Melt Shop
Sandwich Spot$$$$
Theater District, New York
"Grilled chicken truffle melt is very good."(5 Tips)
"shop tots and nutella shake is the way"(4 Tips)
"Burger melt is absolutely delicious."(4 Tips)
"I can't even begin to describe how good the Nutella milkshake is"(3 Tips)
68 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- sandwiches
- tater tots
- truffle melt
- burger melt
- lively
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Alexandra MaesenMarch 12, 2015If I could give MeltShop more 4sq hearts I would! Fan since the beginning on 26th Str.! Little pricier than a regular sandwich, but oh so yummie. Truffle melt w/ mushr & caramel.onions all the way!
Nadia MalikSeptember 18, 2016Liked our sandwiches. Truffle melt vegetarian comfort food. Friend's Chicken was tender, crispy coat, sourdough was nice and toasted. Buffalo bleu cheese hybrid blend sauce: no actual cheese chunks.
Tiffany LangstonDecember 27, 2014Gourmet grilled cheese and shakes. It was a little disappointing that they weren't serving their entire list of house-made beverages (lemonade, strawberry lemonade, iced tea) hopefully it's temporary
CJ ThomasNovember 24, 2018They have a fried chicken melt, but feel free to swap a chicken into the burger melt if you don’t want all that extra stuff with the fried chicken melt. So delicious!- The Buffalo Blue was the perfect size. I got shop tots (and they were good) but it put my total over $10, not sure if I needed them. Careful they might be out of root beer when you go too.
My favorite lunch spot!! Gluten free bread upon request and make sure you get the shop tots with a side of melt sauce!
Jazzie ChanelMarch 28, 2019Food was fresh and hot. Love the tots. And seasoning on Nashville hot chicken was good. Just missing white onion!
Lori LuoJuly 25, 2015The burger melt and a side of loaded tots will definitely put you in a post-lunch coma. Choose your order wisely.
Bryant BalatbatAugust 22, 2015The sandwiches are large enough to split between two people. The fried chicken one was quite tasty. If you love root beer, make sure to try the Abita brew.
Christina VermillionJanuary 15, 20141st time I came here had grilled chicken sandwich and it was amazing. 2nd time back and all the filling was in one side of sandwich and other half was just two pieces of bread. Expected more for $$
Harumi UAugust 25, 2014They make their maple bacon very maple-y, but cheese is salty so they balance well. I like my grilled cheese less buttery and salty but I can see why so many people like sandwiches here
Sasha ChinnayaDecember 20, 2016It's a chill environment and the food is absolute comfort, especially if you love grilled cheeses. My favorite is the Truffle Melt.
PaddyFebruary 2, 2016Nice and simple menu. Burger melt was delicious and the house tots with parmesan dust were great too.
Peyton SherwoodJanuary 31, 2014Wisco (cheddar w bacon and tomato) is delicious. Clever to-go boxes keep the sandwich from getting soggy in its own box.- Jacob ForsterJune 21, 2015Burger melt is absolutely delicious. Get it. And top it off with some shop tots and a Nutella shake.
- Grilled chicken truffle melt is very good. For something less heavy, ask for your sandwich without butter.
Ameen AqeelOctober 25, 2014Delicious sandwiches, tried several and all were better than expected but on the heavy side nonetheless.
KristiaMarie Pastor BalatbatJuly 22, 2015Solid fried chicken sandwich Excellent tater tots. Best root beer - on tap!
Jade Del Castillo VaraJanuary 17, 2014Pricey but good. They are going to have an order online option in January, hopefully it will help this place deal with the lines.
Ask the friendly staff for a wifi password or just enjoy some solitude while you pop those tater tots.
Nick CruzJanuary 9, 2014Delicous grilled cheese... tell the people that are working there that they are chessey and watch what happens :)
Amol UtrankarDecember 22, 2013Hard to go wrong; all the sandwiches here are top-notch. Bit pricey for a grilled cheese though ..
Scott ParmenterJanuary 12, 2014Fried chicken sandwhich, shop tots and nutella shake is the way to go
Jonathan BonneyMay 24, 2017The food looks good but make sure you have and extended amount of time to eat. Stay onto them about your order too or you might never see it.
Jim IvinsJune 23, 2014It's a heart attack in a box but god damn if the Award Winner was not the best grilled cheese I've ever had in my life.
Emily HummelJanuary 21, 2014Get the tots without the cheese on top. Classic grilled cheese with onions and tomatoes is perfect.
171 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Melt Shop offers melted sandwiches featuring quality ingredients & handmade bread, with a selection of kid's meals, tater tots, salads, milkshakes & beverages.
Open until 9:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
(212) 974-3423
View menu on https://meltshop.olo.com/menu/1003-50th-ny
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer
See More
You might also like
- 8.5
"Great pick-up and go spot for lunch. Sgt Sweet Pepper on a hero was great and not too expensive ($9). Crispy chicken and great sandwich balance."
Nick Traycheff - 8.1
"The Teen Wolf tastes great. Add a beet salad"
Bastian Beyer - 6.9
"The sandwiches are warm and the line is pretty fast. Pick out your sandwich and be ready to give them your toppings quickly."
Giovanni Alvarez
Appears on 266 lists
Created by Matt Jones
12 items • 4 followers
Created by Shwetha Bhaskar
201 items • 5 followers
