Star Tavern Pizzeria

Star Tavern Pizzeria

Pizza Place and Italian Restaurant
400 High St, Orange, NJ 07050
Hours:
Closed until 11:00am (Show more)
  • Mon–Thu
    • 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
  • Fri–Sat
    • 11:00 AM–Midnight
  • Sun
    • Noon–10:00 PM
Price:
$ $ $ $
Reservations:
No
Menus:
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Credit Cards:
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi:
Free
Outdoor Seating:
No

The Star Tavern has been a traditional family favorite for delicious, thin crust pizza served hot and lively in an atmosphere humming with 65 years of neighborhood character.

8.8/10

Based on 463 votes

Lots of people like this place

Total Visitors
0
Total Check-ins
0
Save
Share
Log in to leave tips at this venue!
Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent

49 Tips

People talk about:

  • "Best thin crust pizza in NJ... the pizza is INSANE! and in Jan and Feb,..." (2 tips)
  • "... pizza in Northern New Jersey. They also make a mean peppers and eggs..." (4 tips)
  • "Scampi wings are awesome!!" (2 tips)
  • Jennifer

    You have to try ANY pizza from Star Tavern. They have the best thin crust pizza in NJ! Read more

    Jennifer · April 19, 2010
    Save
  • Serious Eats

    With some of the best bar-style pizza you will eat, Star Tavern is definitely worth the detour or trip, especially for the pizza enthusiast.

    Serious Eats · January 2
    Save
  • Lauren D.

    Pizza = AMAZING!!! Long lines on weekends but definitely worth the wait

    Lauren D. · June 22, 2011
    Save
  • Jessica C.

    Tip your waitresses well... It's only the right thing to do!

    Jessica C. · September 19, 2011
    Save
  • Ashes

    Definitely try the scampi wings!

    Ashes · December 23, 2011
    Save
  • Eleni K.

    its good to b the boss' pet. pizza n beer for lunch

    Eleni K. · October 28, 2010
    Save
  • Brian K.

    The white clam is crazy awesome!

    Brian K. · March 21, 2010
    Save
  • Peggy W.

    Fried calamari with melted mozzarella

    Peggy W. · August 28, 2011
    Save
  • Lauren D.

    Pizza = AMAZING!!! Long lines on weekends but definitely worth the wait

    Lauren D. · June 22, 2011
    Save
  • Nick

    Get a pie for yourself - maybe two.

    Nick · April 18, 2010
    Save
  • NJ.com

    Don't be fooled by the sports-bar atmosphere. This is a Jersey pizza shrine. Read more

    NJ.com · January 13
    Save
  • Ally B.

    Best pizza place in New Jersey

    Ally B. · August 1, 2013
    Save
  • New Jersey Pictures

    Starving after seeing that Resnais triple feature? You can't beat Star Tavern pizza. Thin, crunchy with the perfect amount of cheese. Best pizza in NJ, hands down.

    New Jersey Pictures · March 18, 2012
    Save
  • Lauren D.

    Pizza = AMAZING!!! Long lines on weekends but definitely worth the wait

    Lauren D. · June 22, 2011
    Save
  • Martin

    The red spinach is actually really good.

    Martin · February 5, 2010
    Save
  • Emily B.

    Can't go wrong with white clam pizza

    Emily B. · January 6
    Save
  • Adriane

    Make sure to order it well done!

    Adriane · December 9, 2013
    Save
  • Mac

    Try the Pizza!!!!!!!!!!

    Mac · October 11, 2013
    Save
  • Jason G.

    Greatest thin crust pizza of all time. Get garlic and/or pepperoni for toppinga. Dont be afraid to use wing sauces (ranch or hot) on your pizza!

    Jason G. · August 10, 2013
    Save
  • Jim W.

    Great pizza

    Jim W. · July 13, 2013
    Save
  • Leigh-Ann Z.

    Penne with vodka sauce and chicken is wonderful

    Leigh-Ann Z. · June 30, 2013
    Save
  • Rell

    Onion Blossom! Great appetizer!

    Rell · March 13, 2013
    Save
  • Stephania G.

    The food is delicious but the service is the worst ever !

    Stephania G. · January 6, 2013
    Save
  • Laura C.

    Best pizza in the state but if you order more then one don't expect it to all come at once it almost never dose

    Laura C. · December 31, 2012
    Save
  • Camillo M.

    Scampi wings are awesome!!

    Camillo M. · December 31, 2012
    Save
  • Theodora T.

    Pizza was delicious! Nice staff!

    Theodora T. · October 21, 2012
    Save
  • Leslie J.

    I love this place has the best pizza

    Leslie J. · September 27, 2012
    Save
  • Carolyn F.

    Pizza is the best, coming here 45yrs.

    Carolyn F. · May 23, 2012
    Save
  • Melquisedec L.

    Gotta try their Surf & Turf special.....

    Melquisedec L. · April 23, 2012
    Save
  • Anthony C.

    The best thin crust pizza in Northern New Jersey. They also make a mean peppers and eggs sandwich. Be prepared to wait 45 minutes. The place hasn't changed a bit in 50 years.

    Anthony C. · April 22, 2012
    Save
  • Sam C.

    If you're here, you already know it's the best pizza you can get.

    Sam C. · April 16, 2012
    Save
  • D.j. C.

    Whole wheat pizza thin crust in the best!! Ohh yeah and the buffalo wings!!

    D.j. C. · February 23, 2012
    Save
  • Brian G.

    Best thin crust pizza in the world! Amazing

    Brian G. · January 22, 2012
    Save
  • Kate

    Best pizza in the world!!

    Kate · December 20, 2011
    Save
  • Maria C.

    Best mussels in spicy marinara sauce!! Yummmmmy!

    Maria C. · December 14, 2011
    Save
  • Jason W.

    If this is the best Jersey has to offer, I'll stay on the other side of the Hudson.

    Jason W. · December 2, 2011
    Save
  • Bob A.

    Best pizza in New Jersey

    Bob A. · October 18, 2011
    Save
  • Tyler I.

    Best thin crust pizza in the world.

    Tyler I. · August 2, 2011
    Save
  • Rachel S.

    Three cheese pizza all the way!!!

    Rachel S. · June 16, 2011
    Save
  • Lesley

    The original thin crust tomato is heavenly. Also try the three cheese. The pizza here is the best pizza I have ever had.

    Lesley · June 16, 2011
    Save
  • Justin B.

    Best damn pizza hands down, and the Bufflo wings rock!!

    Justin B. · May 4, 2011
    Save
  • Justine B.

    Best thin crust pizza in NJ... the pizza is INSANE! and in Jan and Feb, Tues nights = $5 plain pie night! A STEAL if you can fight the lines!

    Justine B. · February 22, 2011
    Save
  • Justine B.

    Best thin crust pizza in NJ... the pizza is INSANE! and in Jan and Feb, Tues nights = $5 plain pie night! A STEAL if you can fight the lines!

    Justine B. · February 22, 2011
    Save
  • Rosemary R.

    Best mushroom pie ever! Order it well done!

    Rosemary R. · November 21, 2010
    Save
  • Anthony

    Star Tavern is an EthnicNJ.com favorite place for pizza in New Jersey.

    Anthony · October 18, 2010
    Save
  • Terry

    Lost my virginity here tonight.. First time here, first time eating a pizza with anchovies and first time drinking rolling rock beer.. Anything on the menu is good

    Terry · August 29, 2010
    Save
  • Marie D.

    Best pizza I ever had. I no longer can eat pizza anywhere else local bc nothing compares. the eggplant parm dinner is the amazing also, its the eggy kind NOT to bready like some other places make it.

    Marie D. · August 22, 2010
    Save
  • Amy N.

    As a former fan of Star, I am saddened that the staff was so rude and I didn't get what I ordered - instead a cold underdone pizza.

    Amy N. · March 28, 2010
    Save
  • Dave E.

    Don't order the spinach or clam pizza.

    Dave E. · January 31, 2010
    Save

More Like Star Tavern Pizzeria

Places people like to go after Star Tavern Pizzeria

Appears on 44 lists

See all »
Tina F.

Mayor: Tina F.

5 check-ins in the last 60 days

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.