Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza
(Now Closed)Pizzeria and Performing Arts Venue$$$$
Worthington
26 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Krystina DarfusJune 18, 2014You cannot go wrong with the meatball any pizza or the creme brulee du jour. Brett is also the best bartender here so make sure to sit at the bar and show him love.
Lindsey HobbsDecember 30, 2012Absolutely delicious! We got the Trevi Fountain and it was soo good. Waitress also was nice enough to ask the bartender about their red wines. I got the Franese and it went great with the food.
cobiJanuary 1, 2013this place is ah-mazing! pizza with truffle oil- wow. just wow. sat at the bar, bartender was very personable- asked our names, etc. will definitely be returning, especially for the live music!
Maria RJuly 25, 2013Awesome pizza- we got the Greenwich Village and the specialty which was "south of the border" type- jake peons, salsa, sausage. Both were outstanding!
Jim AllisonMay 28, 2014Nice atmosphere, good food. I especially enjoyed the Greenwich Village. Live music, expect a cover charge.
Katie JaspersJuly 19, 2016The Josephine pizza is fabulous! Also there's a really good local beer selection, too.
James JulianoDecember 18, 2013Natalies is always fun, with great food and a very nice wine selection. Mixed drinks are on point!
HeidiDecember 28, 2012The pizza is really good. Casanova was my favorite of the three we tried. Good music & atmosphere!
Erik BurgesonDecember 30, 2012Wow! The lighting is dim in here. I like intimate atmospheres, but I don't want to bump into people. Crossing my fingers about the pizza.
Julie KaberOctober 13, 2013brunch is amazing!!! Pleasantly surprised by the Aracini. Delicious and filling
Nico FrananoJanuary 21, 2013Natalie's should find a way to get their bands on foursquare to give them some pub from the check-ins.
Heather AlexanderOctober 6, 2012They can't accurately make a dirty martini here, be prepared to routinely send it back, not just me, a friend has also.
Anne LauxDecember 4, 2014Just ok. Nothing had a lot of flavor. Pizza was soggy. Would not return. Was a cover charge for a band....I just wanted food! Service a bit slow.
The urinal in the men's room is either child, midget, or porn star sized.
101 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Tue–Thu
- 5:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 4:00 PM–Midnight
- Sun
- 4:00 PM–11:00 PM
(614) 436-2625
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza
Appears on 25 lists
Created by Jayna Wallace
19 items • 1 followerCreated by Courtney Baxter
13 items • 1 followerCreated by Sandeep M
37 items • 1 follower
