo on the side.
No nonsense diner straight out of the '50s with great burgers and club sandwiches.
Butter burger and a chocolate egg cream = perfect lunch.
Egg cream is fantastic, especially coffee or chocolate, which favors the proprietor does himself. Burger w/fried eggs, bacon & mushrooms can't be beat... as the atmosphere in this 100yr old joint...
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA