Long's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

1. Long's Bakery

9.3
1453 N Tremont St (at W 16th St), Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · Near Westside · 101 tips and reviews

CheapismCheapism: Amazing doughnuts, some say the best in town. This cash only spot is family owned and serves doughnuts for 50 cents a piece. The Yeast doughnut is a must try. Read more.

Jamie Emerson W.Jamie Emerson Willis: Best doughnuts in the city!

Chris I.Chris Ilich: Best doughnuts in the city no question. Cash only and sometimes really busy, but worth all of that. Chocolate dipped yeast is to die for, you'll be lucky if they have them

BRICS is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

2. BRICS

9.1
901 E 64th St (at Cornell Av), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Shop · Broad Ripple · 53 tips and reviews

Jason W.Jason Williams: Fantastic ice cream and shop is right on the Monon Trail. Big thumbs up for the yellow cake batter with swirled fudge. Read more.

Jonna P.Jonna Patel: The chocolate chip cookie dough was amazing.. ;)

Stephon G.Stephon Gilder: The chocolate chip cookie dough is amazing!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

3. The Cheesecake Factory

8.9
8701 Keystone Xing (at E 86th St), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 92 tips and reviews

Fanta D.Fanta Dickerson: There the best cheesecake ever and i love eating there

TonyTony: Best cheese cake in town

Stan O.Stan Olson: Chicken and biscuits are amazing! Way too much food though! (Must save room for dessert!)

Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream & Java is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

4. Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream & Java

9.2
9922 E 79th St (Fall Creek Road), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Shop · Geist · 23 tips and reviews

James R.James Ross: They're chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream is the best in town!

Julie S.Julie Sawyer: Fantastic homemade ice cream, big variety, even exotic green tea flavor. Support locally owned/run stores like this!

Kieron M.Kieron Mitchell: They make the ice cream in the back, roast their own coffee and the graham cracker was amazing.

Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

5. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream

8.3
427 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Shop · Downtown Indianapolis · 44 tips and reviews

Shane W.Shane Weinbrecht: Best ice cream I have ever had!

Ryan S.Ryan Sawrie: Very unique ice cream experience! Terrific flavors and mix in options - you get to build your own ice cream creation.

Brandy C.Brandy Craig: Cinnamon Vanilla Premium Ice cream with Toffee is delicious

Huddle's Frozen Yogurt is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

6. Huddle's Frozen Yogurt

9.0
1356 E 86th St (at Monon Tr), Indianapolis, IN
Frozen Yogurt Shop · Nora - Far Northside · 43 tips and reviews

Jessie M.Jessie Munn: such a great deal, and so many awesome flavors. red velvet cake is where it's at!

Eva L.Eva Lyford: my expert blend: red velvet yogurt topped with pineapple (non fat!) yogurt and coconut & pineapple toppings.

Jessica R.Jessica Ranalli: Wish they had more dairy free options, but their orange sorbet is awesome

Trader's Point Creamery is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

7. Trader's Point Creamery

8.6
9101 Moore Rd (at W 92nd St), Zionsville, IN
Ice Cream Shop · 25 tips and reviews

Everest C.Everest Castillo: Their blueberry ice cream , is great , if you have time take a walk on the path in the back , ( self guided tour) I'm sure as fall approaches it will be even nicer !

Courtney M.Courtney Merkel: Ice cream and environment to die for!

Wade S.Wade Stinson: Very good icecream!

Insomnia Cookies is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

8. Insomnia Cookies

8.5
809 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Dessert Shop · Broad Ripple · 11 tips and reviews

Ashley J.Ashley Jackson: 12 cookies for $12 & you MUST try the s'mores chocolate cookie!!!!!! Yum-yum!!!

Dana P.Dana Parker: Double chocolate mint cookies are the shiz

Sarah S.Sarah Saturday: Warm cookies for a late night snack, yum!

South Bend Chocolate Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

9. South Bend Chocolate Company

8.2
30 Monument Cir (at N Meridian St), Indianapolis, IN
Dessert Shop · Downtown Indianapolis · 42 tips and reviews

Andie M.Andie Meise: the peppermint ice cream is superb!

Jennifer A.Jennifer Alexander-Maharry: Best place to get hot chocolate and ice cream!

Tushar K.Tushar Khandelwal: The ice cream is to die for. The variety of flavors is very interesting

The Flying Cupcake is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

10. The Flying Cupcake

8.7
423 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Cupcake Shop · Chatham Arch · 26 tips and reviews

Trevor Y.Trevor Yager: The Red Velvet Elvis is amazing. Try one (or three) and you won't be disappointed.

Abby N.Abby Nool: Red Velvet Elvis is the BEST!

Indy Marriott DowntownIndy Marriott Downtown: The Cheeky Cherry Cheese is amazing! White cake flavored with almond, topped with cheesecake & cherry filling...to die for :) Read more.

Graeter's Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

11. Graeter's Ice Cream

9.1
5560 North Illinois Street (56th Street), Indianapolis, IN
Ice Cream Shop · Butler - Tarkington · 10 tips and reviews

Paul C.Paul C: The best French pot made ice cream!

Maggie S.Maggie Swan Akers: Delicious ice cream (and I'm a serious snob). Also they sell Hello Kitty jelly bellies and other candies.

Julius S.Julius S.: The black raspberry chocolate chip and the mocha chocolate chip are the best! While you're at it get a rewards card. It's free and you can eventually get a free ice cream!

Taylor's Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

12. Taylor's Bakery

8.6
6216 Allisonville Rd (at E 62nd St), Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · 12 tips and reviews

Jim C.Jim Cota: The fried Danish is likely the best doughnut on planet Earth. Beware of the addiction!

Jeremy O.Jeremy Ott: Try a Bavarian Creme Doughnut. Enjoy the best chocolate icing ever on a doughnut.

Kat S.Kat Slauzis: Try the red velvet cake donut - yum!

The Flying Cupcake is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

13. The Flying Cupcake

8.9
5617 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN
Cupcake Shop · Butler - Tarkington · 27 tips and reviews

Kt F.Kt F.: Red velvet Elvis or strawberry are my absolute fave!!

Patrick F.Patrick Flanagan: Don't forget, they sell delicious ice cream as well

Roddrea S.Roddrea Smith: Try the red velvet one! It wi change your life.

Goose The Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

14. Goose The Market

9.4
2503 N Delaware St (at E 25th St), Indianapolis, IN
Gourmet Shop · Fall Creek Place · 72 tips and reviews

Ben H.Ben Hilmer: Great coffee and gelato. Most importantly their sandwiches are unlike anything you can order this side of the Atlantic.

Darren C.Darren Chittick: The gelato is amazing! Read more.

ChristinaChristina: All the sandwiches are fantastic, and do not forget to get a cookie, too! They are thick, buttery, nut-filled and delicious.

General American Donut Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Indianapolis.

15. General American Donut Company

8.2
827 S East St, Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · Fletcher Place · 11 tips and reviews

Katie S.Katie Skillman: Love this cute & simple donut shop :0) Options change daily, but if you're a coconut fan you won't be disappointed with that one...Seattle Stumptown coffee and lattes served...really great atmosphere

Tarja H.Tarja Harney: The people were great and the donuts were excellent.

Steven B.Steven Barnett: Great donuts, great coffees too. Really cool environment! Great people to recommend their favorites too, why wait try it now!