4. Bakeri
9.0
150 Wythe Ave (at N 8th St), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · Williamsburg · 139 tips and reviews
Cristina F-M: seating is cramped but the hazelnut rosemary choc chip cookie is worth it. and the pain au chocolat is awesome, first one I've seen where the chocolate was still gooey.
Corinna P: You can't go wrong with the apple cider flowers, the herbal (usually rosemary) salted chocolate chip cookies, or any of their various brioches.
Jean 💜: If Steve Zissou decided to become a landlubber and open up a bakery with the BEST hazelnut rosemary chocolate chip cookies ever.
5. Ample Hills Creamery
9.4
623 Vanderbilt Ave (at St Marks Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Prospect Heights · 374 tips and reviews
Julius Tarng: The chocolate sorbet texture was real flakey and unsatisfying (compared to some other vegan ice creams around like van leeuwens)
Paul Sanwald: My favorite flavor is peppermint patty, but all the flavors are great. Get a chocolate chip cookie cone if that kinda thing sounds tasty.
Cole Kennedy: It's so hard to choose one favorite flavor, so change it up each time you go. Definitely try the chocolate chip cookie cone at some point, though. Perfect stop before or after a walk to Prospect Park.
6. Baked
8.8
359 Van Brunt St (at Dikeman St), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · Red Hook · 137 tips and reviews
karen bonna rainert: Don't skip the Brookster. It's possibly the best baked good mashup ever (chocolate chip cookie baked into a brownie).
Marc: Tasting Table Choc Chip Cookie List: "Contrary to its name, this Red Hook bakery makes a slightly under-baked cookie, giving it an ooey, gooey pecan pie-y thing we like."
Fodor's Travel: Original creations like the Brookster (chocolate chip cookie dough baked inside a brownie) and delicious interpretations of whoopie pies, blondies, bars, and cookies keep this bakery and café buzzing. Read more.
11. Almondine Bakery
8.3
85 Water St (btwn Dock & Main St), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · DUMBO · 151 tips and reviews
jeffrey w: the best guilty pleasures: the white chocolate mousse cupcakes on chocolate cake and the flourless chocolate cookies.
Serious Eats: Their croissants and chocolate chip cookies are excellent—but don't overlook their flaky-crusted squares of fruit tarts, superior oat streusel-topped raspberry muffins, or weekend jelly doughnuts. Read more.
Marc: Tasting Table Choc Chip Cookie List: "The Dumbo bakery bounced back from Sandy-shuttering. Herve Poussot's wide, crunchy, caramelly cookies are still on point"
15. Mia's Bakery
8.4
139 Smith St (Bergen St.), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · Boerum Hill · 46 tips and reviews
Mis Danny: The extra large chocolate chip cookie is fantastic. Everything looks delicious...hard to choose!
KE: I tried the large chocolate chip cookie, which had a strong taste of cream cheese. I didn't love it. I'm a huge chocolate chip cookie nerd and don't recommend these. All other pastries looked good!
Casey: I had a very cozy vegetarian bite before an event last night. Very friendly staff and tasty pastries!