See all
515 photos

Extra Fancy

(Now Closed)

Seafood Restaurant and New American Restaurant$$$$

Williamsburg, Brooklyn

Save

Extra Fancy

The folks at Village Voice and Gothamist like this place. Would you agree?

183 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Julie VMay 31, 2015
Oh my GAD this place is AHmazing! Awesome, fun date spot. Smoked trout appetizer was YUUUM! Clambake for 2, oh momma! Yes I ate the sundae with fudge AND salted caramel by myself. Sorry, not sorry!
Samantha JoJune 26, 2015
My favorite place in Williamsburg! I highly recommend the cocktails and/or a shot and beer combo. ALL the food is awesome. Get a lot of small plates or some in a big group so you can try everything.
GothamistMarch 4, 2016
The lobster bisque fries boil down to a mound of thick-cut fries in a savory lobster bisque with a liberal scattering of lobster meat, a poached egg, and a few spoonfuls of tobiko. Delicious. Read more
Nao MizAugust 31, 2012
Fancy? Maybe. Snobby? Not at all. Sit at the bar and talk to friendly bartenders who know what they're doing. Order the oyster and scallops!! The porkbelly melts in your mouth.
GothamistJune 1, 2016
Their popular Frozémonade is served all year long. As the name might suggest, this is a rosé-based offering, combined with lemonade and whipped into a frothy, frozen treat. Read more
Village VoiceApril 3, 2015
Gold Rush; Basil Hayden's bourbon as the base, chamomile-infused honey syrup and fresh lemon. It'll make you think about all the things you can do now that your snow boots are in storage. Read more
Brian Grogan Jr.September 17, 2016
Cocktail bar / seafood restaurant with unique drinks and really good food! They're open late, until 4 AM, so it's a classy way to cap off a night out. Lobster bisque fries and frozèmonade are 😋
Staff PicksDecember 1, 2014
This is the go to place for late night eats. Make sure to try their patty melts. You can add lobster, fried clams, fried eggs, bacon, or even more patties. Read more
Kate DulubSeptember 29, 2015
Been here 5+ times
If you like tequila drinks with a little kick, get "Honey, I spiced the kids". Soooooo good😊Lobster roll, ceviche and Patty melts are to die for!Fantastic bartenders and a great vibe.Love this place!
Steve ColemanAugust 16, 2015
Great & unique frozen drink stop on balmy summer nights. Cocktails are made to order and complex, so if you have a big group try not to have everyone ordering something different (or youll be waiting)
7th.ListJuly 5, 2012
The new casual seafood restaurant from Mark Rancourt and Robert Krueger, just opened. The drinks menu offers a large of selection craft beers, ciders, wines by the glass, and house cocktails Read more
Public House WineAugust 19, 2014
The new Fish Fry lunch is anything but. For $19 you can get 2 pieces of fish, french fries, and 2 sides (we call that dinner for 2.) Lobster Roll Tuesdays = roll, fries and a 12 oz Bud for $20.
New York PostMarch 1, 2015
After midnight on weeknights, oysters and clams from the raw bar are half off and the late-night menu is packed with filling food in this welcoming Brooklyn spot. Read more
Neil MancusoJuly 17, 2013
Simply amazing 1.25$ oysters at happy hour which is 5-7pm everyday and after midnight Sunday through Thursday. Lobster rolls, fried oysters and nice whiskey.Do yourself a favor and get Extra Fancy!
Kate FurmanMay 23, 2016
Lobster bisque fries, lobster rolls, fish and chips, and corn on the cob. The cocktails are excellent here too. Open late + they have a sweet outdoor area.
Colin M. FordAugust 28, 2013
Make sure to go on Tuesday night for Lobster Roll Tuesdays: A very meaty lobster roll (normally $24), a side, and a Budweiser for $20. Great décor, really friendly staff, and ok seafood.
Allison D'EugenioJune 10, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Used to go for the cocktails and then realized they had an amazing outdoor area in back and the food was awesome. Lobster roll and Brussels sprouts are my fave.
The Meatball ShopJune 21, 2012
We've been eagerly anticipating the opening of this new gorgeous space & it is well worth the wait. Genuinely hospitable service & incredible dishes w/ a little something for all appetites & budgets.
Arielle SilvermanMarch 13, 2015
My new favorite BK spot. Amazing cocktails, and best cevice I've had in a while. Would recommend sticking to seafood/shellfish- definitely outranks meats here.
Anna PotterApril 29, 2014
Easily the best cocktails I have had anywhere in the city. The Go-To was my favorite. Great date spot, too.
Cooper SmithMay 6, 2014
For the first 29 years of my life, I was certain that I preferred Maine style lobster rolls. The Connecticut style lobster roll here made me question everything I know
Polya ShubinaDecember 14, 2013
"Breakfast croissant" is just delicious! Also, wonderful light french music and decoration makes you feel in morning heaven;)
Matthew CaldecuttJanuary 31, 2016
It's hard to get a waiter's attention to check in when you have reservation, but the bone marrow and lobster roll is worth the wait.
Laura LewisApril 19, 2017
The mussels are a must! For $16 you get a huge bowl of mussels with delicious broth and grilled bread. Amazing.
Meg FarmerOctober 18, 2016
Loved the vibe here, and the good was delish. Did a mix of oysters, the gem salad, and the mussels. Nothing disappointed.
Raivenne VenneMarch 11, 2013
The food was delicious! And if you want to to get your drink on, may a suggest the delightfully monikered "Papi...Do Me A Favor". You're going to feel it.
Sable WorthyAugust 11, 2013
Speaking for brunch only: 2 for 1 cocktails but thr cocktails are $10. Mehh. Smoked salmon w/ latkes had potential, but WHOA- the salt! Maybe I will try the doubke happy hour, but brunch? #neveragain
MarisaDecember 23, 2012
Cool vibe with chill bartenders and an amazing menu! Pork belly is cooked to perfection. A must get! Also the chicken pâté toasts is great share.
Shawna AdamsDecember 15, 2013
This place is all sorts of awesome. Had brunch here - the shrimp n grits are the best I've had, and the pork belly + kimchi eggs Benedict were divine.
Morgan GatesAugust 17, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Love this spot! Great ambiance, incredible food, tasty drinks...and a welcoming, friendly staff filled with foodie knowledge & passion. What a treat in my 'hood!
Melanie Loff-BirdAugust 11, 2017
Mussels were bomb. Great place for small groups as you can eat dinner then migrate out to the patio for more drinks
Jeshua BorgesJuly 26, 2015
1/2 off oysters, clams and shrimp, plus $5 draft wine and Prosecco and $2 Budweisers Monday-Friday 6-7pm
Gabriel HayesJanuary 8, 2016
Really enjoyed the cocktails. Very solid Moscow Mule. The Honey, I Spiced the Kids was very good as well.
Nicole MclarenNovember 3, 2012
Most gourmet food I've had in the neighborhood in a long time. The chicken pate is incredible, and an excellent option if you're not itching for seafood.
Jenny SorensenApril 8, 2015
Extra Fancy tuts at all the places whose kitchens close at midnight, perfect for those of us that love a really-late-night dinner & party vibes. Read more
Elysia MannJuly 27, 2015
Lobster bake is def the move. Get a few small plates and it can be shared with 3 people easy.
Gabriel HayesJanuary 8, 2016
Really enjoyed the Uni Carbonara. The sea urchin is a treat.
Zahrah FadelDecember 25, 2014
Go during the week! Super chill vibe with hip locals. And there's a carrot juice cocktail - get it.
Julie VMay 31, 2015
Salad with strawberries and gorgonzola. Clambake. Smoked Trout appetizer. Hot fudge sundae with salted caramel!
Claire J SongMarch 25, 2015
Gold Rush: Basil Hayden's bourbon as the base, and mix it with chamomile-infused honey syrup and fresh lemon.
Petey PMay 8, 2016
On a slow rainy night I had my first late night meal. It was a dud, the female server wouldn't give me flatware or my food bill.The male server was great and vibe ok, so I'll give it another try.
Lincoln ChinneryMarch 24, 2014
Been here 5+ times
If you love seafood and good cocktails this is the place to go.
Nicola RiskeMarch 22, 2014
Been here 25+ times
Try the Grand Experiment - delicious cocktail. Love both the food and the drinks here and the staff are awesome!!
Gabriel HayesJanuary 8, 2016
Awesome Deviled Eggs. Made with smoked trout roe, pickled mustard seeds, old bay potato chip & celery.
Jen LindbergAugust 15, 2013
Tuesday. Lobster roll with beer and a side. Get the potato fries with bacon and creme fraiche. $20.
David ZhangJanuary 2, 2017
Everything we had was great. Lobster roll was fantastic.
D. Stan O'LoughlinJuly 12, 2014
Oysters and cocktails are amazing. Fish is excellent. Garden is nice. Waitstaff knows what's up.
Meghan KathleenAugust 13, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Always sit at the bar. The bartenders and the crowd is interesting. Lots of opportunity to meet cool people.
Julie NJanuary 3, 2015
Try the "I can't even" cocktail. Pimento cheese, ceviche, and Kobe beef are other highlights.
Leah HammerschlagAugust 13, 2015
Great late night spot, awesome fried chicken and ceviche. Skip the patty melt.

1 2 3 4

515 Photos

Extra Fancy

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Extra Fancy

Appears on 972 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.