2. Fred's Restaurant
8.2
476 Amsterdam Ave. (at W 83rd St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 152 tips and reviews
Crystal Hermosillo: Everything I've had here is great! Lobster pasta, Penne pesto pasta, steak, Mac n cheese!! Don't forget to try the brownie dessert!
Ryan: Great neighborhood joint - brunch, burgers, Mac and cheese. Prefer dog lovers!
Karen Tapia: Happy hour sangria 👍🏼 ..and the Mac and cheese!
3. The Smith
8.5
1900 Broadway (at W 63rd St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 345 tips and reviews
Andrea Barrezueta: Love their Mac n cheese... And the burrata is pretty awesome too
Nicole: Generous portions of delicious comfort food. Healthy options and nonalcoholic homemade sodas too. Good for families, brunch, and a late meal. Usually a wait. Get the mac & cheese and s'mores in a jar!
Omar Elddin: Mac n' cheese is out of this world...must try!
4. Maison Pickle
9.0
2315 Broadway (W 84th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 90 tips and reviews
Tim Rossi: The Mac & Cheese is amazing and French Dips are great. Will be back but with a bigger group to share!
Annie Hung: A delightful mismatch of things -- Biggie Smalls blaring in a sleek, loungey space with delicious schmancy French dip sandwiches, mac n cheese...and top notch cocktails. Hey, why not?! It works!
Selene Liszka: Weekday brunch! Delicious Mac and cheese and chicken and (French)toast! Kid friendly.
Brian Watson: Don't sleep on the jerk shrimp! Also, always get the candied yams with mac & cheese.
Stephanie Wu: $12 for jerk chicken and sides of curried potatoes & chick peas, collard greens, and Mac 'n cheese. Amazing food. Good deal.
Joseph Kaminski: The jerk shrimp with Mac & cheese and collard greens are my favorite dish.
8. The Milling Room
8.9
446 Columbus Ave (at W 81st St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 52 tips and reviews
alison zimmermann: Love this place. Great service, steak, truffle risotto, Mac and cheese and steak.
Zach Hamed: Hidden gem on Upper West Side with American/Mediterranean cuisine. Chicken, risotto, and codfish all delicious. Beautiful high ceilings and old fashioned decor.
Tracy Hixon: The special cocktail of the day had a huge jalapeno flavored ice cube in it, try it! Tasty octopus, salads and pasta in a relaxed atmosphere
9. Sugar Bar
8.1
254 W 72nd St (btw Broadway & West End), New York, NY
Caribbean Restaurant · Upper West Side · 25 tips and reviews
Leah Elizabeth: Awsome restaurant! Thursday nights are incredible, go here for a great time, great music, and fun celebrity sightings! Make sure to order the mac and cheese!
Shermaine Johnson: Food is fantastic and reasonably priced & great spot to meet legendary celebrities especially on the Thursday open Mic night
Daniel M.: Nice chill vibe, cabana decor, friendly service and live music. I could make this my regular spot.
10. Chirping Chicken
6.9
355 Amsterdam Ave (at W 77th St), New York, NY
Comfort Food Restaurant · Upper West Side · 85 tips and reviews
Kent Gould: Pepsi Pour! Huge portions. Mac and cheese = yum.
Ali Briggs: Some combination of entering at 2 am with semi-attractive women led to free drinks, mac and cheese, and other sides. The free food just about compensates for the sexist slurs shouted as you leave.
matthew hemingway: Get a whole roasted chicken, Mac & cheese, and a Salad.$22.. Last time we went we got mashed potatoes and they were FAKE, NASTY!! Great chicken!!
11. Luke's Lobster
8.4
426 Amsterdam Ave (btw W 80th & 81st St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Upper West Side · 100 tips and reviews
Suzy Tran: Get the lobster mac and cheese. Won’t regret it. Lobster roll is tiny and a little pricey at $17, but it satisfied my craving.
Ji: Spicy Mala lobster was amazing! The lobster was firm and juicy, but pass on the Mac and cheese.
Michael Fox-Rabinovitz: Solid albeit small lobster rolls and new England clam chowder here, worth a visit
13. Dive Bar
7.5
732 Amsterdam Ave (btwn 95th & 96th St), New York, NY
Dive Bar · Upper West Side · 120 tips and reviews
Mike Gee: Go to Dive Bar and order the Beth Beyer F$*K*N Good Sandwich, good Mac and Cheese too... I LOVE THIS F$*K*N bar!!!! Oh, and most people I know refer to it as Dive 96.
Elise Abdalla: The ambiance fits the name - a dive, but surprisingly delicious food! Must try the lobster mac and cheese or the shrimp caesar salad - my favorites :)
Kyle Bye: A "Dive Bar" is the last spot you think would have decent seafood -- check out anything from the lobster mac & cheese to the grilled salmon sandwich and even a lengthy list of mussels specials.
15. Good Enough to Eat
7.6
520 Columbus Ave (at W 85th St), New York, NY
Breakfast Spot · Upper West Side · 315 tips and reviews
Peter Shankman: Mac and cheese: Decent. Not awesome, but worth having.
Stephen Charles: Try the 1/2 roasted chicken - Subbed the mashed potatoes with their Mac and cheese.
Katie Flynn: Get the meatloaf, the mac and cheese, and everything they offer for dessert!