Northstar Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

1. Northstar Cafe

9.0
951 N High St (at 2nd Ave), Columbus, OH
Café · Short North · 153 tips and reviews

easyColumbuseasyColumbus: Veggie Lover? Stop by Northstar for one of the best veggie burgers you'll ever have. Also try on of there cookies (they're amazing) and our fave - the homemade ginger-ale. Read more.

LaurenLauren: Their chocolate truffle cookie is the best cookie I've ever had.

Bacon G.Bacon Gibson: Grab a chopped salad & peanut butter cookie for dinner on your way home from work. It's good for what ails you.

Northstar Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

2. Northstar Cafe

9.0
4241 N High St (Deland Ave), Columbus, OH
Café · 96 tips and reviews

Grace C.Grace Cooper: Enjoy on-sale delicious cookies the morning after they were baked... Still delicious and cost less! : ) Read more.

LaurenLauren: Their dark chocolate truffle cookies are on my Top 10 list of best things I've ever eaten.

Steven T.Steven Turner: Omg cookies!!!!!! Yum!

Shadowbox Live is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

3. Shadowbox Live

8.6
503 S Front St, Columbus, OH
Theater · 36 tips and reviews

Neil J.Neil Juliano: The cookies are awesome

Theresa W.Theresa Whittington: The fresh cookies are to die for...

Kristopher W.Kristopher Weiss: The food is much better than it should be - chicken Philly was delicious. The house band is amazing and "Which One's Pink? is a must-see for any Floyd fans out there. Don't miss it.

Resch's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

4. Resch's Bakery

9.1
4061 E Livingston Ave (at S Yearling Rd), Columbus, OH
Bakery · 36 tips and reviews

Diane M.Diane Meves: Cupcakes, cakes, cookies

Amber D.Amber Dugan: Everything!! Freshest donuts I've ever had. Gorgeous cookies. I love this place. We make sure we stop on every trip we make to columbus.

Bridget S.Bridget Smith: The best glazed yeast donuts in the city

Starbucks is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

5. Starbucks

8.3
6130 Gender Rd, Canal Winchester, OH
Coffee Shop · 21 tips and reviews

Juan Israel O.Juan Israel Ortiz: The Pumpkin Spice Latte is awesome! Add a chocolate chip cookie in, and you're good to go.

HeatherHeather: Confetti Sugar Cookie 🧡💛💚💙❤️🍪

HeatherHeather: Iced Cinnamon Almond Milk Macchiato yum!!! 👍🏻👍🏻

Brewdog Dog House Hotel is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

6. Brewdog Dog House Hotel

8.7
96 Gender Rd, Canal Winchester, OH
Hotel · South Columbus · 1 tip

Jen C.Jen Cunningham: Amazing! We’ll definitely go back. Dog friendly with a dog park on site. We stayed in a dog friendly room that had a patio. Beer at check in and a stout & cookie from 7-9. Breakfast is also delicious!

Allison K.Allison Kasic: Have a complimentary beermosa with your breakfast

Graeter's Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

7. Graeter's Ice Cream

9.2
2136 Bethel Rd (Pickforde Dr), Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 24 tips and reviews

Leyna S.Leyna Slivka: I love Graters! It's very inexpensive, and has great taste! Personally I love there cookies and cream ice cream

SURESHKUMARAN E.SURESHKUMARAN EASWARAN: Believe it or not!Each and every flavor has its own lingering taste.Service is too good, they give you a scoop of each flavor to taste patiently.Chocolate Chip topped wit butter scotch was jus amazing

CameronCameron: Buckeye Blitz is AMAZING

Smith Farm Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

8. Smith Farm Market

8.1
3341 Winchester Pike (Watkins Road), Columbus, OH
Farmers Market · 7 tips and reviews

Patricia I.Patricia Imler: Love this market produce fresh good cookies and pies

Michelle W.Michelle Wessel: Dutch apple pie is amazing

Stephanie L.Stephanie Livingston: The Georgia peaches are the best

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

9. BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse

8.3
1414 Polaris Parkway, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 103 tips and reviews

HeidiHeidi: My husband and I had their deep dish BJ's combo pizza, then their peanut butter s'more cookie for dessert, both very good.

Guy M.Guy Merrill: Pizza, beer and ice cream and cookies!

jireselljiresell: I like the beer variety here and the food is very good. Huge portions, I recommend sharing.

The Melting Pot is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

10. The Melting Pot

8.2
4014 Townsfair Way (at 17th Ave), Columbus, OH
Fondue Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews

Irina L.Irina L.: Definitely do not skip dessert! Cookies'n cream marshmellow dream is in fact a dream!

Trelawny B.Trelawny Buley: The "Big Night Out: France" is Ah-Maze-Ing

Kim B.Kim Burdett: You have to go here...dinner is an experience rather than just a meal...plan on it taking a while, but it is totally worth it!

Sonic Drive-In is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

11. Sonic Drive-In

7.9
1031 Gemini Pl, Columbus, OH
Fast Food Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

NicolieNicolie: Winter time: get the Spiced Sugar Cookie Blast <3

Mickey H.Mickey Hawk: Get the tots--not fries.

Lizzy Leigh .Lizzy Leigh 🐈: The new, fresh brewed iced teas are relish!

Trader Joe's is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

12. Trader Joe's

9.2
3888 Townsfair Way (at Easton Loop W), Columbus, OH
Grocery Store · 36 tips and reviews

Sally W.Sally Wilson: Cookies, hummus

Angela D.Angela Diyanni: Turkey burgers, banana chips, and Mexican coffee SO good!

Jen⭐️ P.Jen⭐️ Parmentar: Try the Cookie Butter. It is sooo yummy!

Clown Cone Candy & Confections is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

13. Clown Cone Candy & Confections

9.1
3431 Cleveland Ave (Innis Rd.), Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 3 tips and reviews

Kelly H.Kelly Hamme-Baldwin: Excellent excellent ice cream and candy brings back the old days

xlizzymonae ..xlizzymonae .: Cheapest candy in Columbus a must shop

Airius T.Airius Tide: best ghetto styled hot dogs ever

Dairy Queen is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

14. Dairy Queen

7.5
960 Oakland Park Ave (at Maize Rd), Columbus, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · North Linden · 3 tips and reviews

Chip B.Chip Bradford: I got the royal prep blizzard and it was simply amazing... Oreo cookies, strawberries, and fudge!!

Channing R.Channing Ross: Service is ridiculously slow! I ordered 1 regular hot dog. I've been here for 15 minutes. :-/

Size3onmahfeetSize3onmahfeet: Service sucks 3 people working the shift BUT only one serving customers... Then after the wait the product is not right! Don't bother drive pass

The Little Ice Cream Shoppe is one of The 15 Best Places for Cookies in Columbus.

15. The Little Ice Cream Shoppe

7.8
3229 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard, OH
Ice Cream Parlor · 9 tips and reviews

Melissa D.Melissa Dubois: The peanut butter brownie, peanut butter, and cookies and cream are so delicious.

Ashley F.Ashley Fuller: The white chocolate raspberry cheesecake is amazing! My brother also said the dulce de leche was the best he's ever had! The owners are so warm and inviting as well! Check it out!

Lori T.Lori Takos: Homemade ice cream is the best!