Carnegie Deli

Carnegie Deli

(Now Closed)
Deli / Bodega, Sandwich Place, and American Restaurant$$$$
Theater District, New York
266 Tips and reviews
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Karl W.
    A New York cultural institution.
  • Javier
    JavierDecember 31, 2016
    Rubens pastrami is great and big!!
  • Diana P.
    Diana PardueDecember 31, 2016
    Now closed :(
  • Max P.
    Max PerryDecember 30, 2016
  • Karl W.
    Karl With A "K"December 30, 2016
    Pastrami sandwich. Need I say any more?
  • Alex A.
    Alex ADecember 23, 2016
    Pastrami and corned beef sandwiches
  • Barry B.
    Barry BloomDecember 12, 2016
    Have eaten here for 40 years. With it closing on Dec. 31 this was my last experience tonight: they closed an hour early because of "technical" problems and the manager didn't care. Good riddance.
  • Eric G.
    Eric GallegosDecember 7, 2016
    Overpriced? Yeah. Delicious? You bet! An institution for a reason. Get some before it closes! Woody Allen. Latke. Cheesecake.
  • Andreas Y.
    Andreas YiannikarisNovember 19, 2016
    We shared a pastrami Reuben and a slice of strawberry cheesecake and that was more than enough!
  • Mikhail B.
    Mikhail BaraboshinNovember 15, 2016
    Not worth waiting. Just average.
  • Scott S.
    Scott S.November 3, 2016
    Usually get the Woody Allen sandwich (combo of pastrami and corned beef). Everything is top shelf, here- Matzo ball soup; Brisket; Latkes - all good. Desserts are fantastic- try the 5th Avenue Pie
  • Scott Kleinberg
    Scott KleinbergOctober 28, 2016
    Pastrami on rye with spicy mustard. The menu is HUGE but this is the best thing you can order.
  • Samara G.
    Samara GrassottiOctober 8, 2016
    Horrible service! All silverware is greasy and dirty and the food is not even that good. No wonder they're closing!
  • Saarim Z.
    Saarim ZamanSeptember 30, 2016
    A sandwich here easily feeds like ... 4
  • Brett V.
    Brett VSeptember 21, 2016
    Bring you appetite and definitely get the strawberry cheesecake!
  • Roberto C.
    Roberto CosteSeptember 18, 2016
    Be aware of the size of the sandwiches! Huge portions; the Woody Allen is delicious! Pastrami with corn beef
  • Mohammed G.
    Mohammed GhaithSeptember 10, 2016
    There's a long line but it's worth it! Enjoy the pastrami sandwich and the cheesecake
  • Josh D.
    Josh DantoAugust 26, 2016
    Pastrami on rye is a staple, but I dig the salami even more!
  • Erhan I.
    Erhan ImamogluJuly 23, 2016
    Fries and Cole slaw. However not worth waiting in line for an hour.
  • Madison B.
    Madison BackJune 15, 2016
    Oh my god. Gluten free cheesecake. 😳
    ESTHERJune 7, 2016
    The potato salad was amazing!!! Sandwiches are big enough for two to three people.
  • Paddy
    PaddyMay 10, 2016
    Nice traditional NY deli serving sandwiches and breakfast. Pastrami omelette was very good
  • Fuat Ş.
    Fuat ŞahinApril 30, 2016
    I don't care others, best ln town folks..
  • Allison L.
    Allison LevineMarch 30, 2016
    Customer service leaves much to be desired, I have had better exeriences and food at Katz's
  • Nana N.
    Nana NamiMarch 27, 2016
    Woody Allen + Cheesecake
  • Chris D.
    Chris DrakeMarch 25, 2016
    Don't do it. Horrible slow service and way overpriced. The portion sizes are also wasteful and certainly hope they're doing something responsible with the waste.
  • Curtis J.
    Curtis J.March 18, 2016
    Be prepared to wait to sit AND wait for service once you get a table. Take out to avoid the delays and frustrations.
  • Curtis J.
    Curtis J.March 17, 2016
    Consider splitting a sandwich with a friend. They're huge!
  • Joshua S.
    Joshua SassMarch 15, 2016
    Open faced roast beef was so good. Tender and tasty.
  • Ruoyi J.
    Ruoyi JiangMarch 14, 2016
    Possibly the worst cheesecake I've ever eaten. I felt betrayed, possibly violated
  • Elizabeth E.
    Elizabeth EngelbrechtMarch 14, 2016
    Sandwiches were great. Cheesecake was even better!
  • David S.
    David SolimanoFebruary 9, 2016
    Try one of everything. If you get the Reuben, being someone to split it with.
  • Nikos F.
    Nikos FotouJanuary 31, 2016
    Deli. Pastrami
  • Brad K.
    Brad KavinDecember 29, 2015
    Pastrami sandwich
  • Hong Kyu P.
    Hong Kyu ParkJuly 4, 2015
    Love the pastrami and corned beef sandwiches. The pickles are also a must. Watch out for the giant servings
  • Adam J.
    Adam JohnsonMay 25, 2015
    Corned beef was great
  • Julio V.
    Julio VillarrealMay 24, 2015
    Try the pastrami sandwich, there's nothing like it on earth!
  • Shek L.
    Shek LeeApril 28, 2015
    Pastrami and cow's tongue sandwiches
  • John B.
    John BielickiApril 19, 2015
    Great food and great times.
  • Lizz C.
    Lizz C.April 12, 2015
    Excellent food!! They permanently closed their back room so there is always a line out the door.
  • Ariel S.
    Ariel SchpolianskyMarch 27, 2015
    Nice fast food
  • Lee S.
    Lee SimpsonMarch 22, 2015
    The Ruben. You know you want to.
  • Josh W.
    Josh WarfieldMarch 13, 2015
    the brisket sandwhich or the open face reuben! the sandwhiches are huge! love the homemade pickles. finish the night off with some strawberry cheese cake.
  • Joseph O.
    Joseph OsorioMarch 9, 2015
    Pastrami manwish is to die for. greeeaaatt.
  • Marc E.
    Marc EMarch 9, 2015
    “the matzo-ball soup is terrific; The towering Woody Allen is satisfying; Carnegie is impt because it's the last of the great tourist-hazing Broadway showbiz delis” – GS:
  • Travis H.
    Travis HolcombJanuary 26, 2015
    Chocolate egg cream
  • A A.
    A AlawadiJanuary 10, 2015
    The monstrosity of the pastrami.... one of the best sandwiches i have ever had!!
  • Barry B.
    Barry BloomJanuary 7, 2015
    One of my all-time favorites. Dinner there on Monday with mom, brother Steve, Kreda, Sosh and son, Jackson. Brother ask waiter if bread comes with his omelette. "You have to ask," he says. Classic!
  • Mar S.
    Mar SDecember 29, 2014
    The Pastrami Sandwich could feed 4 guys at a time
  • Rafael B.
    Rafael BagmanovDecember 25, 2014
    Best cheesecacke I've ever tasted. Neato. Mucho neato
1,819 Photos

Related Searches

  • carnegie deli new york
  • carnegie deli new york photos
  • carnegie deli new york location
  • carnegie deli new york address
  • carnegie deli new york
  • carnagie deli new york
  • carnegie deli new york
  • carnegie deli restaurant new york
  • carnegie delicatessan new york
  • carnegie delicatessen new york
  • carnegie delicatessen & restaurant new york
  • carnegie delicatessen and restaurant new york
  • carnegie's deli new york
  • carnegies deli new york
  • carnegy delli new york
  • carnegie deli theater district new york

Foursquare © 2017  Lovingly made in NYC & SF