Carnegie Deli

Carnegie Deli

(Now Closed)
Deli / Bodega, Sandwich Place, and American Restaurant$$$$
Theater District, New York
293 Tips and reviews
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Karl W.
    A New York cultural institution.
  • Javier
    JavierDecember 31, 2016
    Rubens pastrami is great and big!!
  • Diana P.
    Diana PardueDecember 31, 2016
    Now closed :(
  • Max P.
    Max PerryDecember 30, 2016
  • Karl W.
    Karl With A "K"December 30, 2016
    Pastrami sandwich. Need I say any more?
  • Alex A.
    Alex ADecember 23, 2016
    Pastrami and corned beef sandwiches
  • Barry B.
    Barry BloomDecember 12, 2016
    Have eaten here for 40 years. With it closing on Dec. 31 this was my last experience tonight: they closed an hour early because of "technical" problems and the manager didn't care. Good riddance.
  • Eric G.
    Eric GallegosDecember 7, 2016
    Overpriced? Yeah. Delicious? You bet! An institution for a reason. Get some before it closes! Woody Allen. Latke. Cheesecake.
  • A Y.
    A YNovember 19, 2016
    We shared a pastrami Reuben and a slice of strawberry cheesecake and that was more than enough!
  • Mikhail B.
    Mikhail BaraboshinNovember 15, 2016
    Not worth waiting. Just average.
  • Scott S.
    Scott S.November 3, 2016
    Usually get the Woody Allen sandwich (combo of pastrami and corned beef). Everything is top shelf, here- Matzo ball soup; Brisket; Latkes - all good. Desserts are fantastic- try the 5th Avenue Pie
  • Scott Kleinberg
    Scott KleinbergOctober 28, 2016
    Pastrami on rye with spicy mustard. The menu is HUGE but this is the best thing you can order.
  • Samara G.
    Samara GrassottiOctober 8, 2016
    Horrible service! All silverware is greasy and dirty and the food is not even that good. No wonder they're closing!
  • Saarim Z.
    Saarim ZamanSeptember 30, 2016
    A sandwich here easily feeds like ... 4
  • Brett V.
    Brett VSeptember 21, 2016
    Bring you appetite and definitely get the strawberry cheesecake!
  • Roberto C.
    Roberto CosteSeptember 18, 2016
    Be aware of the size of the sandwiches! Huge portions; the Woody Allen is delicious! Pastrami with corn beef
  • Mohammed G.
    Mohammed GhaithSeptember 10, 2016
    There's a long line but it's worth it! Enjoy the pastrami sandwich and the cheesecake
  • Josh D.
    Josh DantoAugust 26, 2016
    Pastrami on rye is a staple, but I dig the salami even more!
  • Erhan I.
    Erhan ImamogluJuly 23, 2016
    Fries and Cole slaw. However not worth waiting in line for an hour.
  • Madison B.
    Madison BackJune 15, 2016
    Oh my god. Gluten free cheesecake. 😳
    ESTHERJune 7, 2016
    The potato salad was amazing!!! Sandwiches are big enough for two to three people.
  • Paddy
    PaddyMay 10, 2016
    Nice traditional NY deli serving sandwiches and breakfast. Pastrami omelette was very good
  • Fuat Ş.
    Fuat ŞahinApril 30, 2016
    I don't care others, best ln town folks..
  • Allison L.
    Allison LevineMarch 30, 2016
    Customer service leaves much to be desired, I have had better exeriences and food at Katz's
  • Nana N.
    Nana NamiMarch 27, 2016
    Woody Allen + Cheesecake
  • Chris D.
    Chris DrakeMarch 25, 2016
    Don't do it. Horrible slow service and way overpriced. The portion sizes are also wasteful and certainly hope they're doing something responsible with the waste.
  • Curtis J.
    Curtis J.March 18, 2016
    Be prepared to wait to sit AND wait for service once you get a table. Take out to avoid the delays and frustrations.
  • Curtis J.
    Curtis J.March 17, 2016
    Consider splitting a sandwich with a friend. They're huge!
  • Joshua S.
    Joshua SassMarch 15, 2016
    Open faced roast beef was so good. Tender and tasty.
  • Ruoyi J.
    Ruoyi JiangMarch 14, 2016
    Possibly the worst cheesecake I've ever eaten. I felt betrayed, possibly violated
  • Elizabeth E.
    Elizabeth EngelbrechtMarch 14, 2016
    Sandwiches were great. Cheesecake was even better!
  • David S.
    David SolimanoFebruary 9, 2016
    Try one of everything. If you get the Reuben, being someone to split it with.
  • Nikos F.
    Nikos FotouJanuary 31, 2016
    Deli. Pastrami
  • Brad K.
    Brad KavinDecember 29, 2015
    Pastrami sandwich
  • Hong Kyu P.
    Hong Kyu ParkJuly 4, 2015
    Love the pastrami and corned beef sandwiches. The pickles are also a must. Watch out for the giant servings
  • Adam J.
    Adam JohnsonMay 25, 2015
    Corned beef was great
  • Julio V.
    Julio VillarrealMay 24, 2015
    Try the pastrami sandwich, there's nothing like it on earth!
  • Shek L.
    Shek LeeApril 28, 2015
    Pastrami and cow's tongue sandwiches
  • John B.
    John BielickiApril 19, 2015
    Great food and great times.
  • Lizz C.
    Lizz C.April 12, 2015
    Excellent food!! They permanently closed their back room so there is always a line out the door.
  • Ariel S.
    Ariel SchpolianskyMarch 27, 2015
    Nice fast food
  • Lee S.
    Lee SimpsonMarch 22, 2015
    The Ruben. You know you want to.
  • Josh W.
    Josh WarfieldMarch 13, 2015
    the brisket sandwhich or the open face reuben! the sandwhiches are huge! love the homemade pickles. finish the night off with some strawberry cheese cake.
  • Joseph O.
    Joseph OsorioMarch 9, 2015
    Pastrami manwish is to die for. greeeaaatt.
  • Marc
    MarcMarch 9, 2015
    “the matzo-ball soup is terrific; The towering Woody Allen is satisfying; Carnegie is impt because it's the last of the great tourist-hazing Broadway showbiz delis” – GS:
  • Travis H.
    Travis HolcombJanuary 26, 2015
    Chocolate egg cream
  • A A.
    A AlawadiJanuary 10, 2015
    The monstrosity of the pastrami.... one of the best sandwiches i have ever had!!
  • Barry B.
    Barry BloomJanuary 7, 2015
    One of my all-time favorites. Dinner there on Monday with mom, brother Steve, Kreda, Sosh and son, Jackson. Brother ask waiter if bread comes with his omelette. "You have to ask," he says. Classic!
  • Mar S.
    Mar SDecember 29, 2014
    The Pastrami Sandwich could feed 4 guys at a time
  • Rafael B.
    Rafael BagmanovDecember 25, 2014
    Best cheesecacke I've ever tasted. Neato. Mucho neato
  • Susan B.
    Susan BurroughsNovember 27, 2014
    Excellent hot pastrami sandwich and must try the latkes !
  • Sven L.
    Sven LenaertsNovember 24, 2014
    I don't really like cheese cake but I was pleasantly surprised by the strawberry cheese cake. Would order again.
  • cupkeyk
    cupkeykNovember 17, 2014
    Omg! Tower of everything. Corned beef, pastrami, bacon, turkey, cheese. Good for sharing, even for the regular order ones. I love their strawberry cheesecake. Old chinese lady was so cute.
  • Biz T.
    Biz TraveldudeNovember 9, 2014
    Can't beat the sandwiches here
  • Natasha O.
    Natasha OgrodnikNovember 8, 2014
    We visit here whenever in NYC. Even as a vegetarian I loved this place. Their veggie burger is to die for and their red velvet cake is spectacular. Huge, tasty salads and amazing sandwiches.
  • Jason
    JasonNovember 4, 2014
    If you come for a breakfast bagel, don't get the eggs! They're good but extremely expensive!
  • Eddie
    EddieOctober 15, 2014
    Best pastrami sandwiches in NyC. Now they have the Derek Jeter sandwich it's a most try. Amazing melt in your mouth food!!
  • Harumi U.
    Harumi UOctober 3, 2014
    Everything is big here. You can split anything you get with someone else. Sandwiches, knish, cheesecake are worth trying at least once.
  • Alfred A.
    Alfred ASeptember 27, 2014
    If you want to pay an arm and a leg for a pile of pastrami between two slices of cold bread this is the place to go. Servers are pushy and you are herded around. Go just to take a pic.
  • Jack H.
    Jack HarrisonSeptember 17, 2014
    Grab a pastrami on rye, but share it unless you're feeling epic. Same story with the cheesecake, if you can handle it after the meats!
  • Inderpreet S.
    Inderpreet SinghSeptember 16, 2014
    This place smells gross!
  • Cenk M. Y.
    Cenk M. YetisSeptember 8, 2014
    Beef encounter was far too much for me!
  • Eduardo
    EduardoSeptember 8, 2014
    Woody Allen, definitely
  • TV Food Maps
    TV Food MapsSeptember 2, 2014
    Check out Carnegie Deli as seen on Food Paradise Read more
  • Miguel G.
    Miguel GalarzaAugust 22, 2014
    Corn beef:-)
  • Chax C.
    Chax ChacaAugust 20, 2014
    Gargantum Rouben and blueberry cheesecake. I regret nothing!
  • Emil P.
    Emil PalmsköldAugust 15, 2014
    Terrible service and the food is very expensive. But the cheesecake is worth it all.
  • Joe C.
    Joe CheskinAugust 14, 2014
    Huge sandwiches and the best pastrami this side of Katz's Deli.
  • Lori F.
    Lori FuentesAugust 14, 2014
    The pastrami was tender and was possibly the best I have ever had. Also large portions so sharing was perfect.
  • Ege
    EgeAugust 12, 2014
    World class delicatessen located in the heart of NYC. My advice is to try one of the specials
  • JP P.
    JP ParkAugust 11, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Must have a hot pastrami on rye and a slice of plain cheesecake, much better than Juniors
  • Jenn P.
    Jenn PAugust 10, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Share the Reuben and fries with Russian dressing. So good!
  • Christopher C.
    Christopher CassettaAugust 8, 2014
    Fun experience, but too pricy and touristy to make a regular thing.
  • Ken P.
    Ken Pierre IIAugust 7, 2014
    That 3am breakfast is clutch
  • Michael O.
    Michael ONeilAugust 6, 2014
    Corn beef is great, and massive (like all their sandwiches)!
  • Héloïse M.
    Héloïse MJuly 29, 2014
    Great pastrami!!!! Excellent service and ambiance. But expensive
  • Suzanne
    SuzanneJuly 26, 2014
    Not just legendary - the food is outstanding!
  • Elizabeth G.
    Elizabeth GardnerJuly 9, 2014
    Ask how big a side dish is before ordering. Potions here are huge. I asked for a side of bacon and I swear they brought me a pound of it on a plate.
  • David E.
    David ElrodMay 20, 2014
    Woody Allen. Get it.
  • Simon
    SimonMay 8, 2014
    Went there based on the reviews here. My faith in 4square reviews has been shaken. Chicken salad sandwich was dry and tasteless, burger likewise. Crazy overpriced.
  • Ohara T.
    Ohara TaneApril 11, 2014
    Must try the traditonal cheesecake.. Sooo yummy!
  • Yousef R.
    Yousef RaffaApril 6, 2014
    You can never go wrong with the best Pastrami sandwich
  • Amir A.
    Amir A.March 31, 2014
    Go for hot Pastrami you won't regret
  • Alycia C.
    Alycia CuckaMarch 15, 2014
    The hard salami is...really hard. Only order if you have a strong set of teeth!
  • Wes K.
    Wes KovalMarch 2, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Pickles Pickles Pickles
  • Nat H.
    Nat HarwardJanuary 29, 2014
    Regular cheesecake > chocolate truffle cheesecake
  • Katie A.
    Katie AllenJanuary 18, 2014
    Good food, but way over priced. It is NYC and it is tourist trap --- but $40 for an open faced sandwich and a glass of iced tea?!?!
  • Hi There!
    Hi There!January 13, 2014
    Portions are HUGE! Split meals, unless you want a couple of days worth of leftovers. It's worth the $3 split plate fee.
  • Arlene M.
    Arlene MurphyJanuary 3, 2014
    Don't go alone. Oversized portions of everything but so good!!!!! Avoid sharing fee by one ordering sandwich and other ordering dessert.
  • Ken S.
    Ken SpeakesJanuary 1, 2014
    Make sure MONICA is your server. She's a gem.
  • James S.
    James SmithDecember 12, 2013
    Do yourself a favor and don't order delivery to a hotel. We finally got our food ninety minutes and ten phone calls later and, big surprise, it was cold. Totally inept at delivering to a hotel.
  • Marika C.
    Marika ConwayDecember 6, 2013
    Be forewarned-sandwiches are HUGE! Definitely share! You think it's pricey then you see what you get and you see why. Really fun place to be! If you want lunch go early-the line gets crazy by 12.
  • Graphic Agency
    Graphic AgencyNovember 28, 2013
    The venerable delicatessen's Sandwich of the Month. This puppy features a pair of latkes piled with roast turkey, gravy and stuffing, served open-faced with cranberry sauce on the side.
  • Tankut A.
    Tankut AkayNovember 24, 2013
    Pastrami and pickles, very delicious
  • Sandra R.
    Sandra RNovember 17, 2013
    Get the Woody Allen, a pastrami cornbeef combo its the bomb!
  • Social News Network
    Social News NetworkOctober 30, 2013
    Scrumptious sandwiches. I recommend the Reuben; it is incredible. Just a heads-up: the sandwiches are stupidly huge so plan on splitting. Small, packed, little place with an awesome New York-feel.
  • 🐯 A.
    🐯 AOctober 26, 2013
    Wastefully and gluttonously large portions.
    FoodSherpas.comSeptember 24, 2013
    Try the Chicken Ceaser Salad
  • Stephanie R.
    Stephanie RosadoSeptember 19, 2013
    The WORST cheesecake I have ever had in my life. Super dry. Not enough strawberry sauce...12 bucks...huge slice but NOT worth it. Trust me. Go to Eileen's special cheesecake or to Junior's.
  • Nicole A.
    Nicole AngelesSeptember 15, 2013
    I got the woody allen sandwich with a slice of swiss. Nothing special I still prefer Katz over Carnegie. But I heard their reuben was pretty good so I'll guess I'll have to come back for that!
  • Guilherme 梅.
    Guilherme 梅田October 29, 2016
    Um dos melhores sanduíches!!! Cuidado que eles são enormes! A dica é o de Pastrami!!!!! O lugar sempre tem filas mas vale a pena esperar.. enquanto aguarda, veja as fotos de quem ja veio aqui!!!
  • Angelica L.
    Angelica LestaOctober 2, 2016
    Sandwich de pastron increíble (para compartir!!!)
  • Zeynep A.
    Zeynep AydemirJuly 6, 2016
    İçerde en az 20 kişilik masa boş insanlar dışarda kuyruk bekliyor! Sorduğumda yeterli garsonumuz yok o masalar müsait değil cevabını aldım. Ya bunlar gerizekalı ya da kuyruk havası yapıyorlar. Çakal!
  • Ronaldo M.
    Ronaldo MatosoJanuary 26, 2016
    Considerado entre os três melhores sanduíche de pastrami de NYC, lotado como sempre destaque para sanduíche Woody Allen ....
  • Lucas
    LucasMarch 19, 2015
    Achei o atendimento ruim... Ja a carne e a batata, uma delicia... Não é a toa que toda hora tem uma fila enorme. E da pra conhecer as pessoas ao seu lado (divide mesa! )
  • Владимир Т.
    Что для Американца хорошо, для Русского отвратительно.....не тратьте время и деньги!
  • Cleide C.
    Cleide C.December 31, 2014
    Tudo é muito bom!!! Já comi sanduiche de pastrami e levei mais da metade pra casa; dividi uma fatia de cheese cake com cobertura de blueberries... Sinto água na boca ao relembrar!!!!
  • Лариса П.
    Здесь готовят самые лучшие бургеры в мире. Это официально признано!
  • Nadia O.
    Nadia OcampoAugust 19, 2014
    Delicioso! Pidan el sándwich que quieran y Pay de queso ambos para compartir. Las cantidades son exageradas! Les cobrarán 3 dlls . Esto es medio sándwich!
  • Umit A.
    Umit AlpaslanAugust 8, 2014
    Cheese cake başta hersey
  • Gabriela V.
    Gabriela VilelaAugust 4, 2014
    para comer
  • Memo G.
    Pregunta por Eusebio y sus recomendaciones, he is The man!
  • Löplöpçüler
    LöplöpçülerFebruary 11, 2014
    Pastrami sandviç ve cornef beef sandviç çok başarılı, yok ben ikisinden de tatmak isterim diyorsanız "Woody Allen" derim
1,816 Photos

Related Searches

  • carnegie deli new york
  • carnegie deli new york photos
  • carnegie deli new york location
  • carnegie deli new york address
  • carnegie deli new york
  • carnagie deli new york
  • carnegie deli new york
  • carnegie deli restaurant new york
  • carnegie delicatessan new york
  • carnegie delicatessen new york
  • carnegie delicatessen & restaurant new york
  • carnegie delicatessen and restaurant new york
  • carnegie's deli new york
  • carnegies deli new york
  • carnegy delli new york
  • carnegie deli theater district new york

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF