1. Maison Premiere
9.2
298 Bedford Ave (btwn S 1st & Grand St), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Williamsburg · 447 tips and reviews
Mathieu Cartoixa: Oysters, cocktails, Gainsbourg... Heaven!
Tasting Table: The feel of an old New Orleans bar and one of the finest oyster selections in town—over 30 varieties ($2.50 to 3.25), and the staff is committed to fast and careful shucking at the elegant bar. Read more.
Lucie Pustova: Oysters are a must. Cocktail menu is impressive!
2. Red Hook Lobster Pound
9.0
284 Van Brunt St (btwn Verona St & Visitation Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Red Hook · 170 tips and reviews
amNewYork: Because sometimes we need to have a lobster roll at inconvenient hours, we love that Red Hook Lobster Pound sells their signature lobster salad and packages of J.J. Nissen buns from Maine to go.
Porig Salba: Lobster BLT is awesome. Only 9 bucks plus you get a piece of bacon. What more could you want? (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more.
Michael Chang: Craving a lobster roll, but can't make it to Maine? You won't be disappointed with the Maine (house-made mayo) or Connecticut (butter) lobster rolls made with a 1/4 lb of fresh knuckle and claw meat!
4. Grand Army
9.0
336 State St (at Hoyt St), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Boerum Hill · 93 tips and reviews
Amelia Tidona: Cocktails are amazing - especially sookie's mix. Mussels and deviled eggs delicious as well! Amazing ambiance and location.
Carmen N: Oysters, cocktails, shrimp cocktail, cheese plate.
Lauren Atkins: Perfect seafood spot: $1 oysters between 5-7pm...and the trout was quite delicious too. Exceeded my usual expectations of trout.
5. Littleneck
8.5
288 3rd Ave (btwn President & Carroll St), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Gowanus · 141 tips and reviews
7th.List: Whole Belly Clam Roll - Gigantic whole belly clams are fried as expertly as at any New England clam shack - greaseless, tender, crisp, and hot stuffed into a buttered toasted top-split hot dog bun. Read more.
jake furst: a very good resto. highlights are the excellent raw bar, a great scallop special, the skate entree and the whole belly clam roll. i'd skip the chowder if i were you.
Josh Eagle: Broccoli with anchovy aioli, wellfleet oysters, lobster roll, and the stellar service were all off the hook🙌
6. Brooklyn Crab
8.4
24 Reed St (btwn Van Brunt & Conover St), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Red Hook · 270 tips and reviews
The New Yorker Manager: "[F]resh cold oysters and perfectly steamed lobster, eaten in the open, relatively salty air, with a killer view of New York Harbor." Shauna Lyon on Brooklyn Crab (8/27/2012): http://nyr.kr/R50GAo
Taylor Marsh: snow crab, shrimp, crab roll, fishbowls, crab cake, beer
Michele Hughes: Crab royal was perfect for two ... Cajun style ...delicious
7. Luke's Lobster
8.6
11 Water St (Under the BK Bridge), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · DUMBO · 51 tips and reviews
Mia Jacobucci: Soooo good!!! We got it through a deal and tried the lobster, crab and shrimp rolls. I couldn't decide which I liked better!
Martin Jonasson: Excellent fast food! Go for the lobster roll and just enjoy it and life in general close to the Brooklyn Bridge.
Mike Friedlich: Amazing Lobster roll w/great butter roll and succulent lobster in a great location. Poppy cole slaw is also great.
8. Randazzo's Clam Bar
8.1
2017 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 95 tips and reviews
Village Voice: Enjoy the Seafood Combo, which comes with fried calamari, steamed scungilli (conch), shrimp, and mussels, all of it doused in that brick-red sauce. The calamari somehow maintains its crunch; the shrim Read more.
Anne: The Zuppa Di Mussels with some bread is a must try. Portions are bigger than usual.
Public House Wine: A lowbrow seafood joint that's been ravely reviewed Fresh clams , lobster fra diavolo and last-meal-status $6 lobster bisque are well worth the trip to Sheepshead bay.
9. Marlow & Sons
8.9
81 Broadway (btwn Berry & Wythe St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Williamsburg · 254 tips and reviews
Gabby K.: Amazing wine, amazing oysters and a remarkable soundtrack.
Tarah Feinberg: The seafood dishes are amazing. Oysters are fresh and delicious. Read more.
Daniela Cury: Simple and fresh food, cozy ambient. Great place to go with friends, have some wine, oysters, rosted chicken and whatever else they have available.
10. Sea Wolf
8.8
19 Wyckoff Ave (Troutman St.), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Bushwick · 58 tips and reviews
Rami Haykal-Manning: Great lobster roll, well seasoned fries and salad. Open for Breakfast, Lunch and dinner. Good addition to the neighborhood
James Kiernan: Great vibe and deliciously decadent lobster roll. Lots of open space for families. Also dig the 80s sk8 decor!
Will Scholl: Shrimp and chourico (homemade chicken sausage) was flavored impeccably. Lobster roll was delicious. Our server, Lee, was so friendly and accommodating. Excellent all around.
11. Mayfield
8.8
688 Franklin Ave (at Prospect Pl), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Crown Heights · 171 tips and reviews
Nichelle Stephens: The food is delicious! The service is great! Order the beets, the fried clams and save room for dessert.
Nick Burd: Love this place! The oysters are great, the burger is maybe the best in NYC, and the apps and drinks are always on point. The best neighborhood joint you could hope for.
The Commander: The fried egg on the dandelion salad is absolute perfection! Plus $1 oysters and draft beers for happy hour...the best!
13. Five Leaves
9.0
18 Bedford Ave (at Lorimer St), Brooklyn, NY
New American Restaurant · Greenpoint · 536 tips and reviews
Gloria Lee: Great ambiance. Great Food. Attractive service staff:) The mussel appetizer is cooked with this delicious sauce/broth and served with sourdough cubes! mmmm to die for.
Cadie Thompson: Get the ricotta to start and order extra bread. You'll need it. Mussels are excellent and if you're not getting the burger try the kale salad.
Justin Baum: Ordered a boulevardier cocktail (negroni with rye instead of gin) and it was perfectly made. Followed up with some oysters and the outstanding Five Leaves Burger with truffle fries. I slept well.
15. Lilia
9.2
567 Union Ave (at Frost St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Williamsburg · 189 tips and reviews
Raquelle Jessie: favorite restaurant. ORDER: baked clams- best i've ever had, ravioli (no need to chew because they melt in your mouth), gnocchi, agnolotti,rigatoni lemon granita, strawberry crostata.
Amanda Rella: Amazing!!!! Must get the grilled clams - so flavorful and with a kick! The agnolotti is a standout and will be ordered every time. Don't leave without having the olive oil cake. All around great!
Julia Millot: Get the clams and mozzarella toast to start, the mafaldini, gnocchi, agnolotti and spaghetti and sea bass for mains. Skip the rigatoni. Try the blowfish is you’re a fish fan and save room for dessert!