Shane Co. is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

1. Shane Co.

8.8
8111 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN
Jewelry Store · No tips or reviews
Barrington Jewels is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

2. Barrington Jewels

8.6
3916 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Jewelry Store · Castleton · 9 tips and reviews

GinetteGinette: Mitra STUNNED us with her talented design! I could not be happier with my engagement ring! It is Gorgeous and exceeded all my expectations!! Can't wait to get my wedding bands from Barrington!

JenJen: What a great experience I had picking out an engagement ring for my fiancee! No pressure, great input from Mitra, and lots of questions about what the ring needed to be for US.

LillianLillian: What a wonderful place! My husband bought a new ring for me for our 30th anniversary. We shopped at many different Jewelers and found Barrington a joy to work with. Mitra was so kind and fun.

Distinctive Diamonds is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

3. Distinctive Diamonds

8.4
8557 River Rd (86th St), Indianapolis, IN
Jewelry Store · Keystone at The Crossing · 8 tips and reviews

QZ S.QZ Smith: Diamonds Direct - New name same Excellent place, awesome service. See NIKKI, she is amazing, truly helpful, excellent friendly, professional customer service. definitely willing to work you with!

Khristina L.Khristina Loving: Completely awesome service and a beautiful showroom!

John S.John Scott: Top notch customer service. No sales pressure, just as it should be.

Reis-Nichols Jewelers is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

4. Reis-Nichols Jewelers

8.6
3535 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
Jewelry Store · Keystone at The Crossing · 9 tips and reviews

Tim J.Tim Jennings: Nicole is the very best!!! I will always ask for her.

Brian A.Brian Anderson: Cole Hale is an amazingly helpful guy - it's all about you with him. Zero pressure - 100% satisfaction. Ask for him!

Melissa F.Melissa Feathers: Their customer service is beyond impeccable. We have been assisted by Aaron for almost a decade now, and every purchase has been fantastic. The other sales associates even know that we're "his". Lol

G Thrapp Jewelers is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

5. G Thrapp Jewelers

8.2
Indianapolis, IN
Jewelry Store · Butler - Tarkington · 8 tips and reviews

Lizzie E.Lizzie Evans: Best jeweler in Indy hands down. Ask for the owner, Gary, or Mary...you can't go wrong. Their customer service is top notch!

New RadarNew Radar: Ask for Ryan or Gary. They'll definitely take good care of you!

Kyle W.Kyle Willis: Ida and Dana were very helpful and professional. Great place for fine jewelry

Tiffany & Co. is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

6. Tiffany & Co.

7.8
8701 Keystone Xing, Indianapolis, IN
Jewelry Store · Keystone at The Crossing · 3 tips and reviews

Kat D.Kat Doherty: Wonderful customer service! A smaller store, but beautiful pieces!

Heather S.Heather S: Audrey Hepburn was right, you can never be upset at Tiffany’s...the top notch customer service always makes you feel special even if you are only just looking

Jasmine O.Jasmine O'Conner: I love this store.

Homespun : Modern Handmade is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

7. Homespun : Modern Handmade

9.0
869 Massachusetts Ave (10th St. & Mass Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
Arts and Crafts Store · Downtown Indianapolis · 9 tips and reviews

Visit IndyVisit Indy: One of the coolest shops in Indy with a great supply of unique, hand-crafted and local gifts. If you're anywhere near Irvington, you have to stop by!

Karina O.Karina Oertel: Must shop store in Indiana!

Maria A.Maria Alviz: This store offers a variety of homemade goods! The staff is also friendly.

Silver in the City is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

8. Silver in the City

9.0
434 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Gift Store · Downtown Indianapolis · 24 tips and reviews

Josie F.Josie Fine Lane: Absolutely my favorite shop on Mass Ave...for anything. Quirky gifts, jewelry, local artist's handiwork displayed simply and beautifully. I can't not buy a Harriet on each visit

Julie S.Julie Sawyer: Swoon over the great selection of jewelry, then head over to the books for some good laughs.

Stacy H.Stacy Hoehle: Fun, unique gifts. For the hard to buy for person, get them something original from here!

Inner Path is one of The 9 Best Jewelry Stores in Indianapolis.

9. Inner Path

8.0
7673 Shelby St (US 31), Indianapolis, IN
Miscellaneous Store · 4 tips and reviews

Barbara C.Barbara Castile: Annie is the best. Everyone here is very friendly and helpful. Love this place. Come every Friday night for class.

Brandon H.Brandon Hunt: Great staff here. They have an excellent selection of gifts, jewelry, crystals, incense, and much more. Their tea is great, too!

Barbara C.Barbara Castile: I love this place. It's like going home.