Reloading results...

Suggestions for Dining and Drinking near Montauk

Filters:
    • 8.9
      Seafood$$$$
      88 Firestone Rd, Montauk
      Save
      • Idan S.

        Idan S. • October 13, 2017Great spot for grabbing a beer and watch the sunset

    • 8.7
      Mediterranean$$$$View Menu
      11 S Emery St (S Euclid Ave), Montauk
      Save
      • CM S.

        CM S. • May 19, 2014Family style dishes (read: very large!) Order to share. Delicious!

    • 8.7
      Ice Cream$$$$View Menu
      478 West Lake Drive Extension, Montauk
      Save
      • Laura M.

        Laura M. • July 18, 2012Very nice service, let me take a taste and recommended a great Carmel flavor!!

    • 8.5
      Bagels$$$$
      28 S. Etna Ave, Montauk
      Save
      • Ardvaark

        Ardvaark • September 19, 2016The bagels are great, but the flagels are even better!

    • 8.5
      Coffee Shop$$$$
      83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk
      Save
      • Yannis P.

        Yannis P. • October 22, 2015Espressos, cappuccinos, lattes, cold drip coffee and new seasonal flavor lattes :)

    • 8.4
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk
      Save
      • Katie G.

        Katie G. • August 19, 2014Byob and fresh fish. Perfect for a Hamptons summer night. Come early to avoid long waits and surprisingly cold night breezes.

    • 8.4
      Bakery$$$$
      29 Carl Fisher Plz, Montauk
      Save
      • Kathleen V.

        Kathleen V. • August 8, 2015The fish cookie was adorable and it taste really good and I would really recommend you guys having the blueberry crumb cake. I would come back just for those two things. :)

    • 8.3
      Seafood$$$$
      352 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • Sally

        Sally • June 5, 2015Chowda + calamari bibb lettuce basil cilantro salad for the win ....down to earth vibe with a friendly staff and regulars

    • 8.3
      Beach Bar
      The Crow's Nest, Montauk
      Save
      • Jasmine D.

        Jasmine D. • August 4, 2020Sea bass ceviche is the best I’ve had in NY.

    • 8.2
      American$$$$View Menu
      32 Star Island Rd, Montauk
      Save
      • SPQR

        SPQR • October 18, 2015Amazing... The Montauk Blue drink is a must have

    • 8.2
      Café$$$$View Menu
      779 Montauk Hwy (btwn The Plaze & S Edison St), Montauk
      Save
      • Holiday

        Holiday • June 22, 2016Bee's knees. Amazing patio in back. Healthy breakfast, lunch and beach supplies spot. Open until 6 but kitchen closes a bit earlier.

    • 8.2
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      16 Navy Rd (Shore Road), Montauk
      Save
      • Maritza S.

        Maritza S. • July 23, 2013Better than the mussels or ceviche is their Corn-On-The-Cob, Mexi-Corn, yum!!!!!!!

    • 8.2
      RestaurantView Menu
      782 Montauk Highway (The Plaza and S Edison), Montauk
      Save
      • Jenifer

        Jenifer • October 3, 2010Yum. Fish tacos. And the smoked bluefish spread. Definitely worth it.

    • 8.1

      14. Joni's

      Sandwich Spot$$$$View Menu
      28 S Etna Ave, Montauk
      Save
      • Mike t.

        Mike t. • September 9, 2017Good for breakfast and light lunch. Healthy options and a wide array of drinks to choose from.

    • 8.1
      American$$$$View Menu
      500 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • Shiri L.

        Shiri L. • July 3, 2016Love this place! Fresh tuna steak in the tuna melt hit the spot. the fried asparagus is perfection! Definitely the most authentic Montauk.

    • 8.1
      Ice Cream$$$$
      677 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
      Save
      • The Corcoran Group

        The Corcoran Group • March 14, 2011Burgers, shakes and fries and the best homemade ice cream to boot! Try the John burger and the homemade ice cream. No website, but then who needs one for a popular place like this.

    • 8.1
      Hotel Bar$$$$
      21 Ocean View Ter, Montauk
      Save
      • Arjun R.

        Arjun R. • September 8, 2019Nicely renovated. Right on the beach unlike other properties nearby. Very kid friendly too. Got a free upgrade given that we went after Labor Day.

    • 8.0
      Seafood$$$$
      Gosman's Dock, Montauk
      Save
      • Dmitry

        Dmitry • August 29, 2012Great place for lunch or dinner. Above getaway from the glitz of the hamptons. Fish is fresh and great. Great restaurant on the water.

    • 7.9
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      541 E Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • Bogdan V.

        Bogdan V. • September 1, 2013Great food, mussles to die for, but very crowded, unbelievable sunset view when the sky its not cloudy...

    • 7.9
      Italian$$$$View Menu
      290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk
      Save
      • Alex K.

        Alex K. • August 17, 2020The Spaghetti with tomato was amazing - as well as the wagging!

    • 7.9
      Beach BarView Menu
      290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk
      Save
      • Nabil B.

        Nabil B. • August 23, 2019Nice serviced beach. Nice bar/restaurant. Nice dj. Nice crowd

    • 7.9
      Seafood$$$$
      2167 Montauk Highway
      Save
      • Jesse G.

        Jesse G. • June 4, 2021Highly recommend the tuna tostada, the fish and chips (light and delicious), of course the oysters, and the cocktails. The Como la Flour was delightful.

    • 7.9
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      500 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • Erika R.

        Erika R. • August 30, 2013Don't leave with out getting the seasonal local pie and ice cream! I had the Peach Raspberry and it was delicious!

    • 7.9
      Mexican$$$$View Menu
      364 W Lake Dr (at Diamond Cove Marina), Montauk
      Save
      • Elyse E.

        Elyse E. • July 12, 2017Get the quesadilla it's incredible! The nachos are amazing but huge so def go splitty splitty with a friend.

    • 7.8
      American$$$$View Menu
      474 West Lake Drive, Montauk
      Save
      • mikeyboxx

        mikeyboxx • August 12, 2018Great food, covered deck dining area and service was great. Heather was our waitress. Get the mussels!

    • 7.7
      Pizza$$$$
      240 Fort Pond Rd, Montauk
      Save
    • 7.7
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      17 S Edison St (Montauk Highway), Montauk
      Save
      • Ashley G.

        Ashley G. • May 12, 2012Rock shrimp linguine, tuna chipotle tacos and of course the lobster rolls are legen...dary!

    • 7.7
      Seafood$$$$
      32 Star Island Rd, Montauk
      Save
      • Nikki W.

        Nikki W. • October 1, 2020Great food. Lobster fried rice, steak are all great.

    • 7.7

      29. Hooked

      Seafood$$$$
      34 S Etna Ave, Montauk
      Save
      • Mari

        Mari • October 9, 2023The crab cakes are very good. All crab. The fries are also amazing if you like lightly crispy fries with a soft potato-y inside.

    • 7.6
      Dive Bar$$$$
      401 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • Ryan B.

        Ryan B. • August 7, 2014Karaoke on Fridays is a must. Popular with locals

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.