The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

1. The Cheesecake Factory

8.6
8701 Keystone Xing Ste 4A (at E 86th St), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 94 tips and reviews

Fanta D.Fanta Dickerson: There the best cheesecake ever and i love eating there

TonyTony: Best cheese cake in town

Amy R.Amy Randall: Get the Hershey bar cheesecake, it's the best!

Taylor's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

2. Taylor's Bakery

8.6
6216 Allisonville Rd (at E 62nd St), Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · 23 tips and reviews

April G.April Gregory: The best cakes and cupcakes! The cake is so good and the icing is even better. Full bakery including cookies, candies, and donuts. And try their homemade ice cream.

Danielle C.Danielle Croyle: It’s all so yummy and the store has a great atmosphere! They even did my wedding cake and people still to this day rant about Taylor’s having the BEST white cake they’ve ever had!

Martha H.Martha Hofacker: Taylor’s bakery has some of the best sweets, I personally love the white cake and angel food cake! Light and fluffy with sweet, creamy icing! Always a staple for a family gathering/holiday!

The Cake Bake Shop is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

3. The Cake Bake Shop

8.6
6515 Carrollton Ave (65th Street), Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · Broad Ripple · 21 tips and reviews

Dana P.Dana Parker: Macarons, croissants, cakes, all the pastries you can dream of!

PJ S.PJ Steele: Cakes, pies, bars! It's all good, although I'm hooked on the Lemon Bars!! I've fallen in love with the Nropolitan Cake 🍰✨

CS_just_CSCS_just_CS: Cakes and pies have all been delicious and over the top. Carrot cake and chocolate silk pie have been my favorites. Several flavors of macaroons to choose from as well.

Shapiro's Delicatessen is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

4. Shapiro's Delicatessen

8.6
808 S Meridian St (bt Sycamore & W McCarty Sts), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Downtown Indianapolis · 97 tips and reviews

Zach S.Zach Steiner: Pastrami. Rye. Try to save room for cake or pie.

Carrie S.Carrie Savage-Zimmerman: Corned beef, pastrami, Mac'n cheese. Incredible desserts, esp. Lemon cake. Pricey. Worthwhile every so often.

Dougie R.Dougie Rocks: I've been eating here for over 50 years. Corned beef on rye, potato pancakes and the best cheesecake in the city!

Long's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

5. Long's Bakery

9.0
1453 N Tremont St (at W 16th St), Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · Near Westside · 109 tips and reviews

Cleopatra B.Cleopatra Bilal: Blueberry cake is the Best!

Falcone Volkswagen Subaru Saab & FalconeFalcone Volkswagen Subaru Saab & Falcone: Our dealership offers Long's do-nuts everyday to our customers! And they are happy to have them! Delicious! Order their cake for your special occasion...they are just as good!

SamSam: Everything! Cinnamon Fries, blueberry cake, yeast... list is endless!

Huddle's Frozen Yogurt is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

6. Huddle's Frozen Yogurt

8.3
1356 E 86th St (at Monon Tr), Indianapolis, IN
Frozen Yogurt Shop · Nora - Far Northside · 43 tips and reviews

AmandaAmanda: Get the red velvet cake.

Jessie M.Jessie Munn: such a great deal, and so many awesome flavors. red velvet cake is where it's at!

JuliusJulius: Cake batter and Red Velvet cake are amazing

BRICS is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

7. BRICS

9.1
901 E 64th St (at Cornell Av), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Parlor · Broad Ripple · 56 tips and reviews

Jason W.Jason Williams: Fantastic ice cream and shop is right on the Monon Trail. Big thumbs up for the yellow cake batter with swirled fudge. Read more.

Ali B.Ali Burger: Cake in Ice cream! Earth friendly everything! Great all around

Tony J.Tony Jones: Carrot cake ice cream is incredible!

Sahm's Place is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

8. Sahm's Place

8.8
2411 E 65th St (at N Keystone Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Bar · Glendale · 41 tips and reviews

Steve S.Steve Smiley: Steak sandwich and sour cream coffee cake are awesome.

Ana C.Ana Contreras: Coffee Cake

Shawn D.Shawn Dickensheets: Mmmm. Brunch! Instead of toast, opt for a slice of coffee cake!

The Flying Cupcake is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

9. The Flying Cupcake

8.6
423 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Cupcake Shop · Chatham Arch · 28 tips and reviews

Indy Marriott DowntownIndy Marriott Downtown: The Cheeky Cherry Cheese is amazing! White cake flavored with almond, topped with cheesecake & cherry filling...to die for :) Read more.

Nikki G.Nikki Guzman: Carrot cake & German chocolate cake are thee best!

Joshua M.Joshua Moore: The velvet elvis is the perfect mixture of red velvet cake, chocolate chunks, and cream creams. Its very large and filling.

3 Sisters Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

10. 3 Sisters Cafe

8.0
6360 Guilford Ave (Main St.), Indianapolis, IN
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 76 tips and reviews

Teresa G.Teresa Goble: The lemon corn cakes are delicious!

Heather V.Heather Voigt Powell: Lemon corn cakes with fresh berries! Off the chizzy.

Ryan H.Ryan Hamlett: Mira is awesome. Get the sweet corn cakes!

Heidelburg Haus Cafe & Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

11. Heidelburg Haus Cafe & Bakery

8.5
7625 Pendleton Pike (at E. 42nd St), Indianapolis, IN
German Restaurant · 28 tips and reviews

AmeethaAmeetha: Coffee lovers get the mocha cheesecake layered cake from the bakery. For food, try currywurst.

Flossie A.Flossie Avey: Wonderful German deli and great cookies. Best cakes in the city. I have been eating a Heidleberg cake with rum fudge for all of my 30 birthdays!

Lee B.Lee Byron: Eclectic shop with authentic food, baked goods, amazing cakes, and tons of trivia and gifts.

Thai Taste is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

12. Thai Taste

8.3
5353 East 82nd Street (Allisonville), Indianapolis, IN
Thai Restaurant · 29 tips and reviews

Lori S.Lori Sirtosky: Excellent family-owned Thai restaurant on Indy's north-side. Try the sole fillet steamed in ginger. A-mazing! Also leave room for dessert. Homemade coconut icecream and rum cake. Heavenly!

CheapismCheapism: As you can guess, they have good Pad Thai which is $6.95 during lunch. Their lunch specials come with soup, salad, spring roll and rum cake. Large portions for small prices. Read more.

Hillary Q.Hillary Quick: The rum cake is delicious!! I'm guilty of buying a whole cake.

Gigi's Cupcakes is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

13. Gigi's Cupcakes

7.5
8487 Union Chapel Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Cupcake Shop · Keystone at The Crossing · 13 tips and reviews

Taylor S.Taylor S: The icing is delicious! cake is too. Make sure you go early before all the specials run out!

Jessica H.Jessica Hurt: Love these cupcakes... worth the 15 minute drive from my house. Strawberry Shortcake is very yummy!

Lyz A.Lyz Agnew: their wedding cake flavor is amazing.. not just your average vanilla at all!

Delicia is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

14. Delicia

8.7
5215 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Latin American Restaurant · Meridian Kessler · 24 tips and reviews

Jesika G.Jesika Gunter: Yummmm!!! Tamales and beef corn cakes are delicious!

Nancy Q.Nancy Quincy McDermott: Tamal corn cakes are awesome!

Michelle M.Michelle Madden: The Tamal Corn Cakes are the most popular menu item for a reason. So good!

The Flying Cupcake is one of The 15 Best Places for Cake in Indianapolis.

15. The Flying Cupcake

8.7
5617 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN
Cupcake Shop · Butler - Tarkington · 29 tips and reviews

Mab G.Mab Graves: The CARROT CAKE is so the best! Oh, plus: make sure you get a little gnome put on top!

Dawn H.Dawn Huntley Stamper: Here Comes The Bride! Don't know anyone getting married soon but craving the sweet delicious wedding cake??? Here is the solution! <3

Maria A.Maria Alviz: Satisfy your sweet tooth with some of the best cupcakes around. When you go, try the Blueberry Cream Cheese or the Red Velvet Elvis! The Flying Cupcake also offers vegan and gluten free options.