See all
44 photos

Brown's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

(Now Closed)

Ice Cream Parlor$$$$

Town of York

Save

22 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Ed McDevittAugust 13, 2013
As other have said - the "small" is huge. If you get a cone, plan on dripping. As for the "over-rated, expensive" comment below - ignore. Their prices are what you'll pay anywhere. Ice cream is great.
JenKuduJune 9, 2011
Possibly the best Icecream I've had in my life. The large $5 is big enough to share! It's practically a full pint. The almond joy is delicious!
Caitlin B.August 31, 2011
Been here 10+ times
The cookie dough truly is amazing. A small is basically the size of a large anywhere else. There is an amazing variety of flavors
Morgan LevyJuly 14, 2011
Ginger ice cream is crazy awesome. Beware the sizes - a kiddie cup is huge and a small will blow your mind.
Eric McErlainMay 13, 2012
Be sure to ask for a large cup no matter what you order. The servings are so large they can quickly melt into a mess!
Meghan BurnsMay 15, 2011
Kahlua Fudge Brownie - so good! Get a cone and take it to Nubble Light for a scenic view.
Aaron FlaMay 20, 2012
Get a cone with a cup and put half in the cup. They give to much icecream for the cups.
David HowlandAugust 13, 2011
Black raspberry explosion is the best...can be made into a chocolate brownie sundae too mmm
Amie GoetkeSeptember 11, 2014
A yearly pilgrimage destination for me and my in-laws. Some damn good ice cream
Kyle FrenetteApril 20, 2011
Been here 25+ times
do yourself a kindness and try the Indian Pudding for some Guilded Age, olde tyme, fun.
DanwenAugust 11, 2010
get the Big Bang... most amazing combination of ice cream ingredients. ever.
Michelle SmithJune 10, 2012
Over-rated, expensive, only takes cash, puts a two-scoop ice cream in a hoodsie cup size cup... Go else-where
Scott WilliamsonJuly 20, 2013
Tornado flavor is the bomb.
Marija GoronjicAugust 7, 2015
Raspberry explosion!
Laurel HoffmanAugust 28, 2013
If only they took credit/debit...nearly perfect.
Andrew OJune 11, 2014
Generous on sizes
Meghann VoorhisJune 25, 2013
When ice cream for dinner is in order....
mary shaneJune 23, 2015
Closed and for sale
Aj BadderSeptember 5, 2011
sizes are large!!!
Ted HowellSeptember 2, 2011
just get the blueberry already
John SchausterJuly 26, 2011
Best chocolate ... ever.
RC LationsSeptember 3, 2010
Planet Earth flavor is awesome.

44 Photos

Brown's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

Related Searches

Places people like to go after Brown's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

Appears on 9 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.