Five Points Bakery & Toast Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

1. Five Points Bakery & Toast Cafe

9.2
44 Brayton St (at W Utica St), Buffalo, NY
Bakery · Bryant · 23 tips and reviews

Tommy S.Tommy Sobol: The apple cake is DELISH

D C.D Craft: Crumb cake

Jewels B.Jewels Be: Protein toast with mascarpone cheese and orange apricot marmalade- so good!

Wegmans is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

2. Wegmans

8.8
601 Amherst St (at Bridgeman St), Buffalo, NY
Supermarket · Black Rock · 70 tips and reviews

Vinny C.Vinny C: Cake is amazing

Felecia V.Felecia Velez: Always get whipped cream frosting on your cake it is the best.

Jennifer L.Jennifer Link: Check if they have Inari at the Sushi stand. So good!

Ristorante Lombardo is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

3. Ristorante Lombardo

8.4
1198 Hertel Ave (at Virgil Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · North Park · 17 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: NB’s rec’s: Octopus is dope. Uovo en purgatorio pizza, Caesar salad made tableside, and then for dessert I love the frou frou cake and n gets the banoffe pie.

Marco N.Marco Navarra: Everything was great! Hot Banana Peppers and Mud Pie were outstanding!

Mike H.Mike Hayes: Amanda might be the best waitress ever. Not a bad thing on the menu. Feel a little full after dinner but still want to try dessert? Vanilla bean gelato! Sounds plain? It's far from it!

Lexington Co-Op is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

4. Lexington Co-Op

8.8
807 Elmwood Ave (at Auburn Ave), Buffalo, NY
Grocery Store · Delaware - West Ferry · 37 tips and reviews

JoshJosh: Best chocolate cake?

WalterWalter: Their in house turkey sandwitch with cranberry mayo is outstanding. You can also get a great cup of coffee to go! And buy some groceries.

SushiaSushia: great ready to eat items for lunch, make sure you become a member-owner!

The Black Sheep is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

5. The Black Sheep

8.0
367 Connecticut St (at 14th St), Buffalo, NY
Eastern European Restaurant · West Side · 12 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: "Then there was the sticky toffee pudding, a Bistro Europa gem. It’s like butter making love to caramel under a whipped cream canopy. Expressed as cake." Buffalo News. 100% correct. YUM

Tom P.Tom Palmer: The Burrata, clams, veal chop, and PLT were all great. We'll done cocktails as well.

Marge N.Marge Novara: Pierogis were over the top delicious. I had chicken breast on a purée of vegetables. It was great! The sticky toffee pudding with their coffee ended aa incredible meal.

The Chocolate Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

6. The Chocolate Bar

7.2
114 W Chippewa St (in Hampton Inn & Suites), Buffalo, NY
Cocktail Bar · Central Business District · 41 tips and reviews

Naomi F.Naomi F: The mojitos, cheesecake and creme brulee are pretty awesome. Great for date night or girls night

Kelly R.Kelly Roux: Ice cream desserts are big enough to share, chocolate martinis are okay. Red velvet cake is the bomb

Anna C.Anna Corder: You've got to get the Build your own S'mores!!! Freaking amazing!!!

Toutant is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

7. Toutant

7.9
437 Ellicott St, Buffalo, NY
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · Central Business District · 17 tips and reviews

Carrie Yael R.Carrie Yael Rittenhouse: The " gris-gris" biscuit to start! The buttermilk fried chicken was to die for and ended with ooey gooey bourbon caramel cake! ! Fabulous..and try the "Packmule" yum!!!

Jon S.Jon Spitz: Great service, vibe, cornbread and desert. Get the coffee themed desert and add liquor. You will NOT regret it.

Michael C.Michael Constantine: Hush puppies, jambalaya, corn bread, French 75, crowdsourced, & pack mule

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

8. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que

8.5
301 Franklin St (btwn W Chippewa St & W Tupper St), Buffalo, NY
BBQ Joint · Central Business District · 58 tips and reviews

PunchPunch: ribs here are awesome. As well as cheesecake! #Go to go!!#

JoshJosh: Great BBQ and nice atmosphere. Always busy, make a reservation first.

Gabi B.Gabi Bulumac: Get a full rack Bar-B-Que pork ribs with Sam Adams ;)

Anderson's Frozen Custard is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

9. Anderson's Frozen Custard

8.7
2634 Delaware Ave (in Delaware Consumer Square), Buffalo, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · North Delaware · 31 tips and reviews

Laketa C.Laketa C.: Pistachio frozen custard! my fave, yum! Call to see if they have it before you go, it's a special flavor they have once in a while.

Elliott V.Elliott Vance: Sponge candy ice cream is the titties

Cara A.Cara Ann: Seasonal Special: Hot Apple Crisp Sundae. Yum!

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

10. Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé

7.7
1292 Hertel Ave (at Crestwood Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · North Park · 23 tips and reviews

Libby M.Libby MacDougall: Cassata cake!

Jewels B.Jewels Be: The scallops were perfectly done and the pasta portions are huge! Either share a plate or be ready to take half home in a doggie bag. The tiramisu is delicious!

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: I'm addicted to their sweets, the Florentine's are fantastic and cheap. Good Italian food as well but the bakery is what keeps me coming back.

Bailey Fish & Seafood is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

11. Bailey Fish & Seafood

8.4
3316 Bailey Ave (at LaSalle Ave), Buffalo, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Steve L.Steve Liverpool: I enjoy seafood and this is a welcome site with lunch, combos, and dinner meals of all sorts. If ever your in town for a game or visiting. Check them out!

Paulette B.Paulette Banks: Getting Haddock Combo Dinners

Anita R.Anita Richley: THE OWNERS AND EVERYTHING - TRUST ME IT IS SOOOOOO WORTH THE WAIT

Billy Club is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

12. Billy Club

8.1
228 Allen St, Buffalo, NY
New American Restaurant · Allen · 3 tips and reviews

Matthew F.Matthew Ferguson: Gray vibe. Varied cocktail list. Get the mai tai if you like tiki drinks. Authentic!

Colette H.Colette H: Bar staff is friendly and knowledgable.

Bradley H.Bradley Homer: Din din to the darlings 🥃🍶🍵

Globe Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

13. Globe Market

7.4
762 Elmwood Ave (at Auburn Ave), Buffalo, NY
Sandwich Spot · West Side · 44 tips and reviews

Diana S.Diana Schaefer: For something sweet the Strawberry Shortcake is amazing.

Christofer M.Christofer MacDonald: Hummus wrap Rocks! Get the garlic hummus! 😀

Niki K.Niki K: Just not sure it's worth the prices they charge but good for a quick bite - diverse selection of vegetarian and non veg - see pic of skimpy roasted veggie sandwich

Oliver's is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

14. Oliver's

8.6
2095 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · Park Meadow · 20 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Watson: Great fasnachts on the dessert menu. Warm and airy.

Adam Robert B.Adam Robert Bartha: U.S.D.A. Prime Filet Mignon • yukon gold mashed potatoes, broccoli & foie gras butter

Brandi S.Brandi S.: Lemon drop martini....Yum!

Osteria 166 is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Buffalo.

15. Osteria 166

8.4
166 Franklin St (at W Mohawk St), Buffalo, NY
Trattoria · Central Business District · 26 tips and reviews

Anthony C.Anthony Crain: The service here is above and beyond amazing. The chef even came out to discuss options and pick food with me, then we crafted our own taste test experiment!

Chris S.Chris Smith: Excellent service, good food, solid wine list, and the friendliest owner in the city. A great place for happy hour and dinner.

Rachel G.Rachel Gottlieb: If you're unhappy about anything, Nick will bend over backwards to fix it. Plus the food is great.