New Castle's Best
Coney Island is one of New Castle's Best.

1. Coney Island

7.6
2712 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA
American Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews
Lanigan's Irish Pub & Eatery is one of New Castle's Best.

2. Lanigan's Irish Pub & Eatery

126 E Washington St, New Castle, PA
Bar · 14 tips and reviews
Pizza Joe's is one of New Castle's Best.

3. Pizza Joe's

7.4
2700 Highland Ave Ste 1, New Castle, PA
Pizza Place · 2 tips and reviews
Jimmy's Hotdog Shop is one of New Castle's Best.

4. Jimmy's Hotdog Shop

1229-1233 S Cascade St, New Castle, PA
Hot Dog Joint · 4 tips and reviews
Bill's Sandwich Shop is one of New Castle's Best.

5. Bill's Sandwich Shop

2401-2481 Pennsylvania 18, New Castle, PA
Sandwich Place · 3 tips and reviews
PO Lunch is one of New Castle's Best.

6. PO Lunch

6.2
2402 Wilmington Rd (Hazelcroft Ave.), New Castle, PA
American Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews
Mulligans is one of New Castle's Best.

7. Mulligans

1403 Old Butler Rd, New Castle, PA
Bar · 6 tips and reviews
Marchelloni's Pizza is one of New Castle's Best.

8. Marchelloni's Pizza

418 W Washington St, New Castle, PA
Pizza Place · 2 tips and reviews
Crane Room Grille is one of New Castle's Best.

9. Crane Room Grille

8.6
3009 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA
Pub · 20 tips and reviews