Lake Effect Ice Cream is one of Top picks for Ice Cream Shops.

1. Lake Effect Ice Cream

9.4
Ice Cream Shop · 79 Canal St, Lockport, NY

Alan B.Alan Bedenko: The sundaes are a meal unto themselves, and the best one IMHO is the French salted caramel. Read more.

Frey's Tasty Treat is one of Top picks for Ice Cream Shops.

2. Frey's Tasty Treat

8.5
Ice Cream Shop · 6186 S Transit Rd, Lockport, NY

Alan B.Alan Bedenko: The special swirl with either chocolate or butterscotch dip is a win every time.

Anderson's Frozen Custard is one of Top picks for Ice Cream Shops.

3. Anderson's Frozen Custard

7.5
Ice Cream Shop · 6075 Main St (at Arlington Rd), Williamsville, NY

Alan B.Alan Bedenko: It ain't the best, but it gets you there.

Charlap's Ice Cream is one of Top picks for Ice Cream Shops.

4. Charlap's Ice Cream

8.2
Ice Cream Shop · 7264 Boston State Rd, Hamburg, NY

Alan B.Alan Bedenko: Fresh and delicious flavors.

Hibbard's Original Frozen Custard is one of Top picks for Ice Cream Shops.

5. Hibbard's Original Frozen Custard

8.2
Ice Cream Shop · 105 Portage Rd (at Center St), Lewiston, NY

Alan B.Alan Bedenko: Best. Mouthfeel. Ever.