Good 'N Plenty Restaurant
(Now Closed)Comfort Food Restaurant and American Restaurant$$$$
Smoketown
"Ham Loaf and butter noodles are to die for."(2 Tips)
"Yum yum! Best shoe fly pie and fried chicken"(2 Tips)
"The fried chicken and dessert were absolutely the best."(11 Tips)
"Drive up the road to Shady Maple, so much better."(2 Tips)
45 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- fried chicken
- shoe fly pie
- great value
- good for groups
- off-menu items
- (13 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Justin OrdovezaDecember 31, 2016They serve the food family style so pray you get good company. It's best to come early to avoid crowds, many buses come in swamping the hall with people. Save room pie!
Victor MilletJanuary 4, 2013This place is GREAT! FamilyStyle Dining is a pretty cool experience. And, the FriedChicken is juicy, crunchy, and delicious! Our waitress was Kim and she did a superb job. Thank you Good'N Plenty!
Tony XerriSeptember 25, 2020Loved this place! Incredible fried chicken, delicious roast beef, and all the sides were absolute dynamite. Doesnt break the bank either. You need to eat here!
Andrew HayakawaOctober 3, 2016Get ready to eat a lot of food! It's an all-you-can-eat family style dining experience. Share a long table with other guests. It's a fun way to meet new people and enjoy a meal together.
Mary EckertJuly 12, 2013Awesome food! The apple butter is delicious. Chicken salad, pepper slaw, and apple sauce. Potatoes, corn, mixed veggies, stewed tomatoes, brown butter noodles. Ham, fried chicken, fish, homemade bread- Brandon CainNovember 18, 2019Best restaurant in Lancaster. Family style restaurant (pass food around the table) with wow tasting food. Ham Loaf and butter noodles are to die for.
WicklessGoodFondueJune 25, 2012We came here about 8 years ago and had never eaten at a Family style restaurant!Food was delicious but it was really neat to be seated with total strangers but they felt like Family!!Highly Recommend!
Amy WulkeOctober 9, 2013My husband and I thought that this place was awesome! In fact it has been a few weeks since our vacation and we still bring it up! We wish we had a good n plenty in our state!
Jimena RojasOctober 9, 2012The food was amazing and the service was awesome. Don't forget to get a pie from the bakery downstairs. You. Will. Love. It. You're welcome.
Manuel UrenoMay 4, 2017Had one of the most quintessential American meals you can think of! The fried chicken was one of the best I've had.
We love the family style meals here! We come every year when we visit Lancaster County.
Gary MyerAugust 23, 2015Fried chicken, corn & peas were great! Ice cream with dessert was a real bonus!
Joseph ZamgulisOctober 31, 2016Family style was something new for me. But created a great setting for getting to know other people
Cyndy WJuly 15, 2013Sooo much food..if you go away hungry it's not their fault. Roast turkey and the sweet corn were really good
KedaJuly 28, 2013Amish people sure know what the hell they're doing because this was one of the best meals I've ever had.
MaryBeth RetaMay 27, 2016The bread is awesome, the food is tasteless. We couldn't finish our food it was that bad and declined the leftovers. Try Miller's Smorgasbord, you'll be much happier.
- Tanya Cuvinar-EbuenMay 29, 2012The fried chicken and dessert were absolutely the best. However, I was expecting Amish to be running the place, but that wasn't the case.
Fried chicken is amazing. Come for a good home cooked meal and friendly service. PA Dutch cooking at it's finest.
David UsseryJuly 10, 2014Not impressed! I would have thought for $22.00 each it would be out of this world.
Layne WomickJuly 6, 2021The food was okay. Our server was great. Some of the other staff left a little to be desired.
Andy GastauerSeptember 6, 2017Not great. Not bad. Average place. Wouldn't say anything was gluten free.
Eric VOctober 19, 2010Meatloaf is so-so. Alton brown has a better recipe. Everything else was good. I think it is better then shady maple for dinner.
97 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Serving up a unique and memorable PA Dutch dining experience since 1969, Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant features family-style dining, menu dining and ToGO.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 11:30 AM–7:00 PM
(717) 394-7111
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
Places people like to go after Good 'N Plenty Restaurant
Appears on 30 lists
Created by John
106 items • 57 followers
Top 10 favorites places in Lancaster, PA
Created by Lex
10 items • 6 followersCreated by Genie G
13 items • 3 followers