See all
18 photos

Pufferbelly Restaurant & Bar

(Now Closed)

American Restaurant$$$$

Downtown Erie, Erie

Save

17 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Donna LuchDecember 12, 2013
Been here 5+ times
my long time friends and school mates ordered Prime Rib. It was tender, juicy. Recommended! Ask for au jus on the side instead of your plate, though.
Nicole ShearerApril 29, 2014
Outstanding food, service, and atmosphere!! Come here every time I'm in Erie. Yum!!!
Stephanie MeyerJuly 31, 2011
Avoid the smoky tomato/bacon penne. The bacon has a jerky consistency, and the smoke balance is too much, though I did really enjoy the bruschetta. More family oriented than I thought.
Edie SApril 29, 2014
Bread puddding is fabulous. We just shared the chocolate coconut. Delicious!
Bryan VarnerJuly 16, 2014
Ate there 15 years ago and the fillet mingon was hard as a hockey puck but im sure its improved since. Havent went back tho
aubrey oharaAugust 18, 2010
Been here 10+ times
try the Mai Tai...but only if rose is makin it! she's the only one in Erie who knows how to make it the right way! and it'll knock u on ur ass!!!!!
Michelle PekarskiFebruary 27, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Bruscetta and spinach artichoke dip. Yum!
visitPAMay 21, 2010
Housed in an old brick firehouse and aptly named after the locals’ nickname for “steam pumpers & engines.” Try the peanut butter pie. Read more
Leah MotzingSeptember 14, 2012
Our food was delicious but the service was piss poor, it took forever for us to get anything when there was only 3 other tables in the whole place
Molly PrzybelinskiJanuary 17, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Try the peanut butter pie!! Rich and delicious :)
Thom HaraczyOctober 13, 2011
Went there on a Wednesday night about 8 and they were closed!! Thought that was strange!
Kim EmehizerSeptember 30, 2012
Disappointed. Steaks Madagascar was over done and dry. Sauce was salty and tasted like something out of a jar. Salad dressing was watery. For 21.99 this was sooo not worth it!
Michael ThomasApril 3, 2013
Go with the Cincinnati chili.
Monica TakacsDecember 26, 2010
Sunday brunch only (no lunch) for $16.95. They don't serve other food until 3.
VisitErieMay 7, 2012
Been here 5+ times
3 words...Peanut Butter Pie
Duane BeckettAugust 20, 2012
Slow service! Make sure u ask what they don't have before you read the menu!
Laura GraceFebruary 15, 2012
I think my server is a pill popper, service was slow, and food wasn't hot. What happened to this place?

18 Photos

Pufferbelly Restaurant & Bar

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Pufferbelly Restaurant & Bar

Appears on 10 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.