Michael Thiele: Even after being forced to move to an obscure location five minutes from Starbucks, they're still brewing the best cup of coffee on the East End. Locally renowned for roasting their own beans.
3 Bay St (btw Division St & Rector St), Sag Harbor, NY
Bagel Shop · 14 tips and reviews
Michael Thiele: Are the sandwiches crazy expensive? Yes. Are the owners extremely grumpy? Yes. Are the bagels decent? Yes. Do I sometimes not want to drive to EH to get a better bagel so I come here? Yes.
Michael Thiele: Thanks to a recent change in NYS law, you can now be served a full pint of any of the offerings. Flights are still offered, and the glass is still yours to keep.
Michael Thiele: Andy Day knows how to bring in the best craft beer you can get in NH and George Craft is a magician considering the amazing food he's putting out of an extremely limited kitchen.