Carroll Gardens Classic Diner
(Now Closed)Diner$$$$
Boerum Hill, Brooklyn
40 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Every time I'm here it's after 1am and I think it's saved my life no less than about five times now. People talking about the quality... what else do you expect from a 24hr diner?!
Kelsey✨August 15, 2015English muffin with salmon, avocado, and poached eggs with hollandaise sauce is a must! Great breakfast potatoes too.
Ely KlimoffApril 7, 2014I wish they can grow faster and provide better quality food.it is so difficult to make home made fries instead of buying cheapest one in jetro or costco?
CarolynAugust 23, 2014Standard diner fare with good prices - much better than other nearby diners value for money-wise (I'm looking at you Apollo Diner)
Don't wait in line to eat a good breakfast. Eat your Hangover Helper here. Good, simple, fast. Oh. And no live music. Leave that for the real show you'll see later.
RachelOctober 15, 2013The challah French toast is delicious. Above average home fries! Hits the spot at 4:30 am
Christina WalthallAugust 11, 2013Food is delicious, everything from the hamburgers to the lemonade is fresh and made from scratch!
Really tasty fried fish sandwich, food is always consistent and they're open 24 hours!
Daniel McDonoughDecember 6, 2015Basic diner. Food comes really quick. If you order a side of bacon be prepared for approx 10 pieces.
David RiveraAugust 7, 2013I'll be going back. They had me at the pickle and slaw they served me as I took a seat. Delish.
Sergey SmirnovDecember 4, 2015Very casual and nice 24 hour diner. Food is decently priced and in large portions.
Melody GambinoNovember 23, 2014Great for 4 am trips to the diner and one of the only 24 hours places in the neighborhood
Marc MayerAugust 27, 2015Perfect for when you realize you've been drinking down the block for twelve hours, your family has no idea where you are and you really, really need a burger.- Lee SimpsonDecember 20, 2014The best sausages and bacon I've had at a diner since coming to New York!
best diner in the area - way better than st claire. cheap, fast delivery, fresh food. make it your go-to diner.
Umair ZiaJune 3, 2013I have to seriously stop coming here. Over priced dinner food... So many options on the menu, which always is a sign of "un-fresh" ingredients. Nothing is terrible, but nothing is amazing either.
- Go to Caroll Garden Classic Diner and sit in the beautiful little garden in back where you can eat quality diner food cheap and read the paper.
Order bacon extra crispy-yum, that's a lotta meat :)
Don't sit by the front doors and avoid the fans. Those things are about to break and go shooting across the place.
Erik MichielsenMay 26, 2009late night go cheezborger or club sammy. do not order rueben after 12am and your heart will thank you in the morning...
61 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Carroll Gardens Classic Diner
155 Smith St (btwn Bergen & Wyckoff St.)
Brooklyn, NY 11201
United States
Brooklyn, NY 11201
United States
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 24 Hours
(718) 403-9940
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Carroll Gardens Classic Diner
- 7.2
"Great happy hour- $3 draft beers, including sixpoint"
Logan Kinney - 7.9
"A cute spot with way cuter prices. I got nachos, popcorn and a juice for $12.50, a great price for the theatre! I love saving $$$."
Jane Eyre - 8.6
"Great selection of organic food at decent prices! Need to applaud on the friendly and excellent service. Oh yeah, and don't be discourage of the long lines, it goes by real quick and smoothly! Enjoy!"
Angona Tran
