Skyline Chili is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

1. Skyline Chili

9.0
3693 Fishinger Blvd, Hilliard, OH
American Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

Rick B.Rick Brock: The baked potatoes are fantastic

Mike S.Mike Singleton: Have you tried the hot sauce yet? Just a few drops will do you

Nick A.Nick Albright: Ask for a habanero cheese on your Way or Coney for an extra kick.

Cooper's Hawk is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

2. Cooper's Hawk

9.2
4230 The Strand (Worth Ave), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · Easton · 69 tips and reviews

Ann L.Ann Lodder: The surf and turf is great! Do a wine tasting only with Therese!

dana 🍓 .dana 🍓 : Complimentary Mimosa or Bellini with brunch? Ok!

Joshua S.Joshua Swearingen: Food is outstanding and the wine selection isn't to be missed. Wine club is absolutely worth it and it's a great date night out. Wear nice clothes or risk having the Waite staff treat you poorly.

Kitchen Social is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

3. Kitchen Social

8.8
8954 Lyra Dr, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews

Ralph M.Ralph Meyer: Very helpful, efficient and helpful staff. We had a wonderful brunch. Breakfast Tacos, French Toast, Shrimp and Grits, and Biscuits and Gravy. Highly recommend, reservations needed.

Ben B.Ben Barr: Great blackened shrimp pasta

Ben B.Ben Barr: Blackened shrimp pasta is amazing

Lindey's is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

4. Lindey's

9.0
169 E Beck St (at Mohawk St), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 62 tips and reviews

Stephen C.Stephen C: Worth the mile walk. Do not miss. Sunday brunch on the patio in nice weather. Eggs Lindey.

Columbus Food AdventuresColumbus Food Adventures: Lindey's has a great happy hour - which you can also enjoy out on the patio. There's a bar out there too!

Courtney E.Courtney Elson: I don't care how full you are, get the chocolate bread pudding! Omg it's ureal! Pass on the Lobster Bisque.

Cap City Diner is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

5. Cap City Diner

8.8
1299 Olentangy River Rd (at Fifth Ave), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 78 tips and reviews

Jenn C.Jenn Clancy: Great Gluten-free options! Even has gluten free bread

John A.John Asendorf: Save room for dessert

Billy W.Billy Wemlinger: Meatloaf. Meatloaf. Meatloaf.

Third & Hollywood is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

6. Third & Hollywood

8.5
1433 W 3rd Ave (Hollywood), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 46 tips and reviews

KathrineKathrine: Croque Madame, burgers, fries, cocktails, biscuits

Mark S.Mark S.: Biscuits. Get biscuits.

Bill L.Bill Litfin: Saltiest food in town. Even the steamed broccoli is salty.

The Guild House is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

7. The Guild House

8.6
624 N High St, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

Niki B.Niki B: I loved the decor of this restaurant. They blended trendy colors with classic and farmhouse furniture. My favorite dishes of the night were the tuna ribbons, brussels sprouts, and the smoked trout.

Katie B.Katie Brownfield: Brussels sprouts were amazing.

Jen M.Jen Marquez Ginn: Duck pate was awesome. Smoked trout was great. Loved the pork. Nice atmosphere. Dance music playing, which was an interesting choice. Good beer & cocktail selection.

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

8. BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse

8.8
4020 Stelzer Rd, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

Kayla K.Kayla Kitchen: Good selection of home brews

Dominic S.Dominic Salvucci: Cheese sticks and Flatbreads are excellent. Happy Hour 3-6 PM

Ronda D.Ronda Despas: Wings and a flight! Very cozy atmosphere! Great food selections! 24 pages!

The Old Mohawk is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

9. The Old Mohawk

8.3
819 Mohawk St (at Kossouth St.), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 42 tips and reviews

Maxwell P.Maxwell Posival: Awesome! One of the best Bacon Cheeseburgers I have ever had

Chris S.Chris Skovron: In the winter, the vestibule is the warmest place in Cbus.

Francie G.Francie Griffith: Reuben is good and they have really great wedge salads!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

10. The Cheesecake Factory

8.2
1566 Polaris Pkwy # 124 (at Polaris Mall), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 63 tips and reviews

Stacy K.Stacy Krajci: The Godiva cheesecake was excellent! Portions are huge even the kids had huge portions! An adult couple could def share a dish and then split a slice of cheesecake for dessert. Food was superb! 👍😋

Meghann C.Meghann Cleary: Best Happy Hour in the Area!

Sara C.Sara Cleary: Erica is a pretty sweet bartender!

The Sycamore is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

11. The Sycamore

8.3
262 E Sycamore St (6th St), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

Kane T.Kane Thompson: Brussels, chicken fig and great old fashions

jireselljiresell: Very good craft beer selection. We had the guacamole (good and spicy) and the burger, delicious. Highly recommend sitting outside.

Asha A.Asha Augustine: Don't get the Braised Ohio Beef Cheeks sandwich. The bread was soggy and there was an asinine amount of garlic that made it difficult to eat!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

12. The Cheesecake Factory

8.3
3975 Townsfair Way Easton Town Center (Easton Town Center), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 91 tips and reviews

Debra V.Debra Vedder: Always a great meal here. Love the brown bread!

Jason M.Jason McLaughlin: Don't care about calories or the size of your ass? Welcome to The Cheesecake Factory!

Corey H.Corey Holliday: Amazing food, great location. If you're eating here be sure to ask for Ashley, she's very nice and a great server

J Alexander's is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

13. J Alexander's

8.6
7550 Vantage Dr (btwn E Campus View & Dimension), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · Crosswoods · 44 tips and reviews

Daniel T.Daniel Tiernan: Prime rib Maui w Caesar salad rocks..great service..comfy chairs 4 yur rear..no wooden stilts here.

cobicobi: food is always good- but today they screwed up over half of our meals.

Brent A.Brent Allen: Great filet!

Tip Top Kitchen & Cocktails is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

14. Tip Top Kitchen & Cocktails

8.6
73 E Gay St (at Third St), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 120 tips and reviews

Charles G.Charles Gresham: Salmon is great fritters and sandwich great sauce

Amy K.Amy Karnes: Try the pot roast sandwich...comes on a pretzel bun!

Liz S.Liz Sonnanstine: Ditto on the sweet potato fries and fresh salads too Read more.

Club 185 is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in Columbus.

15. Club 185

8.6
185 E Livingston Ave (at Mohawk St.), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 40 tips and reviews

John Z.John Zajac: Courtney, server extraordinaire, was quick, courteous and pleasantly knowledgeable about the club's cuisine. The fries were fresh cut and wonderful.

A F.A Fox: I live an hour away and I am here at least once a week. It's my favorite spot in German Village (maybe cbus). Love the staff, atmosphere, music, seating, and food. Basically, 185 makes me happy.

Chris S.Chris Stocker: Beef on Weck Thursdays. Get it. Just get it! And pile on the horseradish!