Petee's Pie Company

Petee's Pie Company

Pie Shop, Bakery, and Dessert Shop$$$$
Lower East Side, New York
  • Stars
  • Tips
    "My goodness, this black bottom almond chess pie is AMAZING."(15 Tips)
    Stefan M.
    "Delicious pies, gotta try the lemon chess"(6 Tips)
    Jenny R.
    "The sour cherry pie and coconut cream where delicious!!"(5 Tips)
    Bin Y.
    "Great sweet pies and the savory pies are enough for a light meal."(4 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon112 Tips and reviews
  • pies
  • lemon chess
  • desserts
  • savory pies
  • quiet
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Amy C.heart icon on user image
    Amy ChenJuly 12, 2015
    This cozy little pie shop is worthy of a dedicated visit. Grab a slice of delicious pie and a beverage of choice. I got the coconut cream pie, but will definitely be back to try the banana cream pie.
  • Taiowa W.heart icon on user image
    Taiowa WanerJanuary 10, 2017
    Been here 10+ times
    A cozy place to grab some sweet or savory pie and watch people walk by. I usually ask the staff for a recommendation on what pie to try-they all look very good and choosing is tough.
  • Ashleyheart icon on user image
    AshleyMarch 6, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Really great pies - sour cherry has a solid sweetness and great flavor. The spot is tiny, but if you can grab a seat there are a few stools along the window. They also sell bags of Parlor Coffee
  • Ambreen M.heart icon on user image
    Ambreen MolitorNovember 11, 2018
    I bought the salty chess pie for my coworkers birthday. It was the best pie I’ve ever eaten in my life. Go around noon (on a weekday) the pies are fresh out of the oven !!!!
  • Katie J.heart icon on user image
    Katie JettFebruary 22, 2015
    The blueberry pie is flawless. Lemon chess was awesome too.I wish the pecan pie had a more solid nougat-y texture, but was still pretty good. Interesting ice cram favors like goat cheese, or lavender.
  • inna k.
    inna katsDecember 24, 2018
    Quiet, open til midnight, best people, window seats & the very best pies. I wish I could bottle the smell of this tiny LES spot and bring it w/me when I need a pick me up. Coconut custard + tea 😋🤤
  • Jack H.heart icon on user image
    Jack HoflandJanuary 17, 2019
    I'll definitely be going back...often. Coco custard and NY cheese were both phenomenal. Shop has a small window bar with don't expect seating. Easy to walk and eat to go though. Cute shop.
  • Adam M.heart icon on user image
    Adam MerriamApril 14, 2018
    Cold brew is on point. Cherry pie is great. Should’ve sampled all of the pies. Best part is sitting on the stool smelling them bake the pies
  • Eater
    EaterNovember 25, 2014
    Petee's Pie Company opens just in time for Thanksgiving. They are selling pies in flavors like maple walnut, cranberry apple, cherry crumb, and sweet potato. Read more
  • Charles G.heart icon on user image
    Charles GuerreroAugust 13, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Petra makes some awesome pies. Trust me, you can't go wrong (that crust is to die for), and you absolutely can eat two slices.
  • Erin R.heart icon on user image
    Erin RathJuly 9, 2016
    Very homey little cafe -- lots of character! Plates and silverware looked like they were off a rummage sale (though clean and without chips). Old wooden counter half-missing. Good selection of pies!
  • Theresa R.heart icon on user image
    Theresa RoldanMay 26, 2016
    Apple pie with vanilla ice cream was delicious, and my friends loved the sour cherry pie. My only qualm is the limited seating....also I'm not to big on pie.
  • Dolci K.heart icon on user image
    Dolci KeyMay 30, 2018
    The chocolate ice box pie was amazing, as in I’m going to have to run another 6... or 12 miles because I already want another slice. Very sweet and rich.
  • Sean L.heart icon on user image
    Sean LlewellynApril 20, 2015
    My new favorite pie spot! The lemon chess, almond chess, and sour cherry were great. The crust is perfection, buttery and flakey, and compliments the filling nicely.
  • Markheart icon on user image
    MarkDecember 23, 2016
    My goodness, this black bottom almond chess pie is AMAZING.
  • Bin Y.heart icon on user image
    Bin YangFebruary 16, 2015
    Great sweet pies and the savory pies are enough for a light meal. In case those are out, you could always get the quiche, which is light and fluffy!
  • Bommy
    BommyApril 9, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Literally everything is good, but I'm a huge fan of all the chess pies. And the owners are so nice!
  • DJ J.heart icon on user image
    DJ JensenAugust 18, 2018
    Been here 10+ times
    Best place to buy a slice of pie up until 1am. Just walking in, you smile because the smell is amazing.
  • Elevine B.heart icon on user image
    Elevine BergeJanuary 21, 2017
    Sesame pie is a must if you like tahini, perfectly earthy!
  • Christie H.
    Christie HJune 30, 2019
    Black almond chess pie is fabulous! People-watching is also fun here on a weekend night.
  • Teresa E.heart icon on user image
    Teresa Esteban CasanellesDecember 23, 2015
    I liked the pies, you could really feel the flavours (coconut and almond) but I didn't find them to be outstanding.
  • Paul S.
    Paul SanwaldDecember 17, 2015
    Awesome selection of freshly made pies. Not much in store seating, but a nice, friendly place. I had the chocolate chess pie and it was perfect.
  • Karina
    KarinaApril 12, 2015
    Oh man that crust is so good! All of the pies are awesome, sweet and savory ones! The cheeseburger bacon pie is so delicious!
  • Nick A.heart icon on user image
    Nick AndlingerDecember 22, 2015
    I've eaten my fair share of pie, but this pie is spectacular. Especially the coconut custard 🔥🔥🔥
  • Alyssa B.heart icon on user image
    Alyssa B.October 18, 2022
    Gorgeous delicious crust with just the right amount tart/sweet to the cherry filling
  • Kinjil M.heart icon on user image
    Kinjil MathurOctober 15, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Super fresh delicious not to be missed pies. Wifey and hubby run shop. Locally sources ingredients. Gluten free options available
  • Andrew L.heart icon on user image
    Andrew LitvakMarch 4, 2015
    The pecan and chocolate chess pies are delicious. Blueberry isn't bad either. Reasonable prices, too, considering the quality.
  • Clinton L.heart icon on user image
    Clinton LauDecember 28, 2017
    Blueberry pie was amazing. The crust is what made it. Flaky, melts in your mouth. But pricey for how much you get
  • Lower East Side Partnership
    No time to bake? Stroll by Pete’s Pie Company to place your order for a gourmet pie to impress your friends and family with this Thanksgiving.
  • Emily O.heart icon on user image
    Emily OwayniJanuary 31, 2020
    Came for the Sour cherry pie, but the banana cream pie was the real winner here 🥧
  • Anuj M.
    Anuj MathurJanuary 27, 2018
    the pie is unbeatable. but the music selection is so atrocious (some abstract mix of the worst top 40 songs of the last 15 years) that you won't stay too long.
  • Mashkaheart icon on user image
    MashkaJuly 15, 2015
    Sour cherry is the best bet. Very classic recipe and balanced throughout (unlike other pies that vary w each bite)
  • Chad H.heart icon on user image
    Chad HornerOctober 17, 2017
    so many pies! always something available to please anyone. i like the salted chocolate chess
  • etta y.heart icon on user image
    etta yMarch 23, 2015
    Might be the best pie I've ever had. Buttery, flaky crust and not too sweet. Tastes like real food!
  • Christina C.heart icon on user image
    Christina ChinDecember 2, 2017
    Choc chess pie is like choc custard and best served warm! Hit with the family
  • Vivian K.heart icon on user image
    Vivian KongOctober 25, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    The second you step in, you can't turn back - the sweet aromas! Main blueberry pie is my fave.
  • Judy C.heart icon on user image
    Judy CariOctober 25, 2018
    Great pies, look out for their chocolate pecan pie which they only have as a special.
  • Jean T.heart icon on user image
    Jean TranFebruary 23, 2016
    They also make a small handful of savory pies. They are equally as good as the sweet ones
  • Peter C.heart icon on user image
    Peter CucèMarch 19, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    This place is the real deal. Some of the best pie I've had. The coconut custard :)
  • Zayed K.
    Zayed KhanJune 21, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    They get the crust just right. Buttery and flaky, but strong enough to hold the structure of a slice and not crumble too easily.
  • Jacob F.heart icon on user image
    Jacob ForsterJuly 14, 2015
    A tad pricey but worth every penny. Banana cream pie was phenomenal. Even the crust was delicious.
  • Cory C.heart icon on user image
    Cory CozzensMarch 3, 2015
    Blueberry, Cherry and Chocolate Chess are my favorites so far.
  • Marco S.
    Marco SuarezJune 4, 2016
    Best pies. Good coffee and tea. Such a great way to end an evening.
  • Clara E.heart icon on user image
    Clara EloyJanuary 6, 2022
    It was tasty but not mind blowing. It’s mainly sweet and I would have loved to taste the fruits better
  • nikkiheart icon on user image
    nikkiNovember 30, 2016
    crusts and seasonal pies are bomb. knowledgeable staff who pack every slice with care
  • Edmund B.heart icon on user image
    Edmund BoeyMarch 20, 2016
    Lemon chess pies are great! Special pies on pi day! 3.14!!
  • Lea C.heart icon on user image
    Lea CeasrineDecember 12, 2016
    Honey butter pecan 💕✨🙏🏽
  • Angelina M.heart icon on user image
    Angelina MonellFebruary 7, 2016
    Everything is delicious. All homemade. Open until midnight daily.
  • Victorheart icon on user image
    VictorSeptember 8, 2016
    Banana cream pie is so good
  • Kelli Y.heart icon on user image
    Kelli YappOctober 22, 2015
    this spot is ridiculous. gf and vegan options + homemade ice cream to serve a la mode. go.
Photos339 Photos

Related Searches

  • petee's pie company new york •
  • petee's pie company new york photos •
  • petee's pie company new york location •
  • petee's pie company new york address •
  • petee's pie company new york •
  • petee's pie company new york •
  • petees pie company new york •
  • petee's pie company lower east side new york

Foursquare © 2023  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA