Category icon

Sweet Tomatos

(Now Closed)
Italian Restaurant$$$$
Shelter Island Heights
Save
Share
Sweet Tomatos
Tips and Reviews icon15 Tips and reviews
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Yifen J.heart icon on user image
    Yifen JMay 29, 2014
    Homemade pasta at its best. Consider the fantastic menu, but always listen closely for the daily special. Also, the churros are a fantastic fried ending to your meal- get it.
  • Caitlin 🍄
    Caitlin 🍄May 4, 2014
    Service is four star (Raymond really took care of us) the monkfish is perfectly cooked and you will not regret the truffle arancini!
  • ZenFoodsterheart icon on user image
    ZenFoodsterJune 26, 2011
    Shelter Island's family-owned Italian that serves homemade pastas, bread, local produce & seafood. Locals say to book a table early..It'll be my first time trying blowfish! :)
  • Erica V.heart icon on user image
    Erica VirtueOctober 1, 2014
    Great service and delicious pizza, homemade pasta, and seafood. Sit at the bar for less expensive menu options.
  • Nicky K.
    Nicky K.August 30, 2014
    The best restaurant in shelter island! Trust me I've been to them all :)
  • Katie G.
    Katie GrishmanMay 24, 2014
    Love dinner at the bar! Great friends, fantastic food and a super friendly bar staff.
  • The Corcoran Group
    The Corcoran GroupMarch 14, 2011
    A family owned and operated restaurant/bar in the heart of Shelter Island Heights. Italian and Continental dishes but known for their Bar Pie.
  • Robbie K.
    Robbie KnoxApril 19, 2012
    Been here 5+ times
    Great, consistent Italian food. My choice watering hole on the island, as well.
  • Fresh
    FreshAugust 2, 2013
    very nice terrace, but food at Vine Street Cafe is way better
  • Dianna G.
    Dianna GeehrengApril 21, 2012
    Delicious food, exceptional service, welcoming atmosphere.....
  • Em S.
    Em StockerJuly 4, 2014
    Visited for lunch today. The paper menus were filthy. Left after ordering four sandwiches, and waiting more than an hour. never receiving them. It wasn't busy at all. Terrible service. Won't return.
  • Kevin F.
    Kevin FitzpatrickApril 2, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    Try the only wood-fire brick oven on the island. The pizza is incredible
  • Christina H.
    Christina HenslerSeptember 30, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    The risotto will change your life.
  • Lindsay S.
    Lindsay SpringerApril 9, 2010
    Awsome food and great service'
  • Mark B.
    Mark BakerDecember 29, 2011
    Choosethechirros
Photos24 Photos

Related Searches

  • sweet tomatos shelter island heights •
  • sweet tomatos shelter island heights photos •
  • sweet tomatos shelter island heights location •
  • sweet tomatos shelter island heights address •
  • sweet tomatos shelter island heights •
  • sweet tomato's shelter island heights •
  • sweet tomatoes shelter island heights •
  • sweet tomatos shelter island heights •

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

Compass icon
Sweet Tomatos
15 Grand Ave (Chase)
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
United States
Get directions
Phone icon
(631) 749-4114
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
See More

Places people like to go after Sweet Tomatos

Appears on 10 lists

See all
United States » New York » Suffolk County » Shelter Island Heights »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.