Milk Bar
Dessert Shop, Bakery, and Coffee Shop$$$$
Williamsburg, Brooklyn
"Not a fan of the cereal milk but the crack pie is on point!"(32 Tips)
"Try the Birthday Cake Truffles - One of the best truffles they have"(11 Tips)
"The compost cookie is wayyyy better than the cereal milk"(12 Tips)
"the corn cookie tastes like capt'n crunch"(6 Tips)
178 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- crack pie
- cookies
- milkshakes
- soft serve
- cake
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Djaniella D.January 28, 2015The cereal milk soft serve with cornflake crunch: YUM! Just when you think all the crunchies are gone, they save some for the bottom so the true cereal experience continues until the very last bite.
Felix AbarcaJune 3, 2016The team at this location is fantastic, incredibly helpful. Everything is so good here, you can't go wrong with anything, specially the Cereal Milk White Russian 🤘🏼
Upvoted Mar 24
Village VoiceAugust 8, 2012An unconventional trip back to the pastries of childhood, in their corn cookies and crack pie. There is sure to be nostalgia in every bite. #5 on Tejal Rao's 10 Best Pastry Shops in New York
Melissa PerezMay 1, 2019If you have a sweet tooth, try the crack pie! 🥧 It's full of flavor and textures which I always appreciate. The staff is kind 💕and answers any questions you have ⭐️
K & JFebruary 23, 2019The shakes are really unique and were amazing for an after dinner pick me up :)
CompassJuly 24, 2013Christina Tosi’s bakery is known for its “crack pies” and “compost cookies” and while those are exquisite, it’s the offbeat flavors of frozen yogurt that set it apart from other sweet eateries.
Jenny SorensenApril 8, 2015Momofuku’s Milk Bar houses the richest delicacies in the city like amazing alcoholic or virgin milkshakes, soft serves, pies, cookies as well as pork & vege buns. Read more
Megan JohnsonJune 1, 2013Cereal milk ice cream - nailed it! Love the blueberry & cream cookie, and the Yuzu Cherryrita (with tequila). It's sweet! Also of note - they have Mexican Cokes here!
Kourosh BehnamJune 15, 2015This place has some obsession with mixing cereal in every desert. The cereal soft serve ice cream gets old after the first couple of licks. Compost cookie was the only good thing I had.
Sunny HuiAugust 18, 2013Their soft serve milk icecream is okay.. Would only recommend if you're a big cereal fan! Must try their crack pie, my all time fav
T MarieAugust 20, 2014Be sure to try the cereal milk soft serve before going all in. It's yummy, but trying to eat a whole cup before it melts is a task for 2!
Jack HoflandJanuary 13, 2019Crack pie is only thing to go out of the way for. It's amazing. The rest is solid but can only be so good by the nature of what it is.
Leigh QuindaraMay 14, 2015Not sure what the hype is about. Nothing I've ever had here was any good. Even the cereal shake, which was pretty cool for the first minute I drank it, became bland and boring pretty fast.
Tiffany LeighAugust 6, 2011Their Cereal Milk-flavored soft serve with the cornflake crunch... they leave some in the bottom of the cup, so that when you are finished it's exactly like the finishing a bowl of cereal! Delicious.- The pretzel milk milkshake is the best.. get it if they have it! Also the crack pie soft serve ice cream.. so good!
- Ashley MowreyJuly 24, 2017Unless your cookies have arsenic in them, I will rate you highly. Momofuku is no exception, 10/10 hearts for creative sugar usage!
Duncan PJSeptember 1, 2014Too lazy and fat to chew your own food anymore? Try a pretzel milk milkshake they are amazing 😃
ingrid lopezApril 30, 2014Pork buns at Milk bars are different from restaurants (more like a gigantic dumpling) but also tasty. crack pie is a crack!
Thom FinnarnJune 2, 2019Cereal Milk soft serve and Crack Pie are the two legendary options... Don't go for the Quake combination, it's too much... Enjoy them separately.
Ray LinMay 24, 2012The cereal milk shake will be one of the best things you'll ever drink. Like childhood in a cup.
Mer IciJanuary 20, 2016Breads and meal deals are best here. Go egg & cheddar with a corn cookie & cold brew. They also have buns!
Raja HAugust 19, 2012Over-priced baked goods that you may not find elsewhere, but worth it on days you just want to treat yourself. Everything here is delicious.
Kushal DaveNovember 16, 2012The cereal milk white russian is delicious, with just a hint of booze. Protip: You can ask them to split it into two glasses.- Evva KraikulJuly 20, 2013Cereal milk is absolutely delicious. Go for the location in Williamsburg for better quality - the one at Union Square had a strange consistency in addition to bad service.
Lissette AMay 20, 2012The "Cereal Milk" ice cream is awesome! But you have to get the "crunchy corn flakes" topping. Taste just like a bowl of cereal!!! :)
Jessica C.July 16, 2015Cereal milk was just OK. The cornflakes really made the experience. The bday truffles are freaking amazing though!
Venkatesh KondamSettyMay 5, 2015
Eduardo AssunçãoNovember 11, 2018Didn’t really understand the hype. Everything is flavorless, it tastes like sugar. I’ve tried the ice cream, a milkshake and the crack pie (the only thing I believe is eatable).
Gaby GingolaJanuary 10, 2016The boozy milkshakes are good but very decadent so you're best off splitting one with a friend
Pramod PaiMay 8, 2015Here students will grasp every techniques needed to whip up popular toothsome treats from the acclaimed cookbook (plus some newer recipes) at home. Read more
Birthday Party Shake is good but a little strong. You have to drink it in the building (you can't even sit outside)
Kisha ChandlerJuly 9, 2018Delicious and different creative flavors. When on the North side a must try.
Davy KeseyJuly 8, 2017The cereal milk milkshake is overrated, in my opinion. It's basically salty ice cream. The service was pretty subpar too. For all the hype this place has, my experience was only 5/10.
- Try the Maple Cream Cheese Soft Serve - All 5 flavors in one day. I feel sick. This was the best one though.
Alex RobertsonJune 7, 2017I'm always angry when I see that tiny slice of crack pie ($6) slide out of that box. But then I taste it...
- Ask for your cereal milk with crunch in a parfait cup. Same amount of goodness but much easier to eat!
- Try the Oatmeal Creme Pie Soft Serve - Very good, maybe the best one in the current rotation of flavors
Elysia MannNovember 11, 2015The cereal milk soft serve is worth the hype time and time again and I don't even eat cereal
Charles LawSeptember 3, 2014If it's your first time here, you have to get the soft serve milk ice cream.
Selena DelgadoAugust 4, 2012arguably the best café americano in NYC. try the steamed buns with egg for breakfast. excellent service
Adelina TaftsiouJune 29, 2015Interesting place. The cereal milk ice cream flavor seems to be the most popular item selling. It's good, but I feel that too much of it is nauseating.
Ms HeleneDecember 17, 2012Off the beaten track but worth it for those cake balls amongst other quirky and tasty treats
Jordan CrookSeptember 24, 2014Cereal milk soft serve. Compost cookie milk shake. Compost cookie. Candy bar pie. Crack pie.- Try the Maple Cream Cheese Soft Serve - One of the best flavors here ever.
586 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Milk Bar is a sweet (and occasionally savory) shop that’s been quietly shaking up the dessert scene since 2008. Bon Appetit magazine called us “one of the most exciting bakeries in the country.” But you can literally just call us Milk Bar...
Closed until 10:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 10:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 10:00 AM–11:00 PM
(347) 799-2732
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Cocktails
See More
Places inside Milk Bar
You might also like
Appears on 1,012 lists
Created by ballsohardbmore
197 items • 280 followers
Created by beagle (brooklyn)
40 items • 170 followers
Eat & Drink in Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Created by Joe Minami
107 items • 130 followers
