Marcella's is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

1. Marcella's

9.1
615 N High St (at Poplar), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 68 tips and reviews

Krystina D.Krystina Darfus: Amazing food amazing service and amazing drinks. Chicken piccata is hands down best dish ever! Also the bruschetta is to die for. The meatballs slice like butter and melt in your mouth. Wonderful time

Lindsey K.Lindsey Klun: Olive oil is made from olives that are pressed into oil!

Amanda B.Amanda Brehm: Great giant meatball! :)

Giuseppe's Ritrovo is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

2. Giuseppe's Ritrovo

8.8
2268 E Main St, Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 18 tips and reviews

Sarah C.Sarah CJ: It's not listed, but you can get gluten free bread and almost all of the pasta can be made gluten free! They serve gluten free pasta as well. Delicious little gem!!

Kris M.Kris Misevski: Oh man! So good. Best drinks ever!!

Jackie S.Jackie Smith Jr.: My first trip to Giuseppe's Ritrovo. I am very pleased with the service and food!!! Great environment!!!

Basi Italia is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

3. Basi Italia

8.8
811 Highland St (Buttles), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 31 tips and reviews

Scioto ValleyScioto Valley: The cozy atmosphere, tasty cuisine and ever-changing wine list make this the perfect spot in Columbus for date night.

Horacio N.Horacio Nieto: Amazing atmosphere and patio!

Columbus Food AdventuresColumbus Food Adventures: If it's your first time make sure you get the zucchini pronto. It's the best zucchini ever tasted (with olive oil, pecorino and almonds)

BRAVO! Cucina Italiana is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

4. BRAVO! Cucina Italiana

8.7
3000 Hayden Rd (Bethel Rd.), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

Chelsea S.Chelsea Stamp: Crispy shrimp Napoli. Chicken chop salad. Beef ravioli. Chicken scallopini. Chicken bacon spin. flatbread. Lobster ravioli. Filet Toscano with Gorgonzola. Sketchbook Cab and Pinot noir. Happy eating!

None N.None None: The Italian wedding soup tastes like the bride came in it.

joy c.joy chambers: Bread pudding

Scali Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

5. Scali Ristorante

8.6
1903 State Route 256, Reynoldsburg, OH
Italian Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

Ellen O.Ellen O'Dell (RealtorGal71): Love this place. Food was excellent and service was exceptional. Had the Manicotti and Artichoke Salad. Delicious!

Tom H.Tom Higgins: Can't miss with anything here. Lasagne is terrific, order early because they sometimes run out.

Tracy H.Tracy Heitmeyer: Chicken Marsala is to die for! Wonderful desserts- try the cheesecake w fresh berries.

Brio Tuscan Grille is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

6. Brio Tuscan Grille

8.2
1500 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews

Nicole K.Nicole Kirch: Amazing bruchetta and pasta dishes. Peach tea was also unique and wonderful. Beautiful indoors and patio, although the patio is in the parking lot, fyi.

Ryan P.Ryan Pratt: Try the Gorgonzola Steaks. Best steaks in town. Better than any steakhouse.

MichelleMichelle: Bistecca Insalata is delish

Brio Tuscan Grille is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

7. Brio Tuscan Grille

8.1
3993 Easton Sta (at Easton Town Center), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 48 tips and reviews

sara mae p.sara mae pickle: The best patio at Easton- lovely ambience. Always loved everything I’ve ever ordered & had good service each time as well.

Joseph T.Joseph Tsoi: Lobster Bisque

Cindy C.Cindy C: The lobster bisque!

Martini Modern Italian is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

8. Martini Modern Italian

8.5
445 N High St, Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 50 tips and reviews

Presley B.Presley Burley: Popular for Happy Hour downtown. I recommend making reservations for dinner, especially if you're traveling w/ family. You can't go wrong with Mozzarella Cheese as an appetizer paired with a red wine!

Nicholas T.Nicholas Tebbe: Don't really like it when employees take mayorships of long term patrons who support their business. Seems counterproductive to me

Jared B.Jared Bitner: Sit @ the bar and make sure James makes your drinks!

Piada Italian Street Food is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

9. Piada Italian Street Food

8.1
2585 E Main St (at S Remington Rd), Bexley, OH
Italian Restaurant · 39 tips and reviews

jireselljiresell: The wraps are big and delicious. Dip it in the tomato soup for even more flavor! Big outdoor seating area!

Delilah N.Delilah Nunez: The wine is cheaper than a soda! At 1.25 it's a steal!

David G.David G: Horrible service they r really cheep on the food. Not coming back again!

Piada Italian Street Food is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

10. Piada Italian Street Food

8.1
1315 W Lane Ave (btwn Northstar & Kenny), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 58 tips and reviews

Esen A.Esen Andiç: Wonderful comfort food on the healthier side :) priced okay as well

Jayme H.Jayme Hoffman: PIADA STICKS!!!!!

Tom V.Tom Vance: Chuck Norris was here, he said the chairs were too light

Villa Nova Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

11. Villa Nova Ristorante

7.9
5545 N High St (btw W Lincoln Ave & W Staton Ave), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 35 tips and reviews

Kourtney F.Kourtney Fedor: So much good! Great Italian family atmosphere

Leslie®Leslie®: Cozy and love the Clocks!

Claire C.Claire Chen: Wedding soup and bread sticks everytime!

Moretti's is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

12. Moretti's

7.9
5849 Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH
Italian Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

Christina W.Christina Waugh: The service was great ! Loved tomatoe salad , the veal Marsala , eggplant parm , and veal Morettis were all hits also !

Mark B.Mark Bodnar: I recommend anything. It is impossible to go wrong. Moretti's may have the second best alfredo I've ever tasted (mom is first...always).

Steve P.Steve Petrosino: This is one of the 2 best Italian restaurants we have experienced. Ever. And that includes 4 trips to Italy! Tommy Moretti is a culinary master!

Carrabba's Italian Grill is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

13. Carrabba's Italian Grill

8.0
8460 Lyra Dr, Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

Nicole K.Nicole Kirch: Ah, Carrabbas. One of my favorite places, hands down. Pollo Rosa Maria and Sirloin Marsala are the best dishes in my book. Their fresh ingredients, including their bread and herb mix is to die for.

Lisa D.Lisa Doll: Best sangria

Shawndy Spider Throat P.Shawndy Spider Throat Parker: Bryan Chicken Was Amazing!!!

Olive Garden is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

14. Olive Garden

7.9
2439 Taylor Square Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH
Italian Restaurant · 26 tips and reviews

Sarah C.Sarah CJ: Great service! Try the seafood Alfredo

marc f.marc fequiere: WOW!!!!!!! best garlic bread ever! Can't say enough about the Salad

Jay B.Jay Baldwin: Unlimited soup and salad isn't on the menu, but is one of the best deals. :)

Olive Garden is one of The 15 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus.

15. Olive Garden

7.7
7160 Sawmill Rd (at I-270), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 19 tips and reviews

Taylor W.Taylor Watkins: I love dipping the breadsticks in the Chicken and Gnocchi soup. Oh my goodness I can't get enough of that stuff!! I'm so glad they serve endless soup.

Brandie W.Brandie Williams: Me likey breadsticks

MatthewMatthew: Ask for Matthew S as your server.. he rocks. ;-)