See all
179 photos

Hoosier Mama Pie Co.

Pie Shop$$$$

East Ukrainian Village, Chicago

Save

8.6^/10

179

ratings

Ranked #4 for pot pies in Chicago
The experts at Food Network and Time Out Chicago recommend this place
"Try the chess pie, single pies and full size pies available"(6 Tips)
"amazing seasonal creations"(3 Tips)
"Try the banana cream pie - just fantastic."(4 Tips)
"The best chicken pot pie I have ever had."(4 Tips)

67 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pies
seasonal creations
desserts
chef paula haney
coffee
meringues
great value
pastries
casual
espresso
pumpkin
quiet
pears
coconut
apples
pork
chocolate
restaurants
cranberries
Sage
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Time Out ChicagoNovember 2, 2011
Try seasonal creations (from strawberry-rhubarb in spring to apple and pumpkin in fall) and signatures (like the incomparable banana-cream) with a coffee. The pies are, in a word, extraordinary. Read more
EaterDecember 17, 2015
Swing by for some of the best pies in Chicago, including amazing seasonal creations, such as the mincemeat pie. They also take christmas orders from Dec 22nd through Dec. 24th! Read more
Toni FunkAugust 18, 2014
Forget cupcakes! This place will change your mind about pies forever. Whether it's a chess, Elvis, or classic fruit pie you cannot go wrong. Throw away your birthday cakes and grab a pie instead!
Jonathan FerreraMarch 19, 2017
The chocolate chess pie is quite great. They have a great selection of pies depending on the season. The blueberry pie is excellent as well.
Abhishek PillaiJuly 27, 2015
Check the daily pie menu on their website! And go early! They run out quick. Got the coconut custard and chocolate cream, both soo good
ChicagoistAugust 1, 2014
Don’t miss the savory pies. A pork, apple and sage creation or classic chicken pot pie will provide much needed heartiness on chilly nights like these. Read more
Lee HarrisMay 12, 2011
Amazing pies, quiches and staff. You will not be disappointed with anything on the menu. As a southerner and a recovering fatty This place is so good and dangerous-I love it! The choc chess pie is #1
Time Out ChicagoOctober 19, 2011
Try seasonal creations (from strawberry-rhubarb in spring to apple and pumpkin in fall) and signatures (like the incomparable banana-cream) with a coffee. The pies are, in a word, extraordinary.
yeji hanDecember 9, 2013
the chocolate chess pie is like a brownie in pie form. absolutely delicious!!
Food NetworkNovember 20, 2014
Get the Fat Elvis Pie — graham cracker-peanut-pretzel crust filled with chocolate, peanut butter and bananas. Read more
Food & WineApril 26, 2011
Former Trio pastry chef Paula Haney launched her bakery in 2009, but she still has a stand at the Green City Market, where she buys much of the produce for her stellar pies.
ben mApril 24, 2017
Great stuff. The s'mores pie is out of control.
Eddie SharkeyMay 29, 2016
The Apple Pie & The Rhubarb Pie are both delicious. Definitely returning.
kartik sJune 3, 2013
Try the banana cream pie - just fantastic. The key lime pie was a bit too tart for my liking.
Stephen HnatowJune 12, 2010
I'm a huge fan of the Chocolate Cream or Banana Cream pies. Recently tried the Orange Cream though, and I think it takes the cake... er... pie. Read more
Stephanie MuzzallOctober 13, 2017
Pie that dreams are made of, seating, and great value to!
Jacob BrightMarch 26, 2013
Get the passionfruit meringue or chocolate chess... or just get anything you want, it's all impressive!
USA TODAYNovember 22, 2010
Even when chef Paula Haney was baking for some of Chicago's best restaurants, she always had pies on her mind. Last March, she finally opened her own place. Try the raspberry pie. Read more
Time Out Chicago KidsJanuary 13, 2012
If you could eat summer by the slice, it would taste just like the ruby-red strawberry rhubarb pie ($23) from Hoosier Mama. Read more
Peter HardersOctober 11, 2011
I'm a banana pie connoisseur, so as an expert I can safely attest this to be the best banana cream pie to grace this planet.
Tisa MorrisMarch 18, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Simply the tastiest. Selection of pies change daily
Mabel GuzmanJune 8, 2013
The Friendliest people work here and definitely try the rhubarb pie. In fact any pie the crust is killer.
Karen SlackNovember 24, 2014
Had the espresso cream pie and what a great surprise it was delightful!:-)
Diego ReynosoSeptember 18, 2015
Try the chess pie, single pies and full size pies available
Kellen TerrettAugust 21, 2014
The best pies. Seriously. If you love pie, indulge here.
Eddy GonzalezNovember 2, 2015
Fresh ingredients and nice warm pies. Super cozy!
Time Out ChicagoSeptember 17, 2010
Paula Haney banana cream pie alone made her a farmers’-market celebrity, helping build the funds and confidence to launch a West Town pie shop in fall 2009. Read more
Serious EatsOctober 14, 2013
If you love pie, there is no better place in Chicago to indulge.
DailyCandyDecember 9, 2010
Tiny retro pie shop serves ginger cream, apple cranberry, Key lime, quiche, potpie, and scones with farm-fresh ingredients. Read more
Dan OJuly 4, 2011
WOW! Pies are unreal. They open @ 10am but sell out by noon. Nuff said Read more
MJOctober 13, 2013
OMG! It doesn't matter what you order...it's all scrumptious!
Réjane TJune 24, 2011
Been here 10+ times
The Sugar Cream pie is to die for, and their rhubarb is also amazing!
Wes RDecember 31, 2012
It's nice that you can get miniature versions of a lot of the pies.
Brad ChmielewskiJuly 3, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Grab a small chicken pot pie for lunch on your way into work.
Mat BurnettJuly 19, 2015
Everything is awesome.
JillMarch 25, 2014
Best key lime pie next to Joes Stone Crab
Blake J. GrahamMay 4, 2017
The Chicago Sunrise is a real treat
Jasmine DavilaJune 11, 2011
Try the Lemon Chess Pie - Coffee and a slice - perfect.
Colin LeeOctober 4, 2020
Excellent chicken pot pie and pumpkin pie
CarolineDecember 19, 2013
Apple, pear, cranberry pie - delish!
Amando LucasNovember 17, 2015
Lots of fresh baked pies. Love the banana
Wenola AlvaradoNovember 7, 2019
Loved it, delicious pie and cocoa
Joyce PattersonDecember 16, 2019
Loved the pie!!
Jeffrey WrightJune 9, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Skip the fancy packaging, string and business card...it will save all of us all a lot of time.
Michael S.January 3, 2016
The Apple Pie!
Edward HenryNovember 18, 2017
A neighborhood gem.
Kathleen ODonnellNovember 3, 2016
Over rated and too $$$! Plus their crust is dry🙁
TV Food MapsAugust 28, 2014
Check out Hoosier Mama Pie Company as seen on Sugar High Read more
Jessie DDecember 11, 2010
It is very small inside with only 3 tables so be prepared to take your pie to go!
Chefs FeedAugust 22, 2014
Paul Virant, chef of Perennial Virant, eats here on his nights off. He loves the Pie. Read more

1 2

179 Photos

Planning a trip to Chicago?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

Hoosier Mama Pie Co.

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Hoosier Mama Pie Co.

Appears on 220 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.