Category icon

Old Homestead Steakhouse

Steakhouse, Seafood Restaurant, and American Restaurant$$$$
Chelsea, New York
Save
Share
7.9/10
499
ratings
  • Stars
  • Stars
    Has a stamp of approval from The Wall Street Journal and Eater
    • The Wall Street Journal
    • Eater
  • Tips
    Keoniinthecity
    "$20 for Kobe burger, tater tots, wine & salad: what's not to like!"(12 Tips)
    Teresa
    "Truffle mac and cheese is a must!!"(6 Tips)
    Brian P.
    "I had the best jumbo Shrimp Cocktail at the Old Homestead Restaurant"(3 Tips)
    Morten A.
    "My favourite steakhouse in NYC."(3 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon142 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • steak
  • burgers
  • old homestead
  • good for groups
  • filet mignon
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Lenny G.heart icon on user image
    Lenny GalloMarch 5, 2017
    Wow! The burgers are huge and hands down one of the best burgers in NYC. These sixteen ounce treats don't need anything on them. Also the French Onion is a must.
  • Eater
    EaterAugust 1, 2014
    The Old Homestead serves up 28 day dry aged USDA prime grade prime rib dubbed the Empire Cut. $55. Certain customers will special order a double rib cut. $110. Read more
  • Morten A.heart icon on user image
    Morten AuthenDecember 15, 2019
    What’s not to like here. My favourite steakhouse in NYC. I’ve had the scampi tempura, schrimp coctail, bacon slabs, 19oz filet mignon on the bone, truffel lobster mac and cheese, and I loved it :)
  • Bre T.
    Bre TempestaOctober 13, 2014
    Calamari was AMAZING. 18oz NY strip had NOT 1piece of fat. Scallion&filet was delicious (pictured). Martinis were phenomenal but small unlike previously mentioned. Great location!
  • Erik C.
    Erik CintronAugust 4, 2017
    All I have to say is Bacon wrapped filet mignon! One of the oldest steakhouses. Great service and food. Decor and drinks were perfect. Not to big, parking is horrible but its the city.
  • Richard R.heart icon on user image
    Richard RubelJanuary 10, 2020
    Aged rib eye for two med rare was perfect. Truffle dusted bake potato was not hot, too bad given the truffle herbed butter accompanying it. Wedge salad easily split. Great dinner with Malbec
  • PureWow
    PureWowDecember 18, 2015
    This 1968 relic is rumored to have invented the “doggie bag” to pack up its massive portions. Chow down on a giant cut of Kobe beef and a cauldron of truffle mac and cheese. Read more
  • al v.
    al viciedoSeptember 9, 2019
    Thick and meaty! That’s how I would describe the $45 Kobe burger. The burg is a generous 20 oz and is a solid 8. I’m disappointed at the little amount of fries for this massive burger.
  • David T.heart icon on user image
    David TrudoOctober 18, 2015
    Amazingly good filets and lobster. Around top 5 lifetime. The spinach side was nothing to write home about, but that wasn't the main dish anyway. Also, great drinks & atmosphere. They don't rush you.
  • Fuat Ş.heart icon on user image
    Fuat ŞahinAugust 25, 2014
    Yediğim en iyi new york sirloin. Ayrıca soğan halkasına dikkat. The best new york sirloin ever, also pay attention to the onion rings. The best
  • Richard R.heart icon on user image
    Richard RevillaAugust 20, 2015
    NYC oldest steakhouse. Have the rib eye for two aged 40 days. You're in the heart of Chelsea so enjoy everything around you.
  • David P.heart icon on user image
    David PereiraMarch 30, 2015
    Classic steakhouse that does not disappoint. I have visited numerous times and had the t-bone, the bone-in ribeye and the bacon wrapped fillet and all were awesome.
  • Bobby R.
    Bobby RApril 27, 2014
    Food is great, service is wonderful. Not the most generous portions in the world though. The porterhouse steak for two ($98) left us (two men) a little hungry. The servings are a little small.
  • Liam
    LiamDecember 30, 2014
    Steaks here are top notch and in true NY style, portions are generous. Steak au poivre was simply delicious.
  • Mark B.heart icon on user image
    Mark BSeptember 30, 2019
    Been here 5+ times
    A little piece of history in a continually evolving meatpacking district neighborhood. The Filet Mignon is wonderful. Great wine list, terrific service.
  • The Corcoran Group
    The Corcoran GroupNovember 1, 2011
    While the atmosphere is not the greatest (it’s awfully loud) you can’t argue that the Kobe Beef Burger isn’t one of the best in the city and worth it’s lofty price! Plus it comes with tater tots!
  • Natalieheart icon on user image
    NatalieAugust 4, 2017
    Great for special occasions. Food was delicious. Cream spinach and NY strip are great.
  • Tom H.heart icon on user image
    Tom HalleranMay 17, 2015
    Everything from the seafood tower to the drinks to the steaks are as good as you'd expect from one of the top, old school steakhouses in NYC.
  • R.Murat Y.
    R.Murat YilmazNovember 21, 2014
    Great and fun restaurant/diner with spectacular shakes and cocktails, as well as amazing burgers and an out-of-this-world Sandwich!
  • Raied F.
    Raied FarghalySeptember 17, 2023
    Kobe burger was delicious. Also the calamari and rock shrimp collision is a must.
  • Jonas H.heart icon on user image
    Jonas HuckstorfApril 11, 2018
    Amazing Steaks. Excellent service and high quality food. Try the porterhouse steak for two!
  • Mariam A.heart icon on user image
    Mariam AliNovember 24, 2018
    The STEAKS!!! Everything is just delicious. For appetizers, French onion soup and the garlic Parmesan bread was unique.
  • Lindsay C.heart icon on user image
    Lindsay CJanuary 3, 2016
    For you're craving that old school steakhouse food and vibe... Old Homestead serves up classically delicious steak, seafood and sides.
  • CARLOS R.
    CARLOS REDMONDApril 1, 2013
    Great laid back atmosphere, not too dressy and snooty, the waiters are very attentive and polite, I love how they always remember me every time I go.
  • Raj S.
    Raj S.October 9, 2014
    The filet was perfectly cooked for medium rare. Sides were decent but the meat can't be beat. Great for a power dinner with colleagues.
  • Joao V.heart icon on user image
    Joao Veloso JrAugust 16, 2015
    One of the best burgers in town. Truffled Mac & cheese also cool
  • Greg W.heart icon on user image
    Greg W.January 11, 2015
    One of the best in NY, in addition to steak their seafood appetizers and sides are also top notch
  • Luca P.
    Luca PietrantuonoJanuary 28, 2017
    I had the best rib-eye steak ever! Great steakhouse, maybe the best in the city!
  • Gianna N.heart icon on user image
    Gianna NebbiaSeptember 20, 2020
    Ribeye special, crab cocktail, and rock shrimp tempura
  • Stacy C.
    Stacy CApril 12, 2015
    The Macaroni and cheese with truffles is the truth! The Kobe Burger was probably the best I've ever tasted.
  • Kris C.heart icon on user image
    Kris ConcepcionApril 30, 2015
    The steaks are amazing and their wine list is intimidatingly large.
  • Nicole P.
    Nicole PolidoroSeptember 7, 2013
    Awesome! The bacon wrapped scallops for app, rib eye steak and truffled Mac and cheese are AMAZING!
  • Michael M.
    Michael MuseSeptember 10, 2014
    The service is horrible, but the burger is hilarious/good. Its like they took a filet and ground it up and made a full-pounder burger out of it. Actually thats probably exactly what they did...
  • Matt P.
    Matt PollicoveJuly 24, 2012
    Best steak in NYC! Ask for Ceasar, he'll take good care of you! The Shrimp appetizer are the biggest I've ever seen.
  • rich m.heart icon on user image
    rich masioApril 7, 2015
    The one and only. Salads, calamari, t-bone on this visit. All were perfect.
  • howard s.
    howard sunshineApril 28, 2013
    Vic and I go to Peter Lugars just too many times. I wanted the Kobe steak. It's my birthday so it's worth it. I never paid $350 for a steak before. Oh boy
  • Dano T.
    Dano TMarch 26, 2011
    This is the best lunch special and the best burger. $19 for kobe burger, tater tots, caesar salad, and glass of wine. It can't be beat.
  • Melissa G.
    Melissa Garrity GonzalezFebruary 28, 2012
    Try the chef's special bread preparation - looks like a game of Jenga with awesome Alfredo type dipping sauce - SO good!!!
  • What's Good Here
    What's Good HereMarch 31, 2017
    Don't come here for the service. Unlike the high end NYC steakhouses, its a hit or miss here.
  • Rev C.
    Rev CiancioNovember 16, 2011
    While the steaks here are top notch, I definitely suggest splitting the Homestead Burger as an appetizer! Read more
  • Icarus L.heart icon on user image
    Icarus LeungMay 1, 2013
    Get to order HE GOTHAM RIB STEAK ON THE BONE 32oz. So GOOD
  • Dewyheart icon on user image
    DewyOctober 30, 2016
    Classy. Crab cake was very good. Friendly, nice servers.
  • ANGELA W.heart icon on user image
    ANGELA WILLIAMSAugust 19, 2014
    Steak, vegetables, even the bread. You will love it!
  • SPQRheart icon on user image
    SPQROctober 18, 2015
    Wow... Amazing food. Carefully with the staff as they will try to talk you into expensive options
  • Aaron C.
    Aaron ColmanApril 22, 2011
    Kobe burger lunch deal for $19 is worth it. Fresh burger, tater-tots and start with a crisp ceasar salad
  • Rebecca M.heart icon on user image
    Rebecca MazzaJune 24, 2015
    Bacon burger is outstanding but huge!
  • Rev C.
    Rev CiancioJanuary 16, 2011
    The steak is great but so is the burger. Do NOT miss out on the bacon appetizer. Click the link for more info Read more
  • Jerry K.
    Jerry KallarakkalSeptember 15, 2011
    Steaks are great. The truffle mac is very tasty. The raw bar is great too if you like fresh seafood.
  • Jim C.
    Jim ClarkMarch 5, 2010
    Chopped salad, east coast oysters,filet on the bone and do the shaved onions! Add a glass of the house Cabernet and your arteries are good to go!
  • Andrew T.
    Andrew ThomasApril 21, 2012
    Great place if you're with your buddies and you don't wanna talk about life's sh*t. Or if you wanna be boisterous and obnoxious.
Photos526 Photos

Related Searches

  • old homestead steakhouse new york •
  • old homestead steakhouse new york photos •
  • old homestead steakhouse new york location •
  • old homestead steakhouse new york address •
  • old homestead steakhouse new york •
  • homestead steak house new york •
  • homestead steakhouse new york •
  • old homestead new york •
  • old homestead gourmet shop new york •
  • old homestead restaurant new york •
  • old homestead steak house new york •
  • old homestead steakhouse new york •
  • old homestead steakhouse chelsea new york

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA