See all
148 photos

Puffy's Tavern

Pub$$$$

Tribeca, New York

Save

Puffy's Tavern

7.2^/10

186

ratings

Ranked #8 for Italian sandwiches in New York
"Charlie the bartender is awesome and a dartboard!"(6 Tips)
"Little known fact: Puffy's has amazing Italian sandwiches at lunch"(2 Tips)
"... during lunch – try the Gladiatore or the Sofia. Add a beer for $3 or $4 and..."(2 Tips)
"On Mondays, lunch comes with a free beer, that was a nice surprise."(5 Tips)

44 Tips and reviews

Filter:

sandwiches
darts
gladiatore
beer
happy hour
fellini
casual
great value
paninis
lunch
bread
town
well
crowded
lagers
liquor
city
(12 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

doug jaegerDecember 23, 2013
Been here 10+ times
If you like sopressata, and things a bit spicy, try the 'fellini' on pizza bianca bread. Extra points, go Monday, get a FREE BEER. The sandwiches are really generous in size, so you can split it!
Conrad Greiner-BechertMay 9, 2017
Been here 10+ times
This place has charming bar staff and a wrecked dart board in the back. I used to enjoy their sandwiches in an earlier more carb-enthusiastic life. Most people come for a quick beer (or 7) at lunch.
Stephen SaribalisJanuary 30, 2020
Place has for a great feel. Big windows. Crystal our bartender was charming and a straight shooter. They serve Alidoro’s Italian sandwiches here, best in town. Highly recommend.
Tony XerriApril 2, 2016
This place is nothing special. That's why I love it. Honest prices, dart board, good times. Sandwiches are great here for lunch as well.
The Corcoran GroupOctober 11, 2011
Classic New York City tavern serving surprisingly good Italian sandwiches during lunch – try the Gladiatore or the Sofia. Add a beer for $3 or $4 and enjoy lunch all the more!
JennApril 21, 2016
Been here 50+ times
Alidoro sandwich lunches are a specialty here. Come on Mondays for a free beer with your sandwich!
Jeffrey ZeldmanMarch 5, 2018
Legendary institution. It was here before Tribeca was Tribeca. It will still be here after the apocalypse.
Tom M.March 14, 2015
Don't just have a beer here---have one of the amazing Italian sandwiches here---so yummy!
Bruce HaydonJanuary 13, 2017
Cool little neighborhood bar with great drink prices, comparatively speaking in terms of other Tribeca watering holes.
Helen KangMarch 6, 2016
Drinks are fairly priced especially for TriBeCa. Charlie the bartender is awesome and a dartboard!
Sam YooMay 6, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Lunch sandwiches are awesome. Order them on pizza bread! Pizza breads run out so get there early.
Quinton MaMay 30, 2015
Amazing Italian sandwiches here. Love this place. Get the Tre or Fellini
Dallas ShortOctober 7, 2013
Sandwich was large and very filling, but i wasn't a fan of their bread. On Mondays, lunch comes with a free beer, that was a nice surprise.
Tracy BalzanoJuly 22, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Free beer with sammy on Monday uas to be one of the best dealsn in town. Bread from Grandaisy. Yummm.
Natali ElmasogluMay 6, 2017
Friendly bar to hangout and have cool beers
Jacqueline LombardAugust 21, 2012
$5 beer, wine AND well drinks happy hour from 4pm-8pm is one of the best deals in town!
AnissaApril 4, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Darts and cheap drinks! Get there early if you want a table
Nate SAugust 4, 2014
Tribeca without the nannies and strollers. Relax. Have a beer or two.
Andrew PerezMay 12, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Cold beer and good company tbqfh. All the bartenders are mad chill.
Courtney KleinOctober 7, 2016
Decent selection of beers on tap. The happy hour deals are also pretty good.
Lisa BurdigeFebruary 2, 2012
Mouthwaterin ciabatta bread sandwiches plus awesome daily beer specials. I like
Elizabeth Y.January 3, 2014
Great freaking sandwiches. ESPecially the tuna ones.
Trenton GaucherJuly 15, 2013
Free beer on Monday with a sandwich at lunch. That's the move.
AKA MEDIA SYSTEMMarch 19, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Awesome lunch spot - all the sandwiches are great!
RonniSeptember 5, 2015
Chill night here - an older crowd it seems, we took the corner next to the dart and chatted away since it wasn't so loud
Nacho GurlSeptember 7, 2017
You'll break your teeth on that bread. Stick with the liquor.
Courtney KleinOctober 7, 2016
Not a lot of space but very not a lot of space but very welcoming environment.
Andy HeadworthDecember 1, 2010
The Paninis and Brooklyn IPA beer are really great :)
Ryan PottsApril 13, 2009
Puffy's has a rich history and is a well kept secret (until now, sorry). Expect to find incognito Hollywood royalty settling their nerves before a meeting with Harvey Weinstein.
Maximum BurgerJanuary 27, 2018
Great service - not a great selection
marc wDecember 2, 2010
Been here 25+ times
darts, internet jbox, great bartenders. what's not to love? oh, right - no Brooklyn Lager
Alejandro CorpenoOctober 26, 2011
At lunchtime you can have an italian sandwich + beer for $13 including tax
Broc KleinJuly 31, 2019
Been here 25+ times
tip your bartender
Henry ChakApril 5, 2019
Nice vibe. Neighborhood
TeddyJune 22, 2017
Been here 5+ times
The A/C wasn't working and it was over 90° outside. Sweaty!
Marc BuonJanuary 31, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Gladiatore, lagunitas, job done!
Jesse RoehrichMay 25, 2012
Good happy hour and lasts til 8:00
CCnycMay 29, 2015
Lunch sandwiches
DanDecember 6, 2011
Been here 10+ times
don't you forget about me is definately the puffys theme song
Jason BellAugust 17, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Little known fact: Puffy's has amazing Italian sandwiches at lunch
Caroline HarveyJanuary 16, 2011
The Maker's & coke is heavy on the Maker's--- best day ever!
Robbert VorhoffMarch 26, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Alidoro sandwiches - best in town
Mike D.June 27, 2012
He's mine .....
FaiserJune 28, 2009
visit soon, might be destined for greater things soon.

148 Photos

Puffy's Tavern

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Puffy's Tavern

Appears on 113 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.